Best Battle Scene Best Fight Scene
 

Choose one or two for each so others can post scenes not yet mentioned.

I will steal the most obvious...

Best Battle Scenes: Saving Private Ryan (Omaha Beach Landing)
Return of the King (battle for Minas Tirith)

Best Fight Scenes: Star Wars Ep. 2 (Yoda vs. Count Dooku)
Legend of the Drunken Master (Axe gang scene)

Re: Best Battle Scene Best Fight Scene
 

BBS: King Arthur (Final Battle v. Saxons)
Braveheart (Battle of Sterling)

BFS: Fight Club (Ed Norton fights himself in Parking Garage)
The Incredible Hulk (Hulk v. Abomination aka "HULK SMASH!")

Re: Best Battle Scene Best Fight Scene
 

Gotta add one more. sorry.

BFS: Sin City (Dwight v. Irish Mercs)

Re: Best Battle Scene Best Fight Scene
 

Best battle/fight scene?
Either...

• The last fight scenes in the John Wayne Alamo movie.
• Fight scenes in the movie Zulu, with Michael Caine.

Re: Best Battle Scene Best Fight Scene
 

http://www.dvdbeaver.com/film/DVDRev...mes/battle.jpg
Chimes at Midnight
1966 - Orson Welles

Welles' frenzied, muddy, chaotic rendition of the Battle of Shrewsbury is like a ten-minute film school on how to make a perfect battle scene. That he accomplished this with a relatively small budget and crew highlights his filmmaking genius even more brightly. Mel Gibson and company clearly cribbed more than a couple shots and plenty of technique for Braveheart. I like Orson's much better.


And while it hasn't been replied to since '04, there's a long thread about best fight scenes HERE.

Re: Best Battle Scene Best Fight Scene
 

Although many people malign this film, I like handling of the battle scene in The Thin Red Line in which they storm the hill. The swooping camera and unique sound engineering always pull me right in...

Re: Best Battle Scene Best Fight Scene
 

I'm going to stand up for the cheesy cult classics here...


BEST BATTLE SCENE: The castle siege from Army of Darkness. Watch this and the Helm's Deep siege from The Two Towers back to back and see where Jackson drew a heavy chunk of inspiration. Exploding arrows blowing evil skeletons to dust, bombs being catapulted into enemy ranks, even Ash piloting a bizarre "death-mobile" with helicopter rotors slicing up whatever's in his path. It's a bizarre cluster-f*** of a battle scene that mixes lovably bad puppets, loads of explosions, a good handful of sword-fighting and all manner of bizarre Evil Dead-style bits of humour.


BEST FIGHT SCENE: "Put on the glasses!" Rowdy Roddy Piper does what he does best in John Carpenter's infamous anti-consumerism B-movie when he tries to convince Keith David's take-no-crap worker Frank to wear the glasses that expose the truth about our world. What was originally supposed to be a twenty-second sequence in the script ballooned out to a six-minute long alleyway brawl between Piper and David (at the insistence of both). The lack of music and the fact that a large number of the hits were real (excluding hits to the face or groin) make it easy to believe that this is a genuine brawl in a movie about a world where almost nothing is genuine anymore.

Re: Best Battle Scene Best Fight Scene
 

Okay, Zulu is a good pick, but I'm always amazed when someone cites John Wayne's The Alamo for any accomplishment. Hollywood has never made a good, truthful film about the battle of the Alamo, and IMHO the John Wayne version is probably the worst. If Crockett, Bowie, and Travis had been as pompus and hammy as portrayed in that film, they couldn't have led men to a dog fight. But that's just my opinion. :)

The only movie with an Alamo setting that I've really enjoyed was Viva, Max!

Re: Best Battle Scene Best Fight Scene
 

OK, the best battle scenes :

The air combat in 12 O'Clock High. Those are actual films of the air war in World War II.

The confused attacks, retreats, and counter-attacks in The Red Badge of Courage, which I still think is the most realistic war movie Hollywood ever made.

The two German fighters making a useless straffing run on the troops swarming the Normandy beaches in The Longest Day.

The Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor in From Here to Eternity, especially the scene where the Japanese fighter makes a straffing run at the men on the parade ground at Schofield Barracks.

The assault on the farm house at the end of A Walk in the Sun.

The down-and-dirty fighting in Attack! when Jack Palance gets his armed pinned under a German tank.

The confused battle among the trees and snow in Battleground. The assault scenes in Battle Cry!

The realistic knife fight in Saving Pvt. Ryan, which is the only thing that impressed me in that whole film.

Plus:
The air battles in Hell’s Angels (1930)

The hand-to-hand bayonet battle in Hell to Eternity (1960).

The mortar attack on the company headquarters and the subsequent nighttime Japanese attack on a mountain outpost that only 2 men survive in Between Heaven and Hell (1956)

The hopeless attacks against enemy trenches in Paths of Glory and Gallipoli.

Re: Best Battle Scene Best Fight Scene
 

And I'll stand up for cheesy martial arts movies, still love all Kill Bill's and the Drunken Master was pretty cool to watch, I can't believe it's an actual style!

Re: Best Battle Scene Best Fight Scene
 

Ditto -- I love The Thin Red Line.

Re: Best Battle Scene Best Fight Scene
 

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...n_soldiers.jpg
300 is a awsome film and the battles are great.

http://hugereviews.com/Presents/Matrix/matrix6.jpg
This fight sceane is amazing

Re: Best Battle Scene Best Fight Scene
 

Any scence in Shoot Em Up or Crank. I only saw the end scenes Equlibrium but they were awesome.

Re: Best Battle Scene Best Fight Scene
 

Not sure about favourite battle scene but I love the one in Kill Bill 1, no matter how unrealistic it is!

Re: Best Battle Scene Best Fight Scene
 

"Band of brothers" i think it is my all time favorite war movie and has the best fighting scenes. I had watched it when it was new on HBO and when it came out on DVD i watched every episode on the 11 disc set in a row. I just couldn't turn it off. "Blackhawk Down" is a close second. A must have for both movies is surround sound.

Re: Best Battle Scene Best Fight Scene
 

Battle for Helms Deep in LOTR: Two Towers or The Battle of 5 points from the begining of Gangs of New York. I love it.

Re: Best Battle Scene Best Fight Scene
 

Might not be the "greatest" fight in cinema, but certainly very worth a reminder…

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kanIgGfazAc

Re: Best Battle Scene Best Fight Scene
 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NY1lpIf5Jmg

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8_80q_0_mso

Re: Best Battle Scene Best Fight Scene
 

The fight scenes in The Bourne Identity are awsome.
http://images.tomshardware.com/2007/...bourne_425.jpg

Re: Best Battle Scene Best Fight Scene
 

Ong Bak has some amazing fight scenes.
http://www.scene4.com/archivesqv6/se..._Ong-Bakcr.jpg

http://www.sensesofcinema.com/images/05/34/ong_bak.jpg

http://images.starpulse.com/Photos/P...gBak-BH-04.jpg