Midnight Cowboy - 1969
Directed by John Schlesinger
Written by Waldo Salt
Based on a novel by James Leo Herlihy
Starring Dustin Hoffman, John Voight
& Sylvia Miles
This review contains
SPOILERS
The Oscar most assuredly should have gone to Dustin Hoffman when all was said and done, although Jon Voight matched him in
Midnight Cowboy - John Schlesinger's instant classic about one man's spiritual transformation, friendship and struggle to survive. The seedy streets of New York came of age, and for the first time the lens truly focused on the hustlers, con artists, crooks and desperados amidst the dirt and grime. Hoffman's performance was faultless, and rarely has an actor toiled as hard, or been as dedicated, as this actor was at the start of his film career. He already had
The Graduate (and another Oscar nomination) under his belt, but Voight was as fresh faced as his character and had to go through many tests and auditions to play Joe Buck. It's a supreme pleasure to watch both of them perform, elevating each other and really bringing something from deep inside of themselves - the friendship that Joe Buck and Hoffman's Enrico Salvatore "Ratso" Rizzo develop is not only touching, but the driving force behind Buck's evolution as a whole person who can feel compassion and really see other people for what they are. In Danny Peary's
Alternate Oscars he gives the award to Dustin Hoffman (but takes
Midnight Cowboy's Best Picture Oscar and gives it to
Once Upon a Time in the West.)
Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid was that year's favourite for Best Picture - but
Midnight Cowboy was most deserving, and proof that the Academy sometimes gets it right.
In a small town in Texas Joe Buck packs his bags and quits his job as a dishwasher in a cheap restaurant to find fortune in the Big Apple as a hustler, convinced as he is of his prowess as a sex machine. Harry Nilsson performs Fred Neil's song "Everybody's Talkin", which captures the mood perfectly and really propels the film forward - both outwardly, and inwardly as Buck takes moments looking through store windows and on the bus to remember his past - a childhood that is more detailed in James Leo Herlihy's novel of the same name. Buck's 'cowboy' persona is very superficial and almost childlike in it's simplicity - he appears more or less as a fully grown man playing dress-up with his hat and boots. His expressions match this simplicity, not to mention naivety and overconfidence. This is soon punctured on the streets of the city, and in a hotel room which already begins to let him in on the fact that everything here will cost him. Instead of doing the hustling, he's outwitted and preyed upon by his first would-be customer who takes him for $20. There's a sweetness to Buck however, in as much as he feels compassion for people and hates to see this woman (Cass - played by Sylvia Miles in an Oscar-nominated turn) cry. Who he really needs is someone to show him the ropes.
That someone
could be "Ratso" Rizzo, but of course Rizzo also decides to con Buck out of $20 while introducing him to a crazy closeted religious nut (John McGiver) and taking off. Buck plots his revenge in a series of crazy black and white shots, but soon enough is broke, eating free crackers in diners and doing sexual favours for young guys in movie theaters (who invariably don't have the money to pay him.) A young Jewish kid is played by a young Bob Balaban - a Wes Anderson favourite and future Oscar nominee. Locked out of his hotel room, with all of his belongings confiscated, Buck eventually comes across Rizzo again, and despite an initial confrontation "Ratso" invites him to stay at his place - an apartment in a condemned building, which is broken down,
filthy and has no electricity. Rizzo, who suffers from a limp and bad cough, dreams of travelling to Florida, which he believes will help his poor health - posters of Florida adorn the otherwise dull walls of this apartment, where Rizzo and Buck will stay despite the cold which sets in, and for which they have no remedy. Desperation seeps through. The two often go hungry, and desperate for money Buck pawns the one thing he loves above all others - his transistor radio.
The two will remain close for the rest of the film. Rizzo's obsession about Florida leads to one of my favourite segments of
Midnight Cowboy - which is Rizzo's fantasy about what life there will be like as Buck heads off to earn some money (that was intended for someone else.) In it, cinematographer Adam Holender completely transforms thought into another dimension - and the difference in light from overexposure makes everything seem heavenly. John Barry introduces a cheerful melody - a jaunty tune which accompanies scenes where Rizzo is a regular playboy and adored by the older women as he cooks, gambles and flirts with the ladies. He can outrun Buck, and returns waves from balconies in this happy, healthy atmosphere. Holender had come from Poland and became the director of photography during an audition process where different cinematographers came and went during preproduction. He used a long lens for many of the shots on New York streets, capturing the characters from far off in a more naturalistic way. John Barry is most famous from his work on the James Bond films, and the pieces of music we hear on New York streets are recognizable as his kind of melodic trademark.
Midnight Cowboy has a lot going for it as far as talent goes, not the least of which is it's terrific screenwriter Waldo Salt - who lovingly and carefully put together the screenplay, and spent many days on set revising it to perfection to make sure everything worked. Salt was a writer who spent time on everything he wrote, his slow pace a thoughtfully purposeful mode of working to make sure everything was exactly how he wanted it. He'd been blacklisted during the McCarthy Red Scare for being an avowed communist - a stance he abandoned when the many cruelties of the Stalin regime came to light. Waldo Salt won an Oscar for his screenplay for
Midnight Cowboy, and would go on to write ones for such films as
Serpico,
The Day of the Locust and
Coming Home (for which he won another Oscar.) Director John Schlesinger, an Englishman, was really coming into his own here, and his fascination for America and New York saw him accentuating things that an American director may have completely overlooked. He also won an Oscar for
Midnight Cowboy and would work again with Salt on
Day of the Locust and again with Hoffman when he directed
Marathon Man.
Once established, the close friendship between Buck and Rizzo take them to a New York party that was shot over the course of three days, almost in documentary style, taking advantage of the many friends of Andy Warhol at an art event (Warhol himself had been shot around this time, and was unable to be present.) It seems a little slow, and out of place, but at the same time I feel that the film needed this change of setting and pace, and it's another event which takes the characters along on their journey of change. Characters and people who populated the Warhol Factory scene appear, such as Viva, Ultra Violet and International Velvet. Buck accidentally smokes a reefer, and finds for himself his first bona-fide client, which will potentially lead to more - but not before Rizzo's illness worsens and a desperate Buck resorts to violence in a powerful scene opposite Barnard Hughes. The two of them then find themselves on the road heading to Miami - Buck in the midst of great personal change and Rizzo deteriorating quickly. Those final scenes in
Midnight Cowboy are masterful, moving and a perfect way to end what is nearly a perfect film.
Midnight Cowboy came on the scene over 50 years ago, and it appears to have aged particularly well. It's a film that has only grown in stature as far as I'm concerned, and although I've always held it in particularly high regard I admire it even more when I look at it today. It doesn't dwell on the darkness found in the deepest recesses of the alleys and tenements in New York, but instead takes what it finds in those places and uplifts it - holds a light to it so we can see inside and not only understand it, but realise that there is love and goodness to be found there as well. Buck is redeemed, not only through the journey he takes but by painfully recalling how he became the man he was when he set out on his journey. "Ratso" Rizzo is a dirty con-man scratching around for dimes in telephone booths, but shown love he becomes a human being once more - desperate for dignity and somebody to share a meal and cigarette with who might consider him an equal and companion. The friendship these men share is profound, and through Waldo Salt, John Schlesinger, Dustin Hoffman and Jon Voight every ounce of it is imparted to us the audience.
I love seeing the innocence on the face of John Voight and how it changes during the course of the film. There's a realisation he has, when he gets to New York and he briefly begins to write a postcard to a coworker he used to wash dishes with (and who he realises is illiterate, and as such couldn't read his postcard anyway) - a realisation that he doesn't really have a friend in the world, and perhaps never did. Through flashbacks we find out that Buck was once in a relationship with the town floozy - and that both of them were raped in a traumatic incident, where she ended up in a mental institution and him in prison. His mother dumped him on his grandmother, who used to force enemas upon him and treat him in an unusually tactile way. He's hardly had a chance to grow in a normal manner. None of this has hardened him - on the contrary, he's a soft and sensitive individual - but through what is perhaps the first real friendship of his life his childlike innocent selfishness turns outward and he reacts less about himself and more towards his friend. Eventually he throws his cowboy suit away, adorning adult clothes and talking to a waitress without putting a stud-like show on for the first time. Instead he talks to her simply as adult to adult in a normal manner. From start to finish this change in him has been transposed onto the screen in such a manner that it's simply so pleasurable to watch.
Another character in this film we can't forget is New York itself, a hard place for a child-like man with naïve dreams to land in alone with all of his worldly possessions in a small suitcase. John Schlesinger was fascinated by the place, and the crazy people doing crazy things on nearly every street (the drugged-up woman playing with the plastic mouse, and the one running about the street in a paranoid fashion were played by the same actress and both based on things Schlesinger had recently seen.) He was also captivated by American television of the day, some examples of which he included in the film. Recently arrived Adam Holender had the same kind of fervour and wonder for the place, with it's neon lights, skyscrapers, advertising and strange people. The film got some of it's most enthusiastic receptions from New York audiences, who agreed with the reflection of the city (while ironically, in other places some of the darker depictions of New York were frowned upon.) I've never been to New York, but simply having lived right in the heart of my city gives me an appreciation for how inner city living is depicted in
Midnight Cowboy.
Midnight Cowboy ushered in a new era of filmmaking at a key period in United States history, one that could finally look at sex and homosexuality in a more open way, and be less restrictive when it came to depicting city streets and the lives of those living in cities who were less fortunate. For me though, it's the performance from it's leads that lift it into the stratosphere - a place it was destined to reach with such talent as Salt, John Schlesinger, John Barry and Adam Holender involved. Hearing "Everybody's Talkin", seeing those long shots, watching Voight and Hoffman and travelling on their journey will always remind me of just how great this film is. It is probably overlooked too often on "Best Films" lists these days - and to tell you the truth may have been overlooked by me if I hadn't of revisited it and really payed attention. There are many small and unmentioned little touches that add to it, and they're everywhere - from Dustin Hoffman's ad-lib when nearly knocked over by a taxi to Barnard Hughes suggesting that maybe his false teeth should come out when he's hit in the face by Buck. Everyone involved cared deeply about making the best film they could possibly make - and as such they
did make the best film they could possibly make. When I see Voight lean over and close Hoffman's eyes, and then hold his little buddy on that bus - the look in his eyes reverberates in me - into my heart. Moments like that are why I love movies.