Citizen Rules...Cinemaesque Chat-n-Review

We rarely agree about movies.

__________________
It's what you learn after you know it all that counts. - John Wooden
My IMDb page

Who? me and you, Mark? We could be MoFo's Siskel and Ebert They use to argue like cats and dogs sometimes, but it was all good.

You say most of the dialouge is pointless, as a Pulp Fiction fan I would say only a small portion of it can be removed (but it shoudn't ), you do have a good argument.

I want to refute by pointing out that all Tarantino films are an exploitation of some sort. In Pulp Fiction the thing being "exploited" is the dialouge. The dialogue of the film is a writer's nightmare- conversations pop out of nowhere and the events are out of basic order, and so on. The cleverness and daringness, almost obnoxiousness behind it is awesome.

Plus I really like when dialogue isn't used to drive the plot, instead sit back, relax, and seem to chat with the audience. It's entertaining, fresh, and way more enjoyable. It still is a revolution today.

Considering your film taste disliking parts of Pulp Fiction is understandable, just wanted to let you know that not everything thrown in the long 150 minutes is a waste.

I've been on the portion that passes through Castle Crags in Northern California. Here is a brochure: http://www.parks.ca.gov/pages/454/fi...ochure2014.pdf

Watched it this afternoon and after reading your review wasn't sure how I'd feel about it. Turned out I liked it a lot.

Firstly, I’m not a hugely experienced hiker but I love it every time I’m out surrounded by nature- even when I’m a disgusting mess and I feel like I’m going to pass out or vomit from exhaustion. For me, I’m pushing myself out of my comfort zone physically but also mentally. I love hiking because of how connected I feel with myself and everything around me but what always surprises me are the random thoughts that will pop into my mind. That’s what the flashbacks during the movie reminded me of and Cheryl was reflecting on everything that brought her to where she was, as a person and in that moment on the PCT.

I may have felt a more personal connection with Cheryl because I could relate to some of the significant events in her life. My dad passed away a month after I turned 21 and it has been the most devastating event I have experienced. I won’t spoil the scene for others who may still want to view the movie, but the day after my dad died someone called extremely early in the morning; My mom and I picked up the phone at the same time but she responded to the caller first. The caller was asking my mom if she would donate my father’s eyes. I was frozen and speechless because it was such a heartbreaking conversation to have and also overhear. Needless to say, I started sobbing when I saw one specific scene in the movie.

Found this article that included most of the quotes I liked:

http://www.ranker.com/list/wild-movi...-and-tv-quotes

My favorite quote was: “Cheryl, if there's one thing I can teach you, it's how to find your best self and when you do, hold on to it for dear life."

There were many moments I related to but what stood out the most was how a person can become unrecognizable to others and even themselves when they are grieving.

I could probably go on and on about this film but I’m going to stop here: Wild may not be the best movie I have ever seen but I liked it a lot and highly recommend it.

Thanks CR for peaking my interest and getting me to watch it sooner!

Haven't finished it yet, but so far it is worth reading. My best friend also enjoyed the book.

You might want to check Cheryl's Dear Sugar column from The Rumpus if you are curious to see how she writes:

http://therumpus.net/sections/blogs/dear-sugar/

Thanks for posting your thoughts Funny Face. I'm glad you liked it and found some personal truth in it. It seems you made a personal connection to the story that I didn't. I can only image your reaction to the eye donation scene, that must have been hard to watch for you.

On a lighter side, I did have one connection to the movie. In the scene where Cheryl takes off her shoes, then loses one as it rolls down the mountain side...happened to me. When I was in my early 20s, me and two friends were climbing in the Cascades in Washington state. We reached this rocky outcropping that was very steep and I did not want to climb it. I was nervous about it as it was a free climb (no ropes) and a fall would be deadly. So I took off my shoes and got half way up, then got stuck and accidentally dropped a shoe just like Cheryl did. It must have rolled a couple hundred feet down so there was no way I could get it. I tossed my other shoe as it wasn't no good to me, and I went to the top and back down bare foot! To make matters worse I then had to walk a mile up a gravel road to reach the car. My feet were sore! and bleeding.

At least you were able to give it another go, CR. As others have said, I find merit in your criticism. I myself haven't watched the film for a long time now and, in part, that's because I just don't want to sit through The Gold Watch segment. Even when I absolutely adored the film I felt it was the weakest part and that degenerated down to not wanting to see it.

__________________
5-time MoFo Award winner.

I must have seen Pulp Fiction at least ten times in full and more than twenty in parts. The last time I saw it was at the cinema last year, that was fantastic. It's a shame you don't enjoy it that much

__________________

Gatsby, this might surprise you but I agree with what you said about the dialogue in Pulp Fiction. I actually really liked it and for the same reasons you mentioned.... but only up to the point of the last scene in the diner where Samuel Jackson goes on and on with his speeches. That felt to me like a rehash of what Quentin had wrote earlier in the film and felt contrived. So did Quentin's scene with Harvey Keitel.


Any specific part of the Gold Watch segment or all of it? I really liked Bruce Willis and Maria de Mederiros scenes together. I noticed their relationship and dialogue felt much different than the rest of the movie. They spoke to each other gently and with affection, that was believable. However the scene inside the pawn shop was just disgusting. I don't care to see a man being raped by another man. Not to mention the whole bondage thing and the Gimp character was just too over the top.

Without that scene and Quentin's scene with Harvey Keitel and the scene in the junk yard with Julia Sweeney, I would have gave the film a 4/5

That sounds like quite an experience! Hope you didn't lose any toenails! Do you still go out hiking? What parts of the PCT have you been on? The Pacific Northwest is beautiful. My family lived in Washington about a year before we moved to California. In the last few years I've been taking trips to Oregon and I've completely fallen in love with the state. I hope to move there one day.

Have you seen Redwood Highway? It's on my watchlist and looks like it has similar themes to Wild.

No lost toenails just sore feet! Do I still go hiking? Sadly I haven't in the last 3 years. After getting married me and my wife would go to Mt Rainer at least once a month for a good hike. I'm long over due.

I don't remember what part of the PCT trial it was. I was on another trail and it intersected the PCT trail and I seen the sign and though it was cool, but I don't remember where. I really like Oregon too. I have thought about moving there. What part of Oregon do you want to move to?....I haven't seen Redwood Highway.

The scenes between Willis and de Mederiros the only scenes which worked pretty well in that segment, IMO, but really, the whole segment doesn't really work for me and I feel the writing is the worst of the three segments, too. The scene with Quentin in the house is silly, but I quite like it and once Keitel turns up and starts ordering the hitmen about, he steals the whole scene and makes it work well for me.

Don't get me wrong, the first 10 or 20 times I saw PF, though it was always me least favourite part, it didn't dread it like I do now.

Attachments

 

I love Bend, but realistically I'm thinking Portland because there may be more opportunities for me there careerwise; Also, only a 3 hour drive to Bend so I could visit easily (vs the 6.5 hour drive I have now!). Any specific areas of Oregon you like?

I'm adding Pollack to my watchlist! Marcia Gay Harden is a great actress.

I really like just about every spot in Oregon that I've been in. But I haven't been to the eastern side. I've been camping there quiet a bit on the west side.

Attachments

 

I'm glad you enjoyed Time After Time. I think every time travel movie has some plot holes, but you just have learn to look past them sometimes.

Hi GBG, no I don't mean time travel holes. I mean

Yes, that would have worked too, and it would have made more sense than what she did.