Sin City 2 and 3
 

what does everyone think of Robert Rodriguez doing this?

No.

Sin City was a masterpiece. I dont hink it should be touched

There are enough stories already inked over the years by Frank that they could conceivably do a second feature. SIN CITY has done good business (already made back nearly twice the pre-advertising budget in U.S. boxoffice alone), and will do even better on DVD, so I'm sure from a financial standpoint it's something Dimension would put up money for. Whether or not Miller & Rodriguez want to do another one, time will tell.

I do hope that would happen. I'd love to see A Dame To Kill For in the next one if they do go ahead with a sequel.

Courtesy of jrs and the blog:

Confirmed

Jackpot. WU WHO!!!!!!!!!

[b]Umm All I gotta say lol is Sin City Was a great Movie!!!!

Just read my first Sin City graphic novel, A Dame To Kill For. Loved it! I hope they make it in either part 2 or 3.

But after reading it, I now have a problem with the movie. Why is Dwight in the bar when Marv walks in all taped up? Shouldn't he be in Old Town? I know I'm being a little nit-picky here, but if they do make A Dame To Kill For, they won't be able to link it in with The Hard Goodbye like they did in the book, because it wouldn't make sense.

Was Dwight in the bar in The Hard Goodbye graphic novel? I hope he wasn't.

Why not?

No, he wasn't. The movie screwed up on the continuity.

Nope, but Hartigan was. Only thing is, you didn't know it until That Yellow Bastard, because Frank Miller hadn't decided to connect the story till then (which is why you can see Marv in the background in That Yellow Bastard, but you can't see Hartigan in Sin City/The Hard Goodbye).

How many graphic novels are there for the Sin?

Seven, I think.

• The Hard Goodbye
• A Dame To Kill For
• The Big Fat Kill
• That Yellow Bastard
• Family Values
• Booze, Broads & Bullets
• Hell and Back

There's some short stories too. But I don't know how to get a hold of them. Will some of them be included in the graphic novels I mentioned, or are they only in comic books?

Thanks, I appreciate that!

Only in the comics I think, as my favorite one-shots are in comic form only. Starring Delia Blue-eyes, Sex and Violence and Lost, Lonely and Lethal are two one-shots to track down, and well worth the time. They are in comic form, but with no ads, which is good. They are still available in most of the shops around here, so I would think they aren't that hard to come by...


Lost, Lonely and Lethal

Sex and Violence


Both are available at the above website.

Cheers, Seds.

They won't even quite be sequels as much as continuations. I know by definition that's what a sequel is, but all these stories were there way before the movies so it's just that they need more time to tell them that they didn't have for this one feature.

Anyone have any actors they'd like to see cast for characters who weren't in the first flick?

How about Uma Thurman as Ava? She's got the big eyes, the big lips, and tends to over-act a little too.

As long as Miller and Rodriguez are involved, hell yes I want sequels. Rodriguez and Rouke have already stated that Marv could be in any potential sequel, obviously that would mean the story involving Marv would have to be a prequel. Not knowing the comics does that make sense to anyone, and if so what stories does Marv appear in before the film adaptation?

As far as i know, aside from the first series, "The Hard Goodbye," Marv only appears as a cameo in overlapping stories. He does not take the lead role in any others.