Movie Forums (http://www.movieforums.com/community/index.php)
-   Ongoing Tournaments & Brackets (http://www.movieforums.com/community/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   2nd Chance Hall of Fame (http://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?t=58033)

rauldc14 10-10-18 01:52 PM

2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
This Hall of Fame will be used for previous General Hall of Fame nominations (not winners) to have a second chance at being revisited by members and have another chance to win a Hall of Fame.

The only rule is, you cannot nominate something that you have previously nominated.

For those of us that have been in Hall of Fames before, it gives us a chance to revisit some great films. Newer members can join in too and see some of the films that have been previously nominated.

I'm looking for at least 8 to join. If I can't make that happen, well then, we will see.

Memento
https://pmcvariety.files.wordpress.c...ake.jpg?w=1000
Nominated by Edarsenal
Originally nominated by Teeter G in 2nd HOF

Le Trou
https://www.latimes.com/resizer/8L1A...QNWBYHXVOM.jpg
Nominated by Nathaniel
Originally nominated by Pussy Galore in 5th HOF

The Man From Earth
https://cdn1.thr.com/sites/default/f...cene_still.jpg
Nominated by Jabs
Originally nominated by GbGoodies in 6th HOF

Ed Wood
https://dustyflix.files.wordpress.co.../11/edwood.png
Nominated by CosmicRunaway
Originally nominated by Cobpyth in 4th HOF

Letter from an Unknown Woman
https://dwgyu36up6iuz.cloudfront.net...nown-woman.jpg
Nominated by Neiba
Originally nominated by Sane in 7th HOF

Raise the Red Lantern
https://i1.wp.com/www.vcinemashow.co...?fit=640%2C344
Nominated by Citizen Rules
Originally nominated by Christine in 6th HOF

Pierrot Le Fou
https://www.austinchronicle.com/bina...errotleFou.jpg
Nominated by MijaFrost
Originally nominated by Frightened Inmate in 6th HOF

Farewell my Concubine
https://assets.mubi.com/images/noteb...jpg?1463549450
Nominated by ThursdayNext
Originally nominated by Godoggo in 1st HOF

After Hours
https://jojud265nia2bj9sy4ah9b61-wpe...-c-default.jpg
Nominated by Rauldc
Originally nominated by Cobpyth in 2nd HOF

Anatomy of a Murder
http://www.standbyformindcontrol.com...er-still-2.png
Nominated by Siddon
Originally nominated by Seanc in 8th HOF

Reviews

CosmicRunaway LIST SENT
Ed Wood
Letter from an Unknown Woman
Memento
Raise the Red Lantern
After Hours
Anatomy of a Murder
Le Trou
The Man From Earth
Pierrot Le Fou
Farewell my Concubine

Siddon LIST SENT
After Hours
The Man from Earth
Ed Wood
Letter from an Unknown Woman
Memento
Pierrot Le Fou
Farewell my Concubine
Raise the Red Lantern
Le Trou
Anatomy of a Murder

ThursdayNext
Letter from an Unknown Woman

Jabs
Le Trou
Anatomy of a Murder
After Hours

Edarsenal
Letter from an Unknown Woman
Memento
Anatomy of a Murder
Le Trou
Ed Wood
After Hours
Raise the Red Lantern


MijaFrost
Raise the Red Lantern
Farewell my Concubine
After Hours
Letter from an Unknown Woman
The Man from Earth
Memento
Le Trou
Anatomy of a Murder

Nathaniel LIST SENT
Pierrot Le Fou
Letter from an Unknown Woman
Ed Wood
Memento
After Hours
Raise the Red Lantern
Anatomy of a Murder
Le Trou

CitizenRules LIST SENT
After Hours
Letter from an Unknown Woman
Farewell my Concubine
Memento
Ed Wood
Raise the Red Lantern
Pierrot Le Fou
The Man from Earth
Le Trou
Anatomy of a Murder


Rauldc14 LIST SENT
After Hours
Letter from an Unknown Woman
Anatomy of a Murder
Raise the Red Lantern
The Man from Earth
Memento
Le Trou
Ed Wood
Pierrot Le Fou

Neiba
Pierrot Le Fou
Memento
The Man from Earth
After Hours
Ed Wood
Letter from an Unknown Woman
Raise the Red Lantern
Le Trou

cricket 10-10-18 03:42 PM

I'm probably not going to join this, but if I do, I'll probably nominate The Aviator.

Citizen Rules 10-10-18 03:47 PM

I'm in! I think this will be fun:)

I've been looking forward to this ever since I was looking at the noms from the early Hofs and seen that there were some really choice movies choose way back in the day. Choosing will be fun as there's a lot of great films to choose from past Hofs:up:

Nathaniel 10-10-18 03:55 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
Aww no. I can't nom Day for Night again.

Citizen Rules 10-10-18 04:13 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
To see what films have been previously nominated in past Main General Hofs, check out the second post here:
Movie HALL of FAME Archives & Info

edarsenal 10-10-18 04:32 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
I'll be in. Of course!

Haven't picked one out, but I think I may go with one from one of the very early ones. But we'll see.

neiba 10-10-18 08:56 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
A time is coming when I'll be free to watch as many films per day as I want. I might join this

rauldc14 10-10-18 09:38 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
I won't make it a real rule, but I was thinking anything after the 12th Hall of Fame is ineligible. Since the 13th HOF was 2 years ago.

Siddon 10-10-18 10:23 PM

Does it have to be just the "general" Hall of Fames because my first choice was from a specialty Hall of Fame

Citizen Rules 10-10-18 10:55 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
By my count there's 160 movies that are eligible from the first 12 General HoFs. That's a lot of great movies that deserve a second chance.

rauldc14 10-11-18 10:33 AM

Originally Posted by Siddon (Post 1958445)
Does it have to be just the "general" Hall of Fames because my first choice was from a specialty Hall of Fame
Just generals this go around, sorry.

Citizen Rules 10-11-18 11:53 AM

Originally Posted by Siddon (Post 1958445)
Does it have to be just the "general" Hall of Fames because my first choice was from a specialty Hall of Fame
C'mon Siddon join:p, you can always choose that specialty Hof movie for the 18th HoF.

Nathaniel 10-11-18 04:37 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
I'll send my nomination through tomorrow.

Trying to decide between two films. One that did very well the first time it was nominated and the other not so much.

rauldc14 10-11-18 07:31 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
So far 4 confirmed members

Nathaniel
Citizen
Edarsenal-
Rauldc

Hopefully we can get a few more, but I'm cool with a little Mini Hall of Fame too.

edarsenal 10-11-18 08:26 PM

Originally Posted by Nathaniel (Post 1958643)
I'll send my nomination through tomorrow.

Trying to decide between two films. One that did very well the first time it was nominated and the other not so much.
I was tempted to consider that route about how well a nomination did, but with a nearly completely different group of participants there could easily be a varied response to any given film.

edarsenal 10-12-18 12:48 AM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
made my decision and sent my nomination in.

rauldc14 10-12-18 05:41 AM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
I made mine as well. Look forward to this!

rauldc14 10-12-18 05:41 AM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
@seanc how about taking a stroll down memory lane, it's a small one.

seanc 10-12-18 07:40 AM

Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 1958876)
@seanc how about taking a stroll down memory lane, it's a small one.
Sorry brother. I will eventually, but not this time.

Jabs 10-12-18 08:27 AM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
Can someone explain to me what does participation in this entail?

Citizen Rules 10-12-18 06:04 PM

Originally Posted by Jabs (Post 1958898)
Can someone explain to me what does participation in this entail?
If you join, you have to watch all the movies that get nominated. You get to nominate a movie and everyone who's joined watches your nomination.

And you have to write up your thoughts on the movie as you watch them, you can't nominate then just disappear, Hofs are about participation.

When the Hof is over you send in a voting list ranking all the nominations from your #1 choice on down to your least favorite of the movies in the HoF.

See the 1st Post for the specific details. Raul is the host so he sets the rules/guidelines.

Citizen Rules 10-12-18 06:11 PM

Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 1958720)
So far 4 confirmed members

Nathaniel
Citizen
Edarsenal-
Rauldc

Hopefully we can get a few more, but I'm cool with a little Mini Hall of Fame too.
I wonder if @Thursday Next would like to join? She hasn't been in an Hof for awhile.

rauldc14 10-12-18 09:24 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
Hopefully I can convince @CosmicRunaway to join too

cricket 10-12-18 09:45 PM

I'm just interested to see which of my former nominations you all pick. Joe? Killer Joe?

CosmicRunaway 10-13-18 05:54 AM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
I fully intended to join since it was first mentioned in the other thread, and I thought I even knew what I wanted to nominate. But I don't really want to go with that film any more, and I can't seem to pick a replacement.

Jabs 10-13-18 08:31 AM

Thanks for the explanation @Citizen Rules. How long do these usually last?



If it's not too rushing then I will give it a go.

CosmicRunaway 10-13-18 08:59 AM

Originally Posted by Jabs (Post 1959283)
How long do these usually last?
We typically get one week per film. So if 8 people join, the deadline will be set 8 weeks after the nominations are revealed.

Jabs 10-13-18 09:50 AM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
That's pretty good. Count me in. I will send my nomination a bit later, once I see what films are eligible for this.


Edit: Actually there was one film I really wanted to nominate irregardless of rules and I just saw it is eligible for this so I'm good.

rauldc14 10-13-18 10:25 AM

Originally Posted by CosmicRunaway (Post 1959275)
I fully intended to join since it was first mentioned in the other thread, and I thought I even knew what I wanted to nominate. But I don't really want to go with that film any more, and I can't seem to pick a replacement.
Just pick a former one of mine, then you are good :)

edarsenal 10-13-18 02:49 PM

Originally Posted by Jabs (Post 1959292)
That's pretty good. Count me in. I will send my nomination a bit later, once I see what films are eligible for this.


Edit: Actually there was one film I really wanted to nominate irregardless of rules and I just saw it is eligible for this so I'm good.
WELCOME to the Hall of Fame Jabs!!

Citizen Rules 10-13-18 03:37 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
Helpful tip, people should pick one of my past HoF noms:D At least you know someone loved them....me!

rauldc14 10-13-18 07:28 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
With Cosmic and Jabs that puts us up to 6. Maybe we can get two more yet! C'mon Thursday Next :)

MijaFrost 10-13-18 11:10 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
I'm in. Just need to chose a nom.

edarsenal 10-14-18 01:19 AM

Originally Posted by MijaFrost (Post 1959708)
I'm in. Just need to chose a nom.
YAY!!

Thursday Next 10-14-18 06:54 AM

Originally Posted by Citizen Rules (Post 1959177)
I wonder if @Thursday Next would like to join? She hasn't been in an Hof for awhile.
What counts as a while? The 1930s only just finished! I feel like I've been in halls of fame non-stop :p

I always intended to join this one, just didn't get round to signing up. Just need to narrow down my list of potential nominations.

Jabs 10-14-18 03:55 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
I'm sincerely hoping for films I've never seen before. Would be a shame to not be introduced to new stuff during something like this.

Citizen Rules 10-14-18 04:28 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
I sent in my nom:) I decided to limit myself to the General main Hofs 1-7, as I joined for the first time in the 8th Hof.

It might be fun to include what HoF our movies were from and who original nominated, well that's up to Raul:p

rauldc14 10-16-18 10:29 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
I'll take nominations through Saturday, then I'll do the reveal Sunday :)

Siddon 10-16-18 11:19 PM

Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 1960548)
I'll take nominations through Saturday, then I'll do the reveal Sunday :)

I'm 50/50 on this one, If its not an issue I'd like to wait till after the reveal. Right now I'm in three Hall of Fames and doing the horror-thon so time is an issue. I also don't know if I see much from those Halls' that I would want to vote for let alone rewatch. However if the competition is small enough like the Russian Hall than I'll do it. How many subs do you have right now?

rauldc14 10-17-18 05:46 AM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
There's 8 noms already. And yeah if your heart isn't in it then no big deal.

Thursday Next 10-18-18 05:49 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
Is there a maximum time limit or is any previous film OK? The one I was thinking of nominating is quite long (2hrs 50) but I don't want it to be a chore for fellow HoF members so I can pick something else.

rauldc14 10-18-18 08:31 PM

Originally Posted by Thursday Next (Post 1961050)
Is there a maximum time limit or is any previous film OK? The one I was thinking of nominating is quite long (2hrs 50) but I don't want it to be a chore for fellow HoF members so I can pick something else.
I see no reason on a time limit that is any different than the normal rules

edarsenal 10-18-18 10:57 PM

Originally Posted by Thursday Next (Post 1961050)
Is there a maximum time limit or is any previous film OK? The one I was thinking of nominating is quite long (2hrs 50) but I don't want it to be a chore for fellow HoF members so I can pick something else.
Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 1961113)
I see no reason on a time limit that is any different than the normal rules
The Host as spoken! And a valid point made. If it's already been in a previous HoF it IS eligible.
For me it's not the length of a film it's whether or not I like it. An hour length film can be excruciating if I can't stand it. And while nearly 3 hour films can be quite the endurance test, if it's something I enjoy, it quite easily passes.

So, if you found something you love and wish to give it a "Second Chance" then you really should go with it. And thank you for the courtesy and remarking on your concern of it's running time.

rauldc14 10-19-18 08:52 AM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
We got 8 for this so it will be a nice little HOF. Looking forward to rewatching most of these. Admittedly skeptical of a few but will be fun still :)

CosmicRunaway 10-19-18 10:11 AM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
I'm probably going to finish the 17th HoF before I watch any of the nominations for this one. I only have 3 films left for that anyway, so I probably won't be too late starting this.

I just figured I'd give everyone a heads up in case I don't get anything watched during the first week.

edarsenal 10-19-18 11:00 AM

Originally Posted by CosmicRunaway (Post 1961227)
I'm probably going to finish the 17th HoF before I watch any of the nominations for this one. I only have 3 films left for that anyway, so I probably won't be too late starting this.

I just figured I'd give everyone a heads up in case I don't get anything watched during the first week.
I'll be doing the same along with the B Movies, though I may knock one or two out depending on I bounce around.
But VERY curious to see what everyone choose.

CosmicRunaway 10-19-18 11:50 AM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
I'm looking forward to the reveal as well.

There were a handful of films I had on my shortlist to nominate, but I ultimately went with one that I only saw once, a number of years ago. I'd been planning to watch it sometime this month, and since it was eligible for this HoF, it just seemed like the right choice.

rauldc14 10-19-18 11:55 AM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
I'll get through a good two or three more for the 17th Hall of Fame and then I may bounce around between that and this.

Citizen Rules 10-19-18 12:46 PM

Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 1961209)
We got 8 for this so it will be a nice little HOF. Looking forward to rewatching most of these. Admittedly skeptical of a few but will be fun still :)
How many have you seen before? I bet a lot as you've done a number of main Hofs in the past.

Originally Posted by CosmicRunaway (Post 1961227)
I'm probably going to finish the 17th HoF before I watch any of the nominations for this one. I only have 3 films left for that anyway, so I probably won't be too late starting this.

I just figured I'd give everyone a heads up in case I don't get anything watched during the first week.
Me too. I have 3 left for the 17th and I'm not looking forward to one of them:eek:... But I'll watch those first, before starting this HoF.

Nathaniel 10-19-18 01:23 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
This is where K-On! takes its rightful place in the Hall of Fame.

Citizen Rules 10-19-18 01:37 PM

Originally Posted by Nathaniel (Post 1961327)
This is where K-On! takes its rightful place in the Hall of Fame.
Ha:p that would be a miracle if it did. It came in last in the 6th HoF. It's not even a movie is it? Isn't it a TV series?

Nathaniel 10-19-18 01:44 PM

Originally Posted by Citizen Rules (Post 1961333)
Originally Posted by Nathaniel (Post 1961327)
This is where K-On! takes its rightful place in the Hall of Fame.
Ha:p that would be a miracle if it did. It came in last in the 6th HoF. It's not even a movie is it? Isn't it a TV series?
Oh I know haha.

There was a film released after the TV series that someone nominated. It just looked so out of place when I was deciding on a nomination.

Miss Vicky 10-19-18 03:43 PM

Originally Posted by Citizen Rules (Post 1961333)
Ha:p that would be a miracle if it did. It came in last in the 6th HoF. It's not even a movie is it? Isn't it a TV series?
It's a movie. K-On! is also a TV series, but what was nominated was a movie. It's an annoying movie that was really hard to get through and I don't know WTH Guap was thinking when he nominated it, but it is a movie.

Also something tells me that the movie you're not looking forward to for the 17th HOF just might be my nomination.

edarsenal 10-19-18 04:18 PM

Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 1961277)
I'll get through a good two or three more for the 17th Hall of Fame and then I may bounce around between that and this.
I'll be doing some SERIOUS bar hopping from HoF to HoF. Should be a lot of fun.

CosmicRunaway 10-21-18 11:39 AM

I managed to finish the 17th HoF earlier than expected. I just need to finalize my list. So it looks like I won't be late starting this after all. :cool:

Jabs 10-22-18 11:15 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
Shouldn't the submissions be announced by now?

rauldc14 10-22-18 11:19 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
They should have but I slacked. Tomorrow night I promise.

rauldc14 10-23-18 08:30 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
Memento
https://pmcvariety.files.wordpress.c...ake.jpg?w=1000
Nominated by Edarsenal
Originally nominated by Teeter G in 2nd HOF

Le Trou
https://www.latimes.com/resizer/8L1A...QNWBYHXVOM.jpg
Nominated by Nathaniel
Originally nominated by Pussy Galore in 5th HOF

The Man From Earth
https://cdn1.thr.com/sites/default/f...cene_still.jpg
Nominated by Jabs
Originally nominated by GbGoodies in 6th HOF

Ed Wood
https://dustyflix.files.wordpress.co.../11/edwood.png
Nominated by CosmicRunaway
Originally nominated by Cobpyth in 4th HOF

Letter from an Unknown Woman
https://dwgyu36up6iuz.cloudfront.net...nown-woman.jpg
Nominated by Neiba
Originally nominated by Sane in 7th HOF

Raise the Red Lantern
https://i1.wp.com/www.vcinemashow.co...?fit=640%2C344
Nominated by Citizen Rules
Originally nominated by Christine in 6th HOF

Pierrot Le Fou
https://www.austinchronicle.com/bina...errotleFou.jpg
Nominated by MijaFrost
Originally nominated by Frightened Inmate in 6th HOF

Farewell my Concubine
https://assets.mubi.com/images/noteb...jpg?1463549450
Nominated by ThursdayNext
Originally nominated by Godoggo in 1st HOF

After Hours
https://jojud265nia2bj9sy4ah9b61-wpe...-c-default.jpg
Nominated by Rauldc
Originally nominated by Cobpyth in 2nd HOF

cricket 10-23-18 08:47 PM

A lot of great nominations with my favorite being Letter from an Unknown Woman.

I haven't seen Farewell My Concubine.

rauldc14 10-23-18 09:36 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
I have not seen Concubine either, as I was not a part of the first Hall of Fame (and the 12th)

I also have no recollection of seeing Pierrot Le Fou. I think I had to have it averaged in as I couldn't find a source the last time.

I am most looking forward to seeing Raise the Red Lantern and Letter from an Unknown Woman again.

I do NOT look forward to seeing The Man from Earth again, but I still will.

edarsenal 10-23-18 10:46 PM

Memento Nominated by Edarsenal
Originally nominated by Teeter G in 2nd HOF
My Introduction to Christopher Nolan and one that's been too long since my last rewatch, so. . .

Le Trou Nominated by Nathaniel
Originally nominated by Pussy Galore in 5th HOF
Have not heard of this Swan Song (the Director died two weeks after completion) but the premise of 4 inmates ready to break out of prison when a fifth inmate is transferred in; definitely has my attention.

The Man From Earth Nominated by Jabs
Originally nominated by GbGoodies in 6th HOF
Have not heard of this one but since gbgoodies originally nominated it, I'm game.

Ed Wood Nominated by CosmicRunaway
Originally nominated by Cobpyth in 4th HOF
This is f@ckin delightful since it's been so long since last I've seen this.

Letter from an Unknown Woman Nominated by Neiba
Originally nominated by Sane in 7th HOF
I actually started watching this for 40s Countdown and never finished it and always wanted to, so, YAY

Raise the Red Lantern Nominated by Citizen Rules
Originally nominated by Christine in 6th HOF
Been a few years, but from what I remember, quite beautiful visually.

Pierrot Le Fou Nominated by MijaFrost
Originally nominated by Frightened Inmate in 6th HOF
Have not heard of this one, but looks intriguing.

Farewell my Concubine Nominated by ThursdayNext
Originally nominated by Godoggo in 1st HOF
Quite a lovely film that I've always wanted to do a rewatch to. VERY cool!

After Hours Nominated by Rauldc
Originally nominated by Cobpyth in 2nd HOF
Now this should be interesting since when I actually saw this for the first time, even though it should have been something I thoroughly would enjoy, I did not, at all. And was curious to see what a rewatch would bring about.
The answer to this query shall be answered.


I am THOROUGHLY hyped! Definitely the makings for a great and intriguingly diverse HoF!!

Citizen Rules 10-23-18 10:46 PM

Good choices everyone!
I'm thinking this will be a cool and laid back Hof. I'm looking forward to watching all these films:)

Memento
- Edarsenal
Originally nominated by Teeter G in 2nd HOF
I've not seen Memento, I see it's a Nolan directed film so that will be interesting.

Le Trou - Nathaniel
Originally nominated by Pussy Galore in 5th HOF
Not seen it either, but interested as it's a French film from the 60s and I seem to respond well to them.

The Man From Earth - Jabs
Originally nominated by GBGoodies in 6th HOF
I've seen this, in fact I was the one who suggested this film to GBG. I liked it! But not sure how I'll feel on a second watch.

Ed Wood - CosmicRunaway
Originally nominated by Cobpyth in 4th HOF
Cosmic stoled my nom! This was my nom but I was slow and Raul told me it was already taken. Which is cool because I've seen this once and really wanted to see it again.

Letter from an Unknown Woman - Neiba
Originally nominated by Sane in 7th HOF
I loved this film and I hope I still do on a second watch.

Raise the Red Lanter
n - Citizen Rules
Originally nominated by Christine in 6th HOF
I've not seen this before, but I'm thinking it's right up my alley.

Pierrot Le Fou - MijaFrost
Originally nominated by Frightened Inmate in 6th HOF
Another 60s French film, fine by me! not seen it.

Farewell my Concubine
- ThursdayNext
Originally nominated by Godoggo in 1st HOF
I considered this one myself as a nom, I've not seen it but it looks good.

After Hours - Rauldc
Originally nominated by Cobpyth in 2nd HOF
Not seen it, but it has Terri Garr, so:up:

edarsenal 10-23-18 10:49 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
Looks like we have all of the first seven HoFs covered with the only repeats being 3 out of the 6th HoF. The rest have one each.

Citizen Rules 10-23-18 10:52 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
Did anybody else try to nominate something that was already taken? Or was that just me that happened to?

edarsenal 10-23-18 11:05 PM

Originally Posted by Citizen Rules (Post 1962487)
Did anybody else try to nominate something that was already taken? Or was that just me that happened to?
I actually nominated mine right out the get-go, so I got lucky with that.
In fact, I think I've only had one time that I had to pick another nomination. For the life of me, I can't remember what, but I'm pretty sure it did happen.

I looked up my review for After Hours, and it's rather befitting that raul remarked at the time how my rating saddened him.

cricket 10-23-18 11:36 PM

Originally Posted by edarsenal (Post 1962484)
After Hours Nominated by Rauldc
Originally nominated by Cobpyth in 2nd HOF
Now this should be interesting since when I actually saw this for the first time, even though it should have been something I thoroughly would enjoy, I did not, at all. And was curious to see what a rewatch would bring about.
The first time I saw it I didn't care for it, and then I loved it the second time. Only thing is the first time was at the movies when it was out, and the second time was about 3 years ago.

cricket 10-23-18 11:38 PM

Originally Posted by Citizen Rules (Post 1962485)

Raise the Red Lanter
n - Citizen Rules
Originally nominated by Christine in 6th HOF
I've not seen this before, but I'm thinking it's right up my alley.
You're going to like that a lot I think.

cricket 10-23-18 11:38 PM

Both of you guys will like Le Trou.

edarsenal 10-23-18 11:51 PM

Originally Posted by cricket (Post 1962491)
The first time I saw it I didn't care for it, and then I loved it the second time. Only thing is the first time was at the movies when it was out, and the second time was about 3 years ago.
I'm hoping that will be the case.

Originally Posted by cricket (Post 1962493)
Both of you guys will like Le Trou.
I have a strong feeling I will. Seeing that Pussy Galore originally nominated it, is a very good sign for me.

MijaFrost 10-24-18 03:01 AM

I too am excited about Le Trou, which I haven't seen yet. I've been kind of fixated on the '60s in French cinema over the past few months.

I was also thinking of nominating Ed Wood! Good thing I chose something different. I only watched it once, quite a long time ago, but had really enjoyed it and later especially purchased the DVD through Amazon since I couldn't find it anywhere.

The Man from Earth I've seen at least twice before. Possibly three times. It's been years now, so I'm looking forward to another viewing.

It's also been years since my one-time watch of Memento. Sadly I no longer have that DVD, but another copy shouldn't be difficult to locate.

Letter from an Unknown Woman is one I've been telling myself lately that I should watch, so I'm glad to see it here.

Raise the Red Lantern is another I'd been meaning to view this year.

Also intrigued about Farewell My Concubine and After Hours, which have both been on my watchlist.

CosmicRunaway 10-24-18 03:46 AM

Originally Posted by Citizen Rules (Post 1962485)
Cosmic stoled my nom!
Originally Posted by MijaFrost (Post 1962517)
I was also thinking of nominating Ed Wood!
I was slow deciding on a nomination, and was going to include a back-up because I had a feeling that someone already nominated it. But I decided not to, and when Raul didn't come back and tell me to pick something else, I was pleasantly surprised haha.

We have a nice mix of films I'm familiar with, and ones I haven't seen before. :up:

Memento - I used to love this film but I haven't seen it in ages. Will be interesting to see if it holds up.

Le Trou - I don't think I've seen this, though I've certainly heard about it before.

The Man from Earth - I had to watch this for an Archaeology in Film class, though it was a little out of place. I think at the time our Professor couldn't find a better example of a Cro-Magnon character. I thought it was extremely boring, however that screenshot does not look familiar so perhaps this is not even the same film.

Ed Wood - Apparently I managed to snag a highly sought after nomination! I've only seen this once, and I saw it before I had even seen any of Wood's films. I'd already been planning to watch it sometime this month, so its eligibility was quite convenient.

Letter from an Unknown Woman - This looks familiar but I'm not sure if I've seen it before. I keep getting films from this era mixed up.

Raise the Red Lantern - Will be my first time watching this.

Pierrot Le Fou
- I've seen at least part of this, but I don't think I've seen the entire thing. The fact that I'm not certain about that means it's definitely due for a rewatch haha.

Farewell my Concubine - Another first watch for me.

After Hours - I watched this for the Chain Challenge awhile ago. I'm hoping I enjoy it more on a second viewing.

Jabs 10-24-18 04:36 AM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
I have seen and loved Memento, After Hours and Ed Wood. Excited to check out the rest, two of which were already in my list.

Siddon 10-24-18 08:27 AM

Okay..I'll play even though this is my fourth Hall of Fame this group of noms is particularly good, and I can post my first review tomorrow as I literally just watched one of them

rauldc14 10-24-18 10:09 AM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
I'm cool with Siddon still joining if everyone else is?

Jabs 10-24-18 10:30 AM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
Fine by me

CosmicRunaway 10-24-18 10:36 AM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
I'm cool with Siddon joining. :up:

neiba 10-24-18 11:27 AM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
Don't know if anybody said this already, but I think the photo from Man from Earth is wrong!

I've seen them all except for 3: After Hours, Ed Wood and Farewell my Concubine.

Gonna rewatch some, while a few are huge favourites which I watched more than once!

neiba 10-24-18 11:33 AM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
Memento - Edarsenal - probably the best from Nolan together with his last movie, Dunkirk. Watched it twice.

Le Trou - Nathaniel - Amazing film! Gonna love rewatching this one. I was going to nominate this one but it was already taken.

The Man From Earth - Jabs - Watched 3 times already. Love the premise and execution on this one.

Ed Wood - CosmicRunaway - new watch for me.

Letter from an Unknown Woman - Neiba - my own nom and one of the films I have closer to my heart and that I would never find if it wasn't for the HoFs.

Raise the Red Lantern - Citizen Rules - Such a beautiful film. Was thinking about nominating this one. Gonna love the rewatch.

Pierrot Le Fou - MijaFrost - Watched it for the 2nd time a couple of months ago on big screen. Best Godard by far and a personal favourite.

Farewell my Concubine - ThursdayNext - new watch for me.

After Hours - Rauldc - new watch for me

edarsenal 10-24-18 01:52 PM

Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 1962543)
I'm cool with Siddon still joining if everyone else is?
hell, yeah!! That'll be great!



Also, for anyone searching, A Letter From an Unknown Woman has a few versions on youtube, so there should be a good chance for availability for all.

Nathaniel 10-24-18 04:06 PM

It will be the weekend before I get a chance to watch one of these but props to everyone as these are great picks.

The only one I haven't seen is The Man from Earth.

I came pretty close to nominating Raise the Red Lantern. Back when Zhang Yimou was firing out great movie after great movie with Gong Li at her best. I'll probably start with that.

Jabs 10-24-18 04:49 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
I nominated The Man from Earth because it is an unusual film and that's why I love it so much. It certainly has its flaws, but it's one definitely worth checking out.


PS. My first choice was Incendies but it was picked the HoF that's running now so it wouldn't make sense to go with that even if it was eligible..

CosmicRunaway 10-24-18 05:01 PM

Originally Posted by Jabs (Post 1962720)
PS. My first choice was Incendies but it was picked the HoF that's running now so it wouldn't make sense to go with that even if it was eligible..
I haven't seen you around very much (since I don't really leave this subforum), but I see you have excellent taste. :cool:

Jabs 10-24-18 05:15 PM

Originally Posted by Citizen Rules (Post 1962485)
Good choices everyone!
The Man From Earth - Jabs
Originally nominated by GBGoodies in 6th HOF
I've seen this, in fact I was the one who suggested this film to GBG. I liked it! But not sure how I'll feel on a second watch.

Not sure how much of it you remember, but I have found that with multiple viewings you discover a bit more depth in the interactions knowing how the film concludes.

Citizen Rules 10-24-18 05:57 PM

Originally Posted by Jabs (Post 1962733)
Not sure how much of it you remember, but I have found that with multiple viewings you discover a bit more depth in the interactions knowing how the film concludes.
I hope so:) I wrote a review on it here at MoFo. Below is an excerpt from that review. Spoiler free and mainly about the background of the writers.

The Man From Earth was written by the famous sci fi & Star Trek screen writer, Jerome Bixby. This is his last work. The film was made after his passing by his son Emerson Bixby who promised his father to be true to the story. Jerome Bixby also wrote the original Star Trek episode: Requiem for Methuselah, which has similarities to this film.

The Man From Earth is a small budget, indie film, shot on only one location, a remote cabin in the mountains. This is a dialogue rich, existential film about how people would treat a friend who claims that he's immortal. A thought provoking study of human strengths and fears.
@rauldc14 that's not my official review, so don't link it. I'm going to rewatch the movie and post my thoughts later.

Jabs 10-24-18 06:03 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
I have a full review on this on another site but I would rather not sway anyone just yet. I will post it here once everyone has watched it.

CosmicRunaway 10-24-18 06:03 PM

1 Attachment(s)
https://www.movieforums.com/communit...chmentid=49217

Ed Wood (1994)
Directed By: Tim Burton
Starring: Johnny Depp, Martin Landau, Sarah Jessica Parker

Although it is biographic in nature, no knowledge about the real Ed Wood or his films is necessary to enjoy Burton's Ed Wood. It is not a documentary, and instead presents a romanticised version of events that is intentionally idealized in order to support its themes and to celebrate the spirit of filmmaking. It is an incredibly optimistic film with a typical Hollywood ending, which normally would have me rolling my eyes, but I found the story to be so compelling that it was impossible not to get swept along for the ride.

From the very start, the cinematography is amazing. I think that this is easily Burton's finest film, since you can see touches of his style, but it enhances the story without overwhelming the picture like it unfortunately does with some of his later works. Those opening credits which incorporate elements from some of Wood's feature films are incredibly well executed, and the music that plays really helps set the atmosphere. It's a great homage. The lighting throughout the film is excellent, as are the recreations of key scenes from Wood's films.

The casting in Ed Wood is practically perfect. Every performance, even the smaller ones are entertaining. Martin Landau was phenomenal as Bela Lugosi, and while I have no idea what Ed Wood really sounded like, Depp's interpretation is a great match for the tone and quirkiness of the film. I've become very bored of his habit for playing odd characters, but I still find him charming in this role. This is only my second time seeing this film, and I'm surprised it's taken this long to watch it again, because I really enjoyed it the first time, and appreciated it even more this time around.




Thursday Next 10-24-18 06:33 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
I've seen all of the nominated films. There's a mix of films I loved, hated and was fairly indifferent to, so it'll be interesting to see if I feel the same second time around :lol:

I picked Farewell My Concubine because it's great, obviously, but also because I think it's underseen and being from the first hall of fame I thought a lot of people might not have seen it or might have forgotten it.

gbgoodies 10-25-18 12:54 AM

Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 1962463)
The Man From Earth
https://cdn1.thr.com/sites/default/f...cene_still.jpg
Nominated by Jabs
Originally nominated by GbGoodies in 6th HOF
Originally Posted by neiba (Post 1962580)
Don't know if anybody said this already, but I think the photo from Man from Earth is wrong!

I think that picture is from The Man from Earth: Holocene (2017), which is a sequel to The Man from Earth (2007).

neiba 10-25-18 06:22 AM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
Originally Posted by gbgoodies (Post 1962832)
Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 1962463)
The Man From Earth
https://cdn1.thr.com/sites/default/f...cene_still.jpg
Nominated by Jabs
Originally nominated by GbGoodies in 6th HOF
Originally Posted by neiba (Post 1962580)
Don't know if anybody said this already, but I think the photo from Man from Earth is wrong!

I think that picture is from The Man from Earth: Holocene (2017), which is a sequel to The Man from Earth (2007).
Uuuuh, I didn't know there was a sequel!!! Is it good?

Jabs 10-25-18 09:03 AM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
Horrible and filled with annoying teens.

Citizen Rules 10-25-18 11:45 AM

Originally Posted by Jabs (Post 1962865)
Horrible and filled with annoying teens.
Agreed! The Man from Earth: Holocene (2017) was so bad that I shut it off after the first 10 minutes. Clearly only made as a money grab.

Siddon 10-26-18 11:05 AM

So @Rauldc am I in this or not?

CosmicRunaway 10-26-18 07:26 PM

Re: 2nd Chance Hall of Fame
 
I watched Letter from an Unknown Woman earlier, but I'm not sure if I'll get anything written tonight. It's been a long day and I'm quite tired. I have some notes written down but I can't seem to form anything into sentences. Is 8:00 too early to go to bed on a Friday night? Asking for a friend. :shifty:

cricket 10-26-18 07:49 PM

Originally Posted by CosmicRunaway (Post 1963308)
I watched Letter from an Unknown Woman earlier, but I'm not sure if I'll get anything written tonight. It's been a long day and I'm quite tired. I have some notes written down but I can't seem to form anything into sentences. Is 8:00 too early to go to bed on a Friday night? Asking for a friend. :shifty:
I used to try to stay up but now I just give in whenever I'm tired.

rauldc14 10-26-18 09:34 PM

Originally Posted by Siddon (Post 1963102)
So @Rauldc am I in this or not?
Yes!

Siddon 10-26-18 10:07 PM

https://a.ltrbxd.com/resized/sm/uplo...g?k=af0ddbcc07



After Hours is Martin Scorsese's attempt at a sex comedy, if you though well that sounds weird it pretty much is. The basic premise of the film is a New York office drone decides to go out and hook up with a girl he met at a cafe. On his way to meet up with her his twenty dollar bill flies out of the window of a cab leaving him broke and stranded in New York.


Over the course of the evening he runs into a variety of weird situations with the strange people who live outside his yuppie world. For a film like this you have a series of episodes and naturally with that you end comparing them to each other. And the only issue I really had with the film is that at one point it becomes a bit too wacky. I think the film works at it's best when Hackett is dealing with sexual issues with women but when he branches out into the other aspects of nightlife society the film kinda ratchet's down. Cheech and Chong show up and they just feel incredibly out of place.

Siddon 10-27-18 02:00 AM

https://dallasfilmnow.files.wordpres...from-earth.jpg


The Man From Earth is the story of a man who invites seven people from his college for a farewell party. The man is leaving everyone he's known for the last ten years and wondering to some new place. He reveals himself to be a caveman who is immortal and that he must leave.


The Man from Earth feels like an episode Amazing Stories padded out to a feature length film role. The problem with a film like this is that it has both too many characters and also too few. Having seven people in a room question this one person from 10 million years ago felt very faked and staged whereas a group of three or four would have been slightly more believable. The other problem is that by having seven extra people you'd want to have sub plots and focus on how his story would affect those people, by doing this you get more into the human condition. Sadly this film just feels like a college lecture or worst a strange little propaganda film for some sort of religion.



I really wouldn't mind seeing this film get remade with a different director and setting because while the story feels important the execution was somewhat lacking for my taste.

Jabs 10-27-18 07:15 AM

I will be starting today with Le Trou. Premise sounds both great and familiar. I am sure it's been mentioned at some point in the thread, but what is the time limit on this? Because since I completed the challenge for 2018 I need some motivation to watch more films so I joined two HoF and a Film Club.

CosmicRunaway 10-27-18 08:51 AM

Originally Posted by Jabs (Post 1963390)
I am sure it's been mentioned at some point in the thread, but what is the time limit on this?
We get one week per nomination. It would have been 9 weeks from when Raul posted the reveal, however Siddon's nomination has yet to announced, so we should get around 10 weeks to complete the HoF.

CosmicRunaway 10-27-18 08:54 AM

1 Attachment(s)
https://www.movieforums.com/communit...chmentid=49257

Letter from an Unknown Woman
(1948)
Directed By: Max Ophüls
Starring: Joan Fontaine, Louis Jourdan, Art Smith

Letter from an Unknown Woman is a bittersweet story about unrequited love, that deals with obsession and consequences. Despite the fact that the central figures are a stalker and a playboy, the characters are strangely endearing and their ill-fated romance is actually quite compelling. Many scenes take place at night, giving the film an almost noir tone at times, where the gloomy atmosphere is never noticed by the characters on screen, since they are too wrapped up in their own fantasies to see the reality of the situation at hand.

The cinematography is amazing. The structure has an incredible symmetry to it, with many shots being mirrored later in the film. The framing is the same for these scenes, but the context or perception has changed dramatically. The camera moves elegantly as it glides across rooms, and the sets and costumes are beautifully crafted. Lighting was handled extremely well, enhancing the mood of scenes without drawing too much attention to itself.

From certain angles early in the film, Fontaine did look a little old to be playing a teenager, though for the most part she looked passable, and before the reserved Lisa matures in the final act, her shyness did give her an incredibly youthful aura that helps sell her character. Louis Jourdan was very charming in his role as Stefan, and the two had great chemistry together. Supposedly the film diverges from its source material, particularly in Stefan's character arc, but from what I've read, I think I'd vastly prefer the cinematic version. The circumstances in the film seem more inherently tragic, and the ending was entirely appropriate. I thoroughly enjoyed the film, and I'm glad it was nominated.



All times are GMT -3. The time now is 03:26 PM.

Powered by: vBulletin, Copyright, ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright © Movie Forums