Chow Yun Fat vs. Keanu Reeves
There can be no doubt that these two men revolutionized the action-genre.
Both heavily contributed to the popularization of "gun-fu", the trench coat, sunglasses, slow-motion, and dual-wielding firearms. And with John Wick 3 further expanding the "heroic bloodshed" genre that Yun-Fat started, this question seems rather apt. But which action hero has made a bigger impact with audiences, critics, and culture? https://t1.daumcdn.net/thumb/R1280x0...GFREU1fLFV_JNo http://www.hindustantimes.com/rf/ima...a65c287ec4.jpg |
Keanu wins by number of movies I like/love;
Point Break, Matrix, Speed, Bill&Ted x2, Dracula, John Wick x2, Street Kings, Devils Advocate, Constantine, Sweet November. (Also, word on the street is, he is a cool dude irl) Chow; Hard Boiled, Killers, Crouching Tiger, The Corruptor, God of Gamblers, Replacement Killers, Better Tomorrow. |
Re: Chow Yun Fat vs. Keanu Reeves
If the question is about which one made the bigger impact, I think Reeves wins by default as he's had the Hollywood machine behind him for decades, whereas Chow is a major Hong Kong star who never quite made the jump to Hollywood - the most high-profile gig he had in a Western film was as a secondary villain in a Pirates of the Caribbean sequel. That is not to discount how his prime Hong Kong output had influenced a variety of filmmakers, including those who worked with Reeves on some of his best action films.
|
Originally Posted by Iroquois (Post 1995573)
If the question is about which one made the bigger impact, I think Reeves wins by default as he's had the Hollywood machine behind him for decades, whereas Chow is a major Hong Kong star who never quite made the jump to Hollywood - the most high-profile gig he had in a Western film was as a secondary villain in a Pirates of the Caribbean sequel. That is not to discount how his prime Hong Kong output had influenced a variety of filmmakers, including those who worked with Reeves on some of his best action films.
I believe that Tarantino did directly give a credit to Chow Yun Fat as inspiration in Reservoir Dogs. And his shootouts as seen in Django Unchained are almost directly taken from the massive final battles in Hong Kong thrillers. |
Re: Chow Yun Fat vs. Keanu Reeves
Chow Yun Fat never mastered an English accent just to fight Dracula. +1 for Keanu!!!!
|
Re: Chow Yun Fat vs. Keanu Reeves
In the interest of fairness, I assessed Reeves based on his action output.
|
Originally Posted by Swan (Post 1995602)
Chow Yun Fat never mastered an English accent just to fight Dracula. +1 for Keanu!!!!
In all seriousness, Chow Yun Fat did learn Mandarin Chinese for CTHD and English for Bulletproof Monk and PC: At World's End. |
I have to vote Keanu because my Chow Yun Fat viewing is limited.
I think I've seen none of his "classics" and just his lower range stuff like Pirates of the Caribbean, The Replacement Killers, The Corruptor, Bullet-Proof Monk. Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon I saw as well. |
Re: Chow Yun Fat vs. Keanu Reeves
I think I will have to go with Reeves. Reeves has more charisma as an action star. Chow's acting is actually good, but his look is a bit off. I read that in Hong Kong, he was considered to be the Asian Cary Grant. I think this is a fair comparison, cause he looks like a Cary Grant type when firing shotguns and Uzis and all that, and it's hard to see Cary Grant doing that, the most convincingly. But he is still a good actor nonetheless, especially in the non action scenes, when he has to show emotion.
|
Re: Chow Yun Fat vs. Keanu Reeves
American popularity or influence? Would there be a Keanu Gun-fu without Chow Yun Fat in Chinese action?
|
Originally Posted by ironpony (Post 1995651)
I think I will have to go with Reeves. Reeves has more charisma as an action star. Chow's acting is actually good, but his look is a bit off. I read that in Hong Kong, he was considered to be the Asian Cary Grant. I think this is a fair comparison, cause he looks like a Cary Grant type when firing shotguns and Uzis and all that, and it's hard to see Cary Grant doing that, the most convincingly. But he is still a good actor nonetheless, especially in the non action scenes, when he has to show emotion.
Honestly, a lot of what made Chow Yun-Fat iconic was not in his ability to play the role competently (which he did) but in John Woo's ability to deliver rocket-fuel action. |
All times are GMT -3. The time now is 12:03 PM. |
Powered by: vBulletin, Copyright, ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
User Alert System provided by
Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) -
vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright © Movie Forums