Search Results
Showing results 1 to 25 of 90
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
Re: VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)

Thanks Ed:)
And with Ed's abstaining vote the majority has decided that Siddon's ballot stays in and I have just now entered that information on the HoF Archive thread.

I hope you guys...
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
My wife didn't like The Jerk either, so perhaps...

My wife didn't like The Jerk either, so perhaps my fondness of it is mainly from nostalgia...I had seen it at the theater first run and then many times since. I think if a person watches the same...
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
Re: VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)

Real Genius was your pick, Wow! I thought for sure that was GBGoodies I know she loves that movie. It looks like my nom The Jerk and yours, Real Genius was the bombs of the HoF:)
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
@edarsenal...

@edarsenal (http://www.movieforums.com/community/member.php?u=50536) @gbgoodies (http://www.movieforums.com/community/member.php?u=84622) Please read the last few pages of this thread, starting here...
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
Re: VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)

I'm done here on this thread for now. Talking to Siddon is like talking to a brick wall. He won't answer if he altered his ballot to effect the outcome in the other HoFs he hosted, even though he...
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
You just can't play fair can you? First you screw...

You just can't play fair can you? First you screw over the other members by altering your ballot as host, so that the outcome of the HoF will be what you want it to be, you admitted to that in this...
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
And seeing how you're online I want an answer to...

And seeing how you're online I want an answer to my question...Did you use your ballot points to break ties or alter the outcome in the 18th and Comedy 1 or II?
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
Re: VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)

I just checked it's 3 votes to keep your ballot and 1 against. We still need to hear from edarsenal and gbgoodies.
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
Who cast the 4 votes? You don't get to vote on...

Who cast the 4 votes? You don't get to vote on this yourself.
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
We still need to hear from edarsenal and...

We still need to hear from edarsenal and gbgoodies.
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
Re: VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)

are=our ugh I hate making that typo...or is it a braino?:p
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
We all get to pick our own movie as winner this...

We all get to pick our own movie as winner this time:p
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
I think people thought Blues Brothers was mine as...

I think people thought Blues Brothers was mine as I talked it up, but I thought it was yours. I had no idea on who nominated Parenthood.

And I'll eat my bow tie if Real Genius and When Harry Met...
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
Just for the record, I wasn't asking Siddon to...

Just for the record, I wasn't asking Siddon to address those quotes. I used those quotes in my post so that the other members could see why I was voting the way I voted to disqualify Siddon's ballot....
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
You have readily admitted to using forehand...

You have readily admitted to using forehand knowledge of other people's voting ballots to alter your own ballot, so that you can effect the outcome of the HoF. That's not allowed in any kind of...
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
Re: VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)

My ballot:
1 Annie Hall
2 Back to the Future
3 The Jerk
4 The Blues Brothers
5 After Hours
6 Who Framed Roger Rabbit s
7 Planes, Trains, and Automobiles
8 Dirty Rotten Scoundrels
9...
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
Re: VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)

Siddon please post all of our voting ballots, (like I did in the 20th HoF)
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
Did you break any other ties in the other HoFs...

Did you break any other ties in the other HoFs that you hosted?
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
Agreed...that's exactly how it should be done by...

Agreed...that's exactly how it should be done by a host. That's why in the 20th HoF that I hosted I said this: As a host I try to get my own voting ballot done early and then it's 'locked' and I...
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
That's completely wrong for a host to do, it's...

That's completely wrong for a host to do, it's the same thing as rigging an election. The host voting ballot should never be influenced by what the other members have voted for on their ballots.
...
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
That's why when I'm a host I always try to vote...

That's why when I'm a host I always try to vote first or at least early in the HoF, and then lock my own ballot down, that way I don't have to be in that kind of situation.
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
Re: VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)

I'm still going to post my guesses at the final outcome but will wait tell we're done with the watching phase. I'll also try to guess who nominated what, I'm pretty sure on some movies.
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
Then I'm not sure what you nominated, but I'll...

Then I'm not sure what you nominated, but I'll try to take a guess soon. I'm just so tired right now, my brain ain't working:eek:
Replies: 442
VHS comedy era comedy Hall of fame III (1977-1989)
Posted By Citizen Rules
You must've nominated The Princess Bride;) as I...

You must've nominated The Princess Bride;) as I don't see it coming in that high. I'd say Roger Rabbit will be #1 I mean did anybody hate it? I don't think so.