The Fall of the House of Usher, Miniseries, 2023
Siblings Roderick (Bruce Greenwood) and Madeline (Mary McDonnell) are the heads of the sprawling Usher empire---a pharmaceutical company that wields immense power and seems to always elude justice for their many criminal and immoral acts. But things take a dark turn for the family as Roderick’s children begin dying in gruesome and mysterious ways. Present at all of the deaths is a strange woman (Carla Gugino), who has a connection to the Ushers’ early history.
Horrifying and humorous in turn, this is a fun interpretation of many of Edgar Allan Poe’s famous works.
I have often had a mixed reaction to movies and shows that try to take classic stories and give them an incredibly modern spin (“It’s
Hamlet, but at a tech startup company!”). To often there’s minimal creativity involved as the only spark comes from seeing how all of the elements are updated.
In the case of this miniseries, however, the framing story---the true history of Roderick and Madeline Usher---is very compelling, and the cast of characters are very enjoyable.
Greenwood and McDonnell are strong leads, both of them playing characters who have clearly weathered many storms and who always have their eye on the big picture. But the absolute anchor of this series is Gugino, a character whose exact nature remains elusive, but she is by turns eerie, sarcastic, seductive, and vengeful. The character, sometimes called Verna, doesn’t fall into any shallow “devil as a woman” tropes. She has a point of view on the people whose deaths seem to be very much her business, and she manages the neat trick of being a character who is scary and who I found myself rooting for.
And boy is it easy to root for Verna the more we get to know the Ushers. They are all, save sweet granddaughter Lenore (Kyliegh Curran), monsters, so crippled by never having faced real challenges that they think that the use and abuse of the people around them is just the way of nature. Perry (Sauriyan Sapkota) is the worst kind of rich kid who fancies himself a business genius with his idea of exclusive sex parties. Vic (T’Nia Miller) wants to be famous for developing a new heart mesh, and is willing to kill, mutilate, and torment an endless supply of chimps to put her name on the map. Tamerlane (Samantha Sloyan) is a wellness guru wannabe, who is so allergic to real intimacy that she can only get off watching her husband role-play with sex workers. Leo (Rahul Kohli) is a drug addict who “creates” video games and cheats on his sweet boyfriend. Camille (Kate Siegel) is a PR guru who wouldn’t know a genuine emotion if it kicked her in the butt, and she gleefully exploits in every way possible the two young interns who work for her. Oldest son Frederick (Henry Thomas) has a dopey mannerism that masks a deep and unsettling cruelty when he feels betrayed.
The portrayal of all of the Ushers shows us just how normal they find it to use anyone or anything they want in order to satisfy their desires. There’s a common thread of not just a lot of debauchery, drug use, consumerism, but specifically of exploiting those who are powerless. They cling to bribery and non-disclosure agreements, caring only about their public image and not a single bit about the countless number of people they have harmed.
Overall I liked the re-imaginings of the different Poe stories/poems. It doesn’t try to get too cute with it, and wisely lets some of the sequences be more nods to the originals than blow-by-blow revamping. I liked that there are little details that might stick out to you if you know the original stories, but they are also compelling enough scenarios to make an impression. While the Ushers are figures of comedy in many sequences (“Well I can’t have them coming over to my place.” “Oh, right, because of all the hookers”), they have a deeply cruel streak that shows itself more and more as the series goes on. They might be buffoons, but they are the worst kind of buffoons: buffoons with money and power and endless resources. Buffoons who can do something truly terrible to another person, place a phone call, and have the police report torn up or “lost”.
I also enjoyed the way that the series is framed. A prosecutor named Dupin (Carl Lumbly) meets Roderick in the crumbling home where Roderick and Madeline grew up. Under the pretense of a confession, Roderick tells Dupin of the family’s recent misfortunes.
I also must devote a short paragraph to Ruth Codd, who plays Juno, Roderick’s most recent wife. Juno is a character who feels like a throwaway at first. Just someone to be around to remind us that Roderick likes to sleep around. But Codd’s snappy line delivery makes an impression, and later in the series Juno becomes a more significant character. She takes a tremendous daily dose of one of Roderick’s medication which is notorious for causing addiction and deaths, and so she symbolically is a defense to what Roderick and his family have been accused of. I found Codd incredibly charming and I was delighted any time she was included in a scene.
Generally I thought that this series was a lot of fun, and I appreciated that it stuck the landing.