September 11th, motion picture?
 

I really don't think it's needed. I believe it will flop, and it would need a HUGE budget for it.

The movie would be HILARIOUS!

Bush would be at his ranch for two hours, at a book reading session for thirty minutes, and wide-eyed looked the rest of the time.

I rather clip my nails then watch a movie like that. What story line would you base it on....it would look like a docuementry if you didn't have a story to it.

There is one called The Guys, about a fire captain who lost a lot of men in 911, and had to eulogize 4 of them. I sw the play, which was pretty good, but I've heard the film sucks. I really think it's too soon, even now, to not be really upsetting to a lot of people.

There is a fantastic documentary called 9/11 by 2 french brothers Jules & Gedeon Naudet. It's their footage that everyone saw of the plane hitting the building, they started out making a docu on probie firemen in New York, and soon become involved at the twin towers. One of the brothers is inside the second tower, and uses the light from his camera to find his way out. I think this was shown on HBO, it was on BBC over here, but I highly recommend it. Having shared a flat in NY with a fireman, IMO it's too early to make a film, emotions are still high, and memories are still fresh in the minds of those who lost loved ones.

Didn't see the play, but the film is quite good, actually. Very subtle and real, without overplaying the emotions to soap opera level, letting the inherent drama reveal itself instead of constantly underscoring it. Anthony LaPaglia and Sigourney Weaver are both very good in the leads. Sigourney's husband Jim Simpson directed, and the original playwright Anne Nelson adapted the screenplay with him. Simpson, Weaver and LaPaglia were all involved with the stage production as well.

http://www.playbill.com/images/photo...1048891574.jpg

http://www.juilliard.edu/update/jour...er_theguys.jpg
Sigourney Weaver and Bill Murray in Anne Nelson’s The
Guys, an Off-Broadway play produced at the Flea, a
theater not far from the World Trade Center that re-
sponded to the aftermath of the tragedy.

i believe if there was an action film made about this it would strike alot of controversy. Think about the people who lost there friends and family in the tragedy. How do you think you would respond to an action film made about this?

Define "Action" in this sense... I don't think (at least I'm sure he doesn't think this) that he means action as in "Ahnold Action". I think by action he means by showing a vivid detail of the planes going into the buildings, explosions, and such, and what the terrorists did in the planes before they destroyed them, all while having the drama of those struggling for survival.

I just think certain people would react differently to this film if it was ever made.

Seriously, I don't think there needs to be a movie about 9/11--it would potentially trivialize a national tragedy. An "action movie" about 9/11? Give me a break!

On the other hand, I would totally support a movie that begins with 9/11 and then goes on to dramatize the worldwide socio-political repurcussions of that event over the following four years. Now that would be eye-opening, IMO.

Sort of like Saving Private Ryan with the D-Day invasion?

No! Not Sorta Like That At All!

Isn't that what darkhorse was talking about? He said to like mix it up with today's current event's, and SPR pretty much did that with the D-Day invasion and then the crew going out to find Pvt. Ryan.

I think such a movie would be seen as an attempt to cash in on this tradgedy and spur patriotism through blatant propaganda and would affend many people including myself. I don't think enough time has passed to have the historical perspective to portray this fairly.

I'm very glad to hear this, Holden.
I saw the play in LA of course, with Tim Robbins and Susan Sarandon in the roles. They were great and I thought the script was nicely done, a great concept. I'm happy to hear it got good treatment. I'll check out the film.

A would not suggest making a film until at least a decade after 9/11. It's just too soon. I think it would be too personnal for those effected, and besides I think those people that lost somene should have the final say about if and when.

Careful... your Django is showing...

Excuse me?...

Dead on! I agree 100%.