The Gold Rush: version
I want to watch The Gold Rush (1925) by Charlie Chaplin, but I just notice that my DVD is with narration and is 69 minutes long (a 1942 remake kind of thing by Chaplin himself).
What version should I watch from this film to get the best experience? What is considered the official one? |
Re: The Gold Rush: version
the version i watched was 69 minutes long.. but i thought city lights, the kid and modern times were all better chaplin films
|
I LOVED Modern Times and City Lights, so I won't mind if the film is worse.
There is a 72 minute version (narration), a 69 minute version (narration), an 86 minute version (silent I guess) and a 95 minute version. This is very confusing. Why are the running times so different? Mark F, I think I need your advice on this one. :D |
I didn't know there were narrated versions. The version I watched was the 95 minute version, I guess. I watched it on YouTube. I think three or four people have it uploaded there.
I'm curious about your question as well. I recently watched it and wasn't a Chaplin fan before, but it completely changed my mind about him. I gave it an A- on first viewing, but now I think I'd take that minus away. I want to watch the other versions if there is something to be gained by doing so. Personally, I think The Gold Rush is his better than both Modern Times and City Lights by quite a bit. I absolutely love the film. |
There is also a whole new soundtrack in the newer version, composed by Chaplin himself, and it got 2 oscar nominations in 1942.
This is a huge dilemma. :p I just wonder which one is considered the best and most important version. |
Re: The Gold Rush: version
My DVD has the 69 and the 96 minute versions. I prefer the original (96 m.). Chaplin took out the intertitles and added music and sound effects for the 1942 reissue to appeal to a newer audience. It's good too but nothing like the original experience. :)
|
96 minute version it is!
I'll watch the other one later then. Thanks for your quick answers! :) |
All times are GMT -3. The time now is 05:39 PM. |
Powered by: vBulletin, Copyright, ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
User Alert System provided by
Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) -
vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright © Movie Forums