Insane number of nazi references in movies
If you happen to notice, vast number of films over the years had countless number of nazi references irrespective of genre. Comedy, horror, dramas etc. all of them have it. Is it because filmmakers by and large are influenced in someway by holocaust as part of learning about human condition ? or is it an easy reference to make so more number of audience can understand what a scene is about ?
I noticed this while watching a few good men and a random nazi reference is thrown in there. |
Re: Insane number of nazi references in movies
If you want to divide the 20th century with some sort of historical before and after line, it's hard to think of a more clear one than the nazis specifically and WW II in general. If a plot writer wants something that makes someone evil in an instant, just by their identity, being a nazi will do that without much in the way of plot exposition. Nazis make the ideal boogyman, so proto-nazis, nazis during the reich and nazis hiding out, engaging in conspiracies, after 1945, are sort of like bank robber gangs in old westerns and you can make them evil without many objections or PC considerations.
|
Re: Insane number of nazi references in movies
It's kind of just lazy writing to be honest, but that's just my two pennies, party on.
|
Re: Insane number of nazi references in movies
It's because they're easy shorthand for universally-recognized evil.
|
It's also universal short-hand for certain specific evils, such as ethnic cleansing and military fascism, the latter being directly relevant to the core moral conflict in Few Good Men and Col. Jessup's tendencies, so, at least in that case, the reference isn't exactly random or arbitrary.
|
Re: Insane number of nazi references in movies
Movie scripts need to be economical, time wise, so what's easier than making a character evil right out of the gate by having them be a nazi. What's curious about that is that 70-some years after the demise of the reich, well past the life span of any nazi that's not in assisted living, well past the era where Germany is contemplating some sort of conquest, we can still use those characters as a template for evil, at least evil of a European type. There's a whole world out there, however, where there have been murderous despots that could be grist for some other sort of movie evil, but nazis do seem to resonate the best, at least in the universe of Euro-American movies. I don't understand why Stalin hasn't ever caught on the same way.
|
Originally Posted by skizzerflake (Post 2191114)
Movie scripts need to be economical, time wise, so what's easier than making a character evil right out of the gate by having them be a nazi. What's curious about that is that 70-some years after the demise of the reich, well past the life span of any nazi that's not in assisted living, well past the era where Germany is contemplating some sort of conquest, we can still use those characters as a template for evil, at least evil of a European type. There's a whole world out there, however, where there have been murderous despots that could be grist for some other sort of movie evil, but nazis do seem to resonate the best, at least in the universe of Euro-American movies. I don't understand why Stalin hasn't ever caught on the same way.
|
Re: Insane number of nazi references in movies
Without getting into any explicitly political arguments, I think it's more to do with the fact that Hitler came first and immediately became such a distinct figurehead for the very concept of human evil that nobody could really displace him as such in the popular consciousness and instead invite comparisons against him. I suppose another key difference is that Stalin never started a world war or a similarly aggressive military campaign so there is less of a perception of him as an individual enemy that had to be fought like Hitler.
|
Originally Posted by Iroquois (Post 2191558)
Without getting into any explicitly political arguments, I think it's more to do with the fact that Hitler came first and immediately became such a distinct figurehead for the very concept of human evil that nobody could really displace him as such in the popular consciousness and instead invite comparisons against him. I suppose another key difference is that Stalin never started a world war or a similarly aggressive military campaign so there is less of a perception of him as an individual enemy that had to be fought like Hitler.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_invasion_of_Poland Certainly nothing personal and I very much agree with your earlier points. |
Originally Posted by Iroquois (Post 2191558)
Without getting into any explicitly political arguments, I think it's more to do with the fact that Hitler came first and immediately became such a distinct figurehead for the very concept of human evil that nobody could really displace him as such in the popular consciousness and instead invite comparisons against him. I suppose another key difference is that Stalin never started a world war or a similarly aggressive military campaign so there is less of a perception of him as an individual enemy that had to be fought like Hitler.
That said, I agree with much of what Gulfport Doc says, as I also consider the atrocities committed by the communists to be just as horrific. |
Originally Posted by James D. Gardiner (Post 2191576)
Well I'd put this forward:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_invasion_of_Poland Certainly nothing personal and I very much agree with your earlier points. |
Originally Posted by aronisred (Post 2190733)
If you happen to notice, vast number of films over the years had countless number of nazi references irrespective of genre. Comedy, horror, dramas etc. all of them have it. Is it because filmmakers by and large are influenced in someway by holocaust as part of learning about human condition ? or is it an easy reference to make so more number of audience can understand what a scene is about ?
I noticed this while watching a few good men and a random nazi reference is thrown in there. Since WWII, it's been a cheap go-to as a reference point for evil. If you want to make sure the baddie is clearly seen as the baddie, the Nazi-fy him. Don't let it concern you that Nazi's had similar go-to devices, because you know that the hero you're writing is good and the villain you're writing is bad. Despite the splash that the Devil made in The Exorcist in the 70's, people don't really believe in metaphysical evil anymore. If Oprah and consumerism fill the God-shaped hole in our lives, Nazis have filled the Devil-shaped hole. We need a reference point for evil, lest we become totally debilitated by the relativism implicit in the materialist worldview, and the Nazis are it, an icon, a reference point, a place to definitely draw the line. Of course, it doesn't take long for images to wear into cliches. After WWII, Nazism was felt as a real threat. It only took a few decades, however, for Daleks on Dr. WHO to represent Nazism as goofy robotic trashcans and for Hogan's Heroes to depict them as baffoons. Nazis are EZ Mac evil. Today, however, in our increasingly polarized society, Nazis are becoming quite scary again, because our bards want to raise the alarm about wolves among the sheep in the real world. When the world is scary and conflicted, we need a tangible Devil to fight, and so we've seen an uptick in Nazi references in media. Nazis are everywhere, or so we are told by moralizing pundits, and films are echoing this message. Consider the original Star Wars trilogy. There were visual references to fascism and Nazism, but it was light. There was just enough there to establish that the Empire was indeed B-A-D bad. In the new Star Wars, however, we have been explicitly told by its new makers that the Empire is a White Supremacist organization (which makes absolutely no sense in a universe with endless species) and that the Force is Female (because that matters, I guess - because you have to smash the Patriarchy which is White Supremacist and therefore... ...A Witch!) and the visual references in the set design and clothing and dialogue lay it all on very thick now. When General Hux (Sic? I don't really even care) gives his rally speech in one of the new films, he might as well have been shouting in German. |
Originally Posted by Corax (Post 2192708)
Nazis are everywhere, or so we are told by moralizing pundits, and films are echoing this message.
It is funny, though, how the recent alt-right/Proud Boog/Qanod folks have a more complicated appreciation of Axis fascism mixed with a healthy dollop of Putin-philia, so maybe it's no longer necessary to blame only one historical national evil over another. And, humorously, they're also inclined toward Christian Monarchism, so we can add a more canonical historical evil to the mix to boot. |
Re: Insane number of nazi references in movies
Reminder to keep this centered around cinema. Thanks.
|
Originally Posted by Yoda (Post 2192733)
Reminder to keep this centered around cinema. Thanks.
|
Originally Posted by Jinnistan (Post 2192729)
Yes, pundits. As well as more objective facts and stats showing levels of organization and spread of racially-pure fascist ideology unseen since the Nazis. Somehow, I doubt it's all click-inspired hype from the JSM, as many of these groups would claim.
What matters is, just as early modern Europe had "witches on the brain" (as my old history prof explained), our current era is fixated with this particular Devil. We are in an apocalyptic sort of age. Politics is now polarized to the point where you can lose friends or get beat up for holding the "wrong" opinion on a question. We see each other, more and more, as "threats to society" rather then neighbors. Thus, fantasy images in film of conspiracies of literal Nazis give voice to the tensions we feel in our day-to-day lives, so much so, that you cannot resist entering into a filmic discussion and insisting that the Devil is really real. Hail Hydra! |
Originally Posted by Corax (Post 2192739)
In addition, if your criteria for identifying the Devil become more inclusive (e.g., voted Trump = Nazi)
|
Originally Posted by GulfportDoc (Post 2191485)
It's because the Fourth Estate and academia are congenial to communism, whereas they somehow have decided that Nazism was more evil. The strange part is that few of them understand the differences and similarities, or are they aware of the tenets of each, including their outcomes to society.
|
3 Attachment(s)
Originally Posted by Corax (Post 2192708)
...Consider the original Star Wars trilogy. There were visual references to fascism and Nazism, but it was light. There was just enough there to establish that the Empire was indeed B-A-D bad...
https://www.movieforums.com/communit...chmentid=75843 Star Trek original series 'Patterns of Force' https://www.movieforums.com/communit...chmentid=75844 Star Trek: Voyager 'The Killing Game' https://www.movieforums.com/communit...chmentid=75845 Star Trek: Enterprise 'Storm Front' |
Originally Posted by Jinnistan (Post 2192749)
I'm simply going to isolate this one thing because I clearly did not refer to Trump voters as Nazis in my post, and none of my links do either. This is a good example, based on the posting history, for why I sometimes feel compelled to pre-empt Corax's dishonesty. So in this case, I feel a right of self-defense to call out this ad hominem lie.
|
All times are GMT -3. The time now is 12:20 PM. |
Powered by: vBulletin, Copyright, ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
User Alert System provided by
Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) -
vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright © Movie Forums