Gangs of New York (2002)
Ok... I watched this for the first time when I was 14 and remember loving it. Daniel Day Lewis' character, in particular, left an impression to this day. I didn't watch it since then, so when I chose it as my nom it was with the intention of rewatching what I was expecting to be a great film. I mean, it's a Scorcese and it features the two greatest actors alive, so I couldn't see where it could go wrong.
Well, now I do. The ratio of hollywoodesque cliches per minute is way too big, the script is subpar to say the least and the acting doesn't make justice to the cast. I mean, Daniel Day Lewis is excellent because he doesn't know how not to be and he's the one who carries the film for the most part, but the rest is just not good enough. Leo seems to be doing a parody of himself, and Diaz is all looks and no talent. There's a few of secondary characters that seem cool but they don't get enough screen time.
The ending is just beyond ridiculous, the movie loses track of itself and it gets totally anticlimatic. And that last scene with New York changing as the burial ground gets diluted... What the f* is that?
Now, there are surely some great moments (almost all of them around the character of Bill the Butcher) and for an almost 3 hour film the pacing is quite well done because it rarely drags. Particularly when no voice-over is involved (it almost never worked in a Scorcese film yet the man insists), the dialogues loosen up and the film flows. I also liked the social critique behind all this and how uptodate its message is, especially in the States, but I feel a lot more could have been done in that regard. The setting is also extremely well built and the soundtrack goes from impressive to "what is this song doing here?".
This is without a doubt my least favourite own nom in the history of these HoFs. I'll stand behind my choice but this won't do well here.
+
EDIT: The write up is a bit more negative than the rating but that's because I know this had the potential to be glorious and it's not, which is so annoying!