Movie Forums (http://www.movieforums.com/community/index.php)
-   General Movie Discussion (http://www.movieforums.com/community/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   Best Director who NEVER made a bad movie? (http://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?t=43823)

matt72582 12-10-15 07:28 PM

Best Director who NEVER made a bad movie?
 
Some of my favorite directors have made some bad movies, so don't include them.

I would go with Stanley Kubrick. His worst film is still pretty good.

Gideon58 12-10-15 07:39 PM

I can't think of a director off the top of my head who NEVER made a bad movie, except for a director who only made one movie...like the late Steve Gordon, who only directed one film, the 1981 classic Arthur and died the following year. But very director who's made more than one movie has at least one stinker on their resume.

Marlon Brando 12-10-15 07:44 PM

Re: Best Director who NEVER made a bad movie?
 
None.

edarsenal 12-10-15 08:16 PM

Re: Best Director who NEVER made a bad movie?
 
The only one I can come with is Billy Wilder, though I can't say I've seen every single film of his, so I could be wrong

foster 12-10-15 08:19 PM

Re: Best Director who NEVER made a bad movie?
 
One of my favorites of course, Chris McQuarrie.
I'm sure you guys have heard me talk about him before.

http://cdn.movieweb.com/img.news/NE37HJeBdCnl66_1_1.jpg

DIRECTED:
The Way of the Gun
Jack Reacher
Mission Impossible: Rogue Nation

Currently he is writing the next MI film which he will also direct.

Rocket_Sam74 12-10-15 09:15 PM

Re: Best Director who NEVER made a bad movie?
 
I've only seen M:I 5 from McQuarrie, so I don't know. Still, if his other movies are as good and flawless as M:I 5, then he's really good.


I'd also go with Tarantino and (haters gonna hate), Michael Bay
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v7ssUivM-eM














Just kidding on that last one though :D

foster 12-10-15 09:21 PM

Originally Posted by Rocket_Sam74 (Post 1421565)
I've only seen M:I 5 from McQuarrie, so I don't know. Still, if his other movies are as good and flawless as M:I 5, then he's really good.
You definitely should watch the others!!
The way of the gun has the most realistic gun battles I've ever seen.

It's not like taken where liam neeson can hide behind a couch and magically not get shot. Hell no, way of the gun you stand next to a door someone will shoot you through the wall.

He began his career as a writer. Most people know The usual suspects, he wrote that. I think that's why he doesn't have any bad films, because he spent so much time in the industry before he started directing.

Derek Vinyard 12-10-15 09:26 PM

Re: Best Director who NEVER made a bad movie?
 
Christopher Nolan
Tony Kaye
Danny Boyle

matt72582 12-10-15 09:28 PM

Originally Posted by edarsenal (Post 1421537)
The only one I can come with is Billy Wilder, though I can't say I've seen every single film of his, so I could be wrong
Billy Wilder never made a bad drama (from the handful I saw)

AdamUpBxtch 12-10-15 10:14 PM

Re: Best Director who NEVER made a bad movie?
 
This would be hard, because even my favorite director Spielberg has one film I do not like (A.I.). I'll have to get back to you on this one.

Redwell 12-10-15 10:22 PM

Re: Best Director who NEVER made a bad movie?
 
James Gray

Rocket_Sam74 12-10-15 10:33 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Originally Posted by foster (Post 1421571)
You definitely should watch the others!!
The way of the gun has the most realistic gun battles I've ever seen.

It's not like taken where liam neeson can hide behind a couch and magically not get shot. Hell no, way of the gun you stand next to a door someone will shoot you through the wall.

He began his career as a writer. Most people know The usual suspects, he wrote that. I think that's why he doesn't have any bad films, because he spent so much time in the industry before he started directing.



...I'll think about it...

foster 12-10-15 10:38 PM

Re: Best Director who NEVER made a bad movie?
 
Not everyone appreciates realism in films, but for me it's such a breath of fresh air.

Movies like Django where people get shot and fly backward 20 feet.. well, I'm not sure I have the words right now to express how stupid that is. Newton's 3rd law of physics state that the person holding the gun would fly back 20 feet too when they shot it - if guns actually exerted that sort of force.

I picked on that one because it's in your top 10 :lol:
Makes me think maybe The Way of the Gun isn't for you?

Daniel M 12-10-15 11:04 PM

Re: Best Director who NEVER made a bad movie?
 
Django Unchained isn't supposed to be realistic, but whilst we're on the subject, Tarantino hasn't directed a bad film :)

Iroquois 12-11-15 01:15 AM

Re: Best Director who NEVER made a bad movie?
 
Leone was the first name to come to mind, though I still feel like he's a debatable example.

Lucas 12-11-15 01:39 AM

Re: Best Director who NEVER made a bad movie?
 
Tarkovsky, duh.

rambond 12-11-15 04:07 AM

Re: Best Director who NEVER made a bad movie?
 
yup christopher nolan has never done a bad film, the worst of the great ones is the dark knight rises for my own taste, i dont know if you guys agree, but he lately made a superb film which i like a lot, in Interstellar, top notch film.

90sAce 12-11-15 07:27 AM

Scorsese never made any bad ones that I know of

vinkevinnn 12-11-15 07:39 AM

Re: Best Director who NEVER made a bad movie?
 
Christopher Nolan and Quentin Tarantino and Denis Villeneuve

Rocket_Sam74 12-11-15 12:08 PM

Originally Posted by foster (Post 1421616)
Not everyone appreciates realism in films, but for me it's such a breath of fresh air.

Movies like Django where people get shot and fly backward 20 feet.. well, I'm not sure I have the words right now to express how stupid that is. Newton's 3rd law of physics state that the person holding the gun would fly back 20 feet too when they shot it - if guns actually exerted that sort of force.

I picked on that one because it's in your top 10 :lol:
Makes me think maybe The Way of the Gun isn't for you?


I don't really care about "realism" in awesome scenes when I see them. I also appreciate realism but I wouldn't say three's one I prefer. I'll definitely check it out...it's only that the movie you told me about didn't get as good reviews.


Plus, if you really wanted to make fun of unrealistic westerns, you should've talked about the fact that people take like 30 mins to die even though they've been shot 1000 times...and also the fact that there's almost no blood in those old westerns :D


All times are GMT -3. The time now is 08:37 PM.

Powered by: vBulletin, Copyright, ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright © Movie Forums