Search Results
Showing results 1 to 25 of 1000
Forum: Movie Reviews 2 hours ago
Replies: 6,109
The Movie Forums Top 100 of All-Time Refresh: Countdown
Posted By Yoda
Re: The Movie Forums Top 100 of All-Time Refresh: Countdown

Most people wait until the end, but as you can see sometimes people reveal some choices (directly or indirectly) once they're totally convinced something isn't showing up, since if they're right...
Forum: Movie Reviews 8 hours ago
Replies: 6,109
The Movie Forums Top 100 of All-Time Refresh: Countdown
Posted By Yoda
I like that explanation for Goodfellas, partially...

I like that explanation for Goodfellas, partially because it simultaneously explains why someone would love it and why it might feel "off" to them, since to some degree that's the point. I imagine...
Forum: Movie Forums Site Stuff 9 hours ago
Replies: 96
Suggestions for future countdowns
Posted By Yoda
First poll: decade or genre? Second poll: which...

First poll: decade or genre? Second poll: which decade/genre? Allows people to have influence on the second choice even if the vote for something that didn't win in the first choice.


There are a...
Forum: Movie Forums Site Stuff 9 hours ago
Replies: 96
Suggestions for future countdowns
Posted By Yoda
Re: Suggestions for future countdowns

What do people think about doing a poll to decide which type of list, first, and then a poll to decide the specific list? That might help more people get what they want to some degree, since...
Forum: Movie Reviews 9 hours ago
Replies: 6,109
The Movie Forums Top 100 of All-Time Refresh: Countdown
Posted By Yoda
For sure, and I'm not flabbergasted by the love...

For sure, and I'm not flabbergasted by the love or anything. I'm just working backwards from the fact that I don't adore it, and just trying to figure out why. I could say "I just don't" (and a lot...
Forum: Movie Forums Site Stuff 9 hours ago
Replies: 96
Suggestions for future countdowns
Posted By Yoda
In general, I do; the subtle distinction here is...

In general, I do; the subtle distinction here is that I prefer a genre countdown, but would generally prefer there be a clear choice for what that genre is. And that distinction is new, just...
Forum: Movie Reviews 10 hours ago
Replies: 6,109
The Movie Forums Top 100 of All-Time Refresh: Countdown
Posted By Yoda
Re: The Movie Forums Top 100 of All-Time Refresh: Countdown

Yeah, that's another thing, it's hard enough to parse preferences, let alone super subtle ones like "why do people here think this is REALLY great instead of just great?"
Forum: Movie Reviews 10 hours ago
Replies: 6,109
The Movie Forums Top 100 of All-Time Refresh: Countdown
Posted By Yoda
Re: The Movie Forums Top 100 of All-Time Refresh: Countdown

Yeah, I've kind of been at a loss to explain why I don't love Goodfellas more. My best explanation is that it suffers from a dominated strategy: it's a very good mob film, but that means I'll always...
Forum: Movie Forums Site Stuff 10 hours ago
Replies: 96
Suggestions for future countdowns
Posted By Yoda
Part of my thinking is that people will...

Part of my thinking is that people will inevitably fight over qualifications when they're not well-defined, so it might be a lot to fight over the choice and its implementation. Which is why I like...
Forum: Movie Reviews 10 hours ago
Replies: 6,109
The Movie Forums Top 100 of All-Time Refresh: Countdown
Posted By Yoda
Re: The Movie Forums Top 100 of All-Time Refresh: Countdown

Very true. And I'd be okay with people asking that, too! The answers might be instructive. Of the three I only like Pulp Fiction as much as most people, caveating that it's difficult to quantify...
Forum: Movie Reviews 10 hours ago
Replies: 6,109
The Movie Forums Top 100 of All-Time Refresh: Countdown
Posted By Yoda
Re: The Movie Forums Top 100 of All-Time Refresh: Countdown

You can technically ask "what's the big deal?" about any film, for sure, but I think it's reasonable with Goodfellas because the love for it here seems to consistently outstrip its love in other...
Forum: Movie Forums Site Stuff 10 hours ago
Replies: 96
Suggestions for future countdowns
Posted By Yoda
Re: Suggestions for future countdowns

Also, I will preemptively volunteer myself as a human sacrifice to make genre qualification choices if the Curator does not want to deal with the headache. I'll be the bad guy. ;) Only if they don't...
Forum: Movie Forums Site Stuff 10 hours ago
Replies: 96
Suggestions for future countdowns
Posted By Yoda
Re: Suggestions for future countdowns

Personally I like the idea of only doing non-decades if there's a pretty clear consensus. If you have seven options and one of them wins by a single vote, and with like 35% of the vote because the...
Forum: Movie Reviews 10 hours ago
Replies: 6,109
The Movie Forums Top 100 of All-Time Refresh: Countdown
Posted By Yoda
"I watch movies for the articles."

"I watch movies for the articles."
Forum: General Movie Discussion 10 hours ago
Replies: 61,241
Rate The Last Movie You Saw
Posted By Yoda
Yikes. Been looking forward to this, since it's...

Yikes. Been looking forward to this, since it's Kaufman and all. Still gonna have to see for myself, but that's a bummer to hear.
Forum: Intermission: Miscellaneous Chat 10 hours ago
Replies: 2,079
Pets
Posted By Yoda
Ike trying to look casual. 72102

Ike trying to look casual.

72102
Forum: Movie Forums Site Stuff 12 hours ago
Replies: 96
Suggestions for future countdowns
Posted By Yoda
I'd agree with that, more distance, less likely...

I'd agree with that, more distance, less likely to fluctuate, etc. And it makes sense to do them "in order" somewhat.

(Standard caveat that my opinions on list things are just one person's...
Forum: Movie Reviews 13 hours ago
Replies: 6,109
The Movie Forums Top 100 of All-Time Refresh: Countdown
Posted By Yoda
If you guys wanna talk future countdowns and the...

If you guys wanna talk future countdowns and the complications they entail, don't forget to put them here, or they're just not gonna be seen long-term:

Suggestions for future countdowns...
Forum: Movie Reviews 14 hours ago
Replies: 6,109
The Movie Forums Top 100 of All-Time Refresh: Countdown
Posted By Yoda
Yeah, saw that a few years ago since I'd heard so...

Yeah, saw that a few years ago since I'd heard so many stories about the horror show that filming was. Would agree that it's a must-see. I enjoyed it more than the film itself. But as you allude to,...
Forum: Movie Reviews 15 hours ago
Replies: 6,109
The Movie Forums Top 100 of All-Time Refresh: Countdown
Posted By Yoda
Re: The Movie Forums Top 100 of All-Time Refresh: Countdown

Apocalypse Now was a classic I took awhile to see, admired well enough when I saw it, but really have no emotional connection to and no plans to watch again any time soon. That's usually my reaction...
Forum: Movie Reviews 15 hours ago
Replies: 6,109
The Movie Forums Top 100 of All-Time Refresh: Countdown
Posted By Yoda
Yeah, this is one of the bigger "really thought...

Yeah, this is one of the bigger "really thought it might make it"s from my list, too. I had it very high.
Forum: Movie Reviews 15 hours ago
Replies: 6,109
The Movie Forums Top 100 of All-Time Refresh: Countdown
Posted By Yoda
https://www.movieforums.com/images/lists/alltime-r...

https://www.movieforums.com/images/lists/alltime-refresh/gQB8Y5RCMkv2zwzFHbUJX3kAhvA.jpg (https://www.movieforums.com/movies/28-apocalypse-now.html)
290 points
20 lists9. Apocalypse Now
...
Replies: 19
Bernie Gone Viral
Posted By Yoda
Re: Bernie Gone Viral

If discussing the rule about political discussions itself counted as a political discussion, I'd never have been able to announce it.
Replies: 19
Bernie Gone Viral
Posted By Yoda
Not until some fun-killer comes along and veers...

Not until some fun-killer comes along and veers away from the memes.
Forum: Birthdays and Introductions 1 day ago
Replies: 8
Happy Birthday, MovieMeditation!
Posted By Yoda
Happy birthday!

Happy birthday!