Best portrayal of Catherine Earnshaw

Merle Oberon

Anna Calder-Marshall

Juliette Binoche

Orla Brady

Charlotte Riley

Kaya Scoledario

I can't really say as I haven't seen all of them and not all the way through. When I saw Juliette Binoche – which was probably the first time I'd seen her at all – her French accent was a massive distraction. One thing I had forgotten until recently is that she plays Cathy Linton as well, so that was good.

I can't really say either. I far prefer her daughter, Catherine Linton, so I pay a lot more attention to her portrayal rather than her mother's.

Oh, I love Kate Bush's song from her perspective if that counts

I prefer the 1939 film, so gonna go with Merle Oberon.