Re: The fate of 1917 at the oscars and how it was inevitable
That's true, my favorite war movie is probably The Battle Of Algiers, which hardly has any character development, and is very situation based. Schindler's List is also a favorite which has a lot more character development.
|
Originally Posted by ironpony (Post 2068541)
Well I watched the movie. It was good and pretty impressive, but I guess I could see what people mean when there is not much for character development? Perhaps it should be viewed the same way as a movie like The Good, The Bad, and the Ugly, where it's not a character study, but more about the spectacle of it's world itself?
Originally Posted by hell_storm2004 (Post 2068552)
Character development in a war movie is not that important to be honest for me. Unless you are making a movie on an individual in who took part in a war. Like Hacksaw Ridge.
|
Originally Posted by tgm1024 (Post 2068583)
I'm not sure what a war movie is without character development. A documentary of events only?
Sort of, yeah. |
Originally Posted by tgm1024 (Post 2068583)
For me anway, I see GBU as entirely about character development. It's a story about tense accomplices learning how to respect and become somewhat reluctant friends but keeping their distance because they realize that "a scorpion is still a scorpion".
I'm not sure what a war movie is without character development. A documentary of events only? But when it comes to 1917, I have seen six of the best picture nominees now, and of those six, I think I would put 1917 third, after Parasite and Jojo Rabbit. So of those six, I agree that the Oscars picked the best movie. |
Originally Posted by ironpony (Post 2068647)
Oh well, it's just I found that they were not really being reluctant friends but just pretending to be so they can each reach the gold. So I didn't think it was character development much, when they were just pretending, and were still the same characters in the end, it seemed, without going through any drastic changes. It felt like more of a plot driven story to me than character driven, not that that's bad though.
The only two dimensional character of the three that I can see is Bad, who consistently has no depth whatsoever, no growth, doesn't change a bit, and was there as literally, just "the bad guy". |
Re: The fate of 1917 at the oscars and how it was inevitable
Oh okay, yes there little things here and there throughout the movie, but I just felt the characters never really changed in the end. It's not something like Oldboy for random example, where the main character is a completely different person compared to at the beginning of the movie, as far as character development goes.
|
Originally Posted by ironpony (Post 2068791)
Oh okay, yes there little things here and there throughout the movie, but I just felt the characters never really changed in the end. It's not something like Oldboy for random example, where the main character is a completely different person compared to at the beginning of the movie, as far as character development goes.
But yeah, I see what you're saying. Of all the classic(?)-era westerns (maybe 20's to the 70's), which movie would you say had the most thought out and complex character growth? |
Re: The fate of 1917 at the oscars and how it was inevitable
Oh I see what you mean, perhaps I got character development confused with character evolution. So maybe what I meant was that 1917, didn't have a lot of character evolution in it. But as for westerns a lot of them suffer from characters being the same throughout, which isn't bad cause they are still fun, but it still feels like a limitation.
If I had to pick ones where the characters change into a different person at the end, off the top of my head, I would say The Searchers, and maybe Little Big Man, but maybe that's not a huge change that the Little Big Man character goes through? |
All times are GMT -3. The time now is 10:13 AM. |
Powered by: vBulletin, Copyright, ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
User Alert System provided by
Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) -
vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright © Movie Forums