I understand everything you're saying. And I guess you're making the point that, unlike old TV broadcasting which was free to the public and paid for by sponsors, modern TV requires funds from both sponsors AND viewers to supply the modern level of TV: (hundreds of channels, shows with advanced special effects, etc.) I'd add in the quality of programming but, although there is some out there, it is overshadowed by all the Reality TV and other garbage that far outnumbers programming of quality.
It's pretty hard to put a price on breadth of programming, too: there's a show for almost everything, and that's awfully nice when you find one you really like. It's easily worth 999 other shows you're not interested in, and there's no way to have that kind of niche programming without, by definition, having a smaller percentage of shows that are interesting to any one person.
I take a bit of exception to the idea that if channels didn't run infomercials all night and put endless pop-ups over top the programs, then my cable bill would be higher - that's because my cable bill IS higher every few months DESPITE the excessive marketing. I don't see any decrease in disruptive advertising every time they raise the bill. Seems if anything was "fair" you would see some resulting balancing going on - like after every price increase you'd see less channels showing nothing but info-mercials after 2:00 am, but instead you only see more.
That said, I've never heard of a cable bill going higher every few months for no reason. Are you in a highly rural area, or going month-to-month, or something? Every time I've gotten cable I've had a rate locked in for something like two years, and even when it went after, it was a modest amount and didn't, as far as I can remember, just keep climbing.
Personally, I can't afford cable AND a DVR (since I can't even afford the cable anymore). But, correct me if I'm wrong, even a DVR will not do anything about the pop-up adds that run on top of programs, will they?
Things like product placement and popup ads are the inevitable result of the DVR. Which is a pretty good trade, I think, given how convenient DVR is.
I ask because just recently I watched something with lots of captions and information in text form that was part of the show - it was made virtually unwatchable by the pop-up ads that covered up the captions every few minutes - no point in even putting a show like that on the air in this TV environment.
In the end, I don't think a lot of the practices I've observed or the evolution of abuses are fair. So I'm seriously considering either going back to the bottom tier at the next price increase or discontinuing TV altogether.