Page 1 of 5
12Last »


Search Results
Showing results 1 to 25 of 122
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
A great one 😉 I had Ox Bow as #1 with the...

A great one 😉

I had Ox Bow as #1 with the other 2 mentioned fairly low. I was surprised by Rio Bravo getting second, however. I didn’t think it was in the running, even though it got mostly good...
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Re: Western Hall of Fame II

I'd think to start it sooner than later. A week pause might seems to log to me, but tonight Sunday eve seems too soon and other stuff is going on. Maybe do it on the next free day you have. Either...
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Re: Western Hall of Fame II

I wish you weren’t so condescending 😏
Oh well, wish you would get the help you so desperately need.
Please stay clear of me, and I’ll do the same of you. In fact. Don’t mention me. At all. I...
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Re: Western Hall of Fame II

My ballot was a follows:

1. The Ox Bow Incident
2. The Man who Shot Liberty Valance
3. Rio Bravo
4. The Salvation.
5. The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly
6. The Shooting
7. The Cowboys
8....
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Re: Western Hall of Fame II

Congrats Citizen! It was a very tight race between the top 3. The better film won in the end
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Re: Western Hall of Fame II

Did you watch it in English or Italian with subs?[/QUOTE]
English
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Ox bow deserves this. Had figured it was the the...

Ox bow deserves this. Had figured it was the the film to beat all along
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Re: Western Hall of Fame II

I did not like The Great Silence at all. It was nice to look at, and even the music was nice to listen to (it was Morricone afterall) but the dialogue was pretty bad at times. Trintignant was pretty...
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Re: Western Hall of Fame II

I’m here!
Was hoping The Shooting would have been a little higher.
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
I must be the only one who enjoyed The Salvation....

I must be the only one who enjoyed The Salvation. 🤷
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Re: Western Hall of Fame II

I wasn't being condescending. I've read your comments on the film and I genuinely think there are some things that you don't understand about yourself and the movie. It's nothing to get upset over....
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Re: Western Hall of Fame II

You have The Shooting ranked too low! 😜
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Re: Western Hall of Fame II

I think The Great Silence was liked well enough by most that it could make a run for the top.
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Re: Western Hall of Fame II

You sure f*cked up the final placements ;)

Here are the final points

46

45

43
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Re: Western Hall of Fame II

Yeah I love classic noir too. In fact just typing that makes me want to start watching them. There was a time when I watch a lot of them. But now it's been so long I need to do a bunch of...
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Re: Western Hall of Fame II

I would have thought Noir was your favorite.
Second favorite I suppose, then?
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
The ego on you. You were flat out...

The ego on you.
You were flat out condescending towards me when you suggested “I couldn’t comprehend a film”.
Then Suggested I had an ego when I responded you were being condescending.
You’re...
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Re: Western Hall of Fame II

I don't know what, "it" is referring to here. What is subjective? There is some truth and some fiction in my review. I never said my review was the truth. But there is a lot of truth in it. I'm...
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Re: Western Hall of Fame II

I appreciate your comments.

I would like to dissect some of them. For me it's not about arguing or one person against another. It's all about the truth. If I can help you learn something, come...
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Re: Western Hall of Fame II

I actually think Siskel and Ebert were two of the best critics ever. You claim Ebert was paid for good reviews. Can you provide proof?
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Re: Western Hall of Fame II

Well, I am willing to consider that I could be wrong. If you make a good argument I will listen. In fact I would love to be wrong because I would love to be corrected if I am wrong. If I'm wrong,...
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Re: Western Hall of Fame II

Everything you say is true, but I don't think it isn't a great movie just because I don't like it. I think it isn't a great movie because it's content lacks depth, the editing is sloppy, and the...
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Re: Western Hall of Fame II

Okay, but when you say something like this it warrants a response, so please don't respond to my response with something like, "I don't care."

My feelings towards Citizen's review of Soldier Blue...
Replies: 566
Western Hall of Fame II
Posted By Wyldesyde19
Re: Western Hall of Fame II

According to google dictionary:

Libel: a published false statement that is damaging to a person's reputation; a written defamation.

Slander: the action or crime of making a false spoken...

Page 1 of 5
12Last »