My Favorite Year - 1982
Directed by Richard Benjamin
Written by Norman Steinberg & Dennis Palumbo
Starring Peter O'Toole, Mark Linn-Baker
& Jessica Harper
I don't think I've ever seen an 80s comedy as well-mannered, inoffensive and generally clean as
My Favorite Year, mirroring the 1950s cultural epoch it's character is thinking back to. That's despite it's Errol Flynn stand-in, Alan Swann - played convincingly by Peter O'Toole - being something of an alcoholic louse. If he's discovered naked in a park carousing with a girl we hear about it instead of see it, and his dialogue never takes a crude turn. I'm sure in real life, Errol Flynn would have been swearing and telling any nearby confidante the most outrageously personal and descriptive things about what he's been doing. That's just life - especially intoxicated life.
My Favorite Year isn't life. Rather it's an image of 1950s America that only exists on Christmas cards and advertisements of the time. It has been mythologised in the imagination of one Benjy Stone - the role Mark Linn-Baker found himself wrestling with at the very beginning of his career.
Benjy Stone is thinking back to his "Favorite Year" - and more specifically, one of the events that happened to occur during that year. It's 1954, and Stone (really Steinberg, changed to obfuscate the fact he's Jewish) works at 30 Rockefeller Plaza as a writer for the variety show Comedy Cavalcade which is a weekly television production. Famous, swashbuckling movie star Alan Swann is to appear on this week's show, and so Benjy has his hands full keeping the always troublesome Swann under control and romancing co-worker K.C. Downing, played by the gorgeous Jessica Harper who really isn't given enough to do in the film's screenplay. In the meantime, the show's star, King Kaiser (Joseph Bologna) is being threatened by mob boss Karl Rojek (Cameron Mitchell) due to some unflattering sketches the former has taken the lead in. Rojek's threats appear to signal that Kaiser is in imminent danger which could be waiting around every corner.
Like almost everything in this film, the threat to Kaiser ends up materializing into something deflatingly tame (getting roughed up by some goons) and not very memorable. The only thing really keeping the show going is Peter O'Toole's charisma and his attempts to breathe vigor and life into Norman Steinberg and Dennis Palumbo's cautious screenplay. As already mentioned, O'Toole's Swann gets up to drunken antics, but they're stopped far short of being truly outrageous. He's never the slightest bit offensive, nor does he cause anyone (save the worrying producers of the show) trouble. The height of his playfulness has him dropping into a party from the floor above by way of a firehose, but even this middle act climax doesn't set us on edge (Swann plummeting to his death would surely have have made this Benjy Stone's least favourite year.) For a comedy writer, Benjy also has a surprising lack of wit* and Mark Linn-Baker makes us yearn for the real Mel Brooks, Woody Allen or Carl Reiner, on whose recollections this film is based.
Although screenwriter Norman Steinberg had experience as a writer for a televised comedy show, it was Mel Brooks and Woody Allen being writers for
Your Show of Shows which inspired this film. Errol Flynn did make an appearance on the show, and King Kaiser relates to Sid Caesar who headlined the production. Brooks worked as Executive Producer on this film, but let it be known that Flynn's appearance on the show was uneventful in the end, and merely an inspiration for the initial screenplay. Another interesting connection with real life takes the form of Herb Lee (played by Basil Hoffman) who always whispers what he wants to say to others, so that this person can relay whatever that message is. Apparently Herb is based on Neil Simon, who would whisper his ideas to others to make them known instead of shouting above all the others who would be making a lot of noise in the writer's den. In the film this whispering is just an eccentricity of the character. 30 Rockefeller Plaza exists in real life of course, and is the headquarters of NBC, where
Your Show of Shows and many other comedy series are/were filmed.
What interests me the most about
My Favorite Year are the performers, especially Jessica Harper. I guess you could call me a fan of Harper, (a Harper
freak) even though I hardly like any of the films she's appeared in. I like
her anyway, which is what makes me very familiar with
My Favorite Year, but her character in it isn't very well developed, although admittedly she's very beautifully dressed and looks fantastic. She exists only to be wooed by Benjy, and after the characters kiss she disappears from the film, without even a mention. Did they go on to marry? Benjy would have to have done more than palled around with Swann for this to be his favourite year, so I guess we can at least assume they did. I enjoy seeing Selma Diamond in this as well, and it's interesting to note that she actually was a writer for
Your Show of Shows, which makes a neat little connection for lovers of trivia.
Peter O'Toole is the big attraction for people who love this film, and he received yet another Oscar nomination and yet another loss on Oscars night (during his career he was nominated 8 times and never won.) He fits his role well, as a once-beloved swashbuckler who is far past his prime and permanently wedded to the bottle - and plays with gusto. He outshines Mark Linn-Baker to such an extent that it seems to me to have been a mistake to cast Linn-Baker in this role - even if he does give an accurate reflection of someone who is young, fresh faced and somewhat inexperienced. He's no young Woody Allen, or young Mel Brooks. Linn-Baker would have his moment on television's
Perfect Strangers, which ran for an impressive 8 seasons, but he never managed to find a niche when it came to feature films. Apart from those I've mentioned, Cameron Mitchell is an extremely well known face, and an actor that would appear in
anything for a paycheck. Bill Macy is always a pleasure, and here he's as likeable and funny as he always seems to be.
Behind the camera, directing, is someone people of the 1970s and early 80s had seen a lot of in front of the camera, Richard Benjamin. He never made a really good director, and after the success of
My Favorite Year he began a downward slide in quality, both in his work and in the projects that came his way.
The Money Pit was mid-80s comedy that was at least appreciated by me at the time, but later the likes of
My Stepmother Is an Alien and
Made in America saw him cement a place in the lower echelons of mediocrity as a bit of a hack (though some might give him some credit for 1990 comedy
Mermaids.) By the late 90s he was mostly directing for television. Nat 'King' Cole sings on the soundtrack, "How High the Moon" turns up numerous times. Aside from that Ralph Burns (a two-time Oscar winner) has added a very sparing score which highlight moments, and you notice it when it decides to underline these occasions. Cinematographer Gerald Hirschfeld was director of photography on
Young Frankenstein and
Fail Safe, two very notable films in an uneven career.
"Haven't we walked enough for one night!?" towards the end O'Toole grabs a policeman's horse (and Linn-Baker) galloping away to the surging sounds of an orchestra and providing that excitement that the films of old used to. It's not enough, and he can't rescue this film from the mediocre writing, lack of really outstanding comedy and poorness of performers that surround him. It's not that
My Favorite Year ends up being a terrible movie, but it doesn't rise to any heights of greatness, and despite being a regular favourite film for some it doesn't stand out as ever so deserving of that status it has. I don't mind seeing Jessica Harper circa 1982, but she's spread pretty thin here, and Mark Linn-Baker, who I don't like so much, is spread very thickly. I don't understand why Mel Brooks or Carl Reiner couldn't write or direct it, seeing as they had such a personal connection to the story. It would have made a vast improvement to the finished product. That said, it could have been worse. There could have been no Jessica Harper, and it had the potential to be a bad film which it is certainly not. There's a lot worse a film can do than be on many a 'favourite film' list and have a legend produce an Oscar-nominated tour de force performance. There's something authentic about it's enthusiastic nostalgia.
* In a deleted scene seen mostly in televised replays of the film, Benjy has a scene in an elevator with K.C. where he actually displays a great sense of comedy and wit.