The Woman on the Beach, 1947
Scott (Robert Ryan) is a Coast Guardsman recovering physically and mentally from having been aboard a ship that was torpedoed. Coming out of his hospitalization, he starts to rush into a marriage with the sweet Eve (Nan Leslie). But soon after proposing, Scott encounters the lovely and sardonic Peggy (Joan Bennett) on the beach collecting driftwood. Peggy is married to Tod (Charles Bickford), a painter who was recently blinded during a domestic dispute with Peggy. A dangerous, fraught triangle soon forms between Scott, Tod, and Peggy.
Full of high drama, this story about obsession and identity seems to come to some dubious conclusions but holds interest with solid performances.
While I’m not entirely sure how much the messiness of the whole story was intentional, it does give the film some emotional realism. Scott might be physically recovered from his experiences, but he is not mentally well. His behavior is characterized by obsession and impulse. First, he pushes Eve into agreeing to marriage. Later, he will become obsessed with the idea that Tod is not really blind and will go to some extremes to prove it. He truly seems like a person who is flailing around, performing his idea of loyalty but endangering and harming others in the process.
Tod makes an interesting foil for Scott. Having lost the ability to paint as he once did, Tod has notions of becoming a writer. But whether for lack of talent in that department, or just the frustration and anxiety produced by his loss of vision, his genius with the paintbrush doesn’t seem to translate to the pen. He must also deal with the looming fact that as a painter he is now considered “dead,” something that drives up the value of all of his remaining paintings. Tod is bitter and angry, and he expresses his emotions via aggression toward Peggy and a needy desire to befriend Scott.
Peggy is the most challenging character. At times, she comes off as a pretty nuanced person. She admits to Scott the unflattering circumstances of Tod losing his vision. And while we see that Tod himself has a nasty, at-times violent temper, Peggy’s guilt over the hurt she’s inflicted on Tod keeps her loyal to him. Peggy knows that while they stay at the seaside, she will only be tempted by Scott and others. She repeatedly begs Tod to go back with her to New York, where they can renew their relationship, but he won’t have it.
I really went back and forth with how I felt about Peggy’s stand by your man act. On one hand, I did respond to the idea of her feeling guilt. On the other hand, Tod is so consistently abusive---physically and psychologically--that it was hard to root for her to stay with him. We see him hit her. We also watch an incredibly uncomfortable sequence where Tod wants to show off a painting, specifically a nude that he painted of Peggy. Tod is obviously in pain, but he’s so comfortable inflicting harm and embarrassment on Peggy that at a certain point her desire to stay with him became maddening instead of understandable.
Visually, the movie is incredibly dramatic. The sequence where Scott first catches sight of Peggy on the beach, she is eerily positioned amidst fog so that there’s something dream-like about it all. Later there will be showdowns on a cliff’s edge, on a boat out at sea, and a burning house. It’s a film where an orchestral score practically explodes every time Peggy and Scott launch into each other’s arms.
A good drama that doesn’t always seem sure about who it wants to center. The relationships and behavior are nicely complex, with solid performances.