Estimated Remake Budgets included (just for kicks)
The Raven 1963 ($100 mil)
The Odessa File 1974 ($30 mil)
Zardoz 1974 ($30 mil)
Mad Max 1979 ($80 mil)
Silent Running 1972 ($60 mil)
Soylent Green 1973 ($80 mil)
Planet of the Apes 1968 ($150 mil)
Moby Dick 1956 ($100 mil)
Bring Me the Head of Alfredo Garcia 1974 ($25 mil)
Seven Samurai 1954 ($80 mil)
The Seventh Seal 1957 ($60 mil)
Quest for Fire 1981 ($80 mil)
Wait Until Dark 1967 ($40 mil)
Dune 1984 ($100 mil)
Today it appears that many "directors" believe that if you use the title of a film then you are making the remake. Some stories have been perverted to being completely new and ruined or the language is ruined.
I would agree - a movie needs changes in the script to give it "original" character. However, a true remake follows the original story, characters, and changes the script only in ways remaining true to the content and language of the original. For instance, I would completely rewrite lines and scenes for Zardoz but I would largely remain true to the story and use the same characters. But I would also heavily change the look of the film.
With Dune I would return more to the novel. I love David's take (for the most part - some major casting mistakes and it ran too short). Moby Dick and Quest For Fire would also refleck the novels (although I would make changes to Quest For Fire in many regards), Soylent Green would return to the novel.
Seventh Seal and Bring Me The Head would largely stay true to the original scripts (with overall polish and redress) and undergo major production changes.
I would love to remake the above list of films (produce/write/ and in cases even direct) bringing my own approach and art concepts (or employing those I like).
Anybody got $800,000,000?
Why remakes? Some stories warrant a new take (better production) or a story is good enough to play again in the theatre (which means you need a new version).
What would you like to remake?
The Raven 1963 ($100 mil)
The Odessa File 1974 ($30 mil)
Zardoz 1974 ($30 mil)
Mad Max 1979 ($80 mil)
Silent Running 1972 ($60 mil)
Soylent Green 1973 ($80 mil)
Planet of the Apes 1968 ($150 mil)
Moby Dick 1956 ($100 mil)
Bring Me the Head of Alfredo Garcia 1974 ($25 mil)
Seven Samurai 1954 ($80 mil)
The Seventh Seal 1957 ($60 mil)
Quest for Fire 1981 ($80 mil)
Wait Until Dark 1967 ($40 mil)
Dune 1984 ($100 mil)
Today it appears that many "directors" believe that if you use the title of a film then you are making the remake. Some stories have been perverted to being completely new and ruined or the language is ruined.
I would agree - a movie needs changes in the script to give it "original" character. However, a true remake follows the original story, characters, and changes the script only in ways remaining true to the content and language of the original. For instance, I would completely rewrite lines and scenes for Zardoz but I would largely remain true to the story and use the same characters. But I would also heavily change the look of the film.
With Dune I would return more to the novel. I love David's take (for the most part - some major casting mistakes and it ran too short). Moby Dick and Quest For Fire would also refleck the novels (although I would make changes to Quest For Fire in many regards), Soylent Green would return to the novel.
Seventh Seal and Bring Me The Head would largely stay true to the original scripts (with overall polish and redress) and undergo major production changes.
I would love to remake the above list of films (produce/write/ and in cases even direct) bringing my own approach and art concepts (or employing those I like).
Anybody got $800,000,000?
Why remakes? Some stories warrant a new take (better production) or a story is good enough to play again in the theatre (which means you need a new version).
What would you like to remake?
__________________
R.I.P.
R.I.P.
Last edited by GodsOtherMonkey; 02-01-10 at 10:39 PM.