Page 1 of 2
12


Search Results
Showing results 1 to 25 of 32
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Re: Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

1. Metropolis
2. Pandora’s Box
3. Faust :(
4. The Kid
5. Sherlock, Jr.
6. The Man Who Laughs
7. Sadie Thompson
8. The Unknown
9. Marianne
10. Lucky Star
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Re: Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

Thanks for hosting CR a very fun HoF.
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Nice my blind nom won haha

Nice my blind nom won haha
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Re: Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

Doesn’t matter to me , I loved both, but I think metropolis will take it.
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Re: Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

Cool another one I voted high. Had the Kid at 4. Which means the next two are my 1 and 2, so I’m real happy.
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Re: Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

I had my own nom at 5, lower than it’s placement... so I’m happy.
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Re: Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

The Unknown was my 8. I don’t know, it just didn’t work very well for me.
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Re: Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

Neither of my noms have showed up yet, so I’m happy. One of them was a blind nom, but I actually had it higher!
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Re: Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

First “perfectly placed” movie. I also had Man who Laughs at 6.
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Re: Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

Lucky Star was my #10. Was not a fan.
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Re: Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

Aw... I liked Faust, had it at #3.
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Re: Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

Me. Sadie Thompson I had at #7.
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Re: Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

I believe this was my #9. It was a tossup between that and Lucky Star for the bottom two spots.
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Re: Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

Yeah, let's do a Part 2, if everyone wants to? Ed said he would, I would. I bet cricket and Siddon would too.

For this HoF I went with two blind noms that didn't do well. I didn't even like them...
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Re: Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

We're doing a Part 2 of this right? I actually only have 17 movies I could put on my Countdown List so I kinda need one!
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Re: Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

Is everyone done then?
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Re: Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

Sadie Thompson

I actually liked this more than I expected, but it was still kind of a drag. Although it wasn’t even very long, they should have cut down on the run time, the story didn’t feel like...
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Re: Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

After watching it I'm so puzzled by your point of view that I can't even believe we watched the same movie. The "touchy" and "sexually aggressive" man you speak of came off to me as a really nice...
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Faust Not bad at all. I loved the technical...

Faust

Not bad at all. I loved the technical aspects, like the really good special effects and wonderful dark and serene images. A lot of this films is just poetical, like the visuals are writing a...
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Metropolis This is a visually stunning and...

Metropolis

This is a visually stunning and beautiful film, with rich sets and designs, and stunning camera work and mission. The story is definitely second to the technical aspects, but it’s...
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Well ,I think because it only has 1,000 votes,...

Well ,I think because it only has 1,000 votes, that's about 1500 times less than the higher rated movies at IMDB.
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Re: Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

Marianne

This one was another letdown. I just though the humor was really dated and they tried to add in sound elements (like the mediocre music) when they weren't necessary. Some of the dialogue...
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Re: Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

Never mind, it switches to English.
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Re: Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

I’m confused...I tried the link for Marianne and three minutes in I realized it’s in French. Is there a way to get English subtitles or something?
Replies: 245
Pre-1930s Hall of Fame
Posted By ahwell
Re: Pre-1930s Hall of Fame

Lucky Star

Not a fan of this one. I think it could only really hold up well under the lens of historical analysis, since it is a silent film partially about World War I. Other than that, I think...

Page 1 of 2
12