Unforgiven v Million Dollar Baby
 

I'm sure Unforgiven will win, though, even though I've picked Unforgiven above Million Dollar Baby....for me, they're the same. :)

Re: Unforgiven v Million Dollar Baby
 

Unforgiven, and it isn't even close.

Re: Unforgiven v Million Dollar Baby
 

You reckon! You like Van Damme! :rolleyes:

Re: Unforgiven v Million Dollar Baby
 

Clint Eastwood Ranked:

1. Unforgiven
2. A Perfect World
3. Mystic River
4. The Outlaw Josey Wales
5. The Bridges Of Madison County
6. Million Dollar Baby
7. Letters From Iwo Jima

He has made tons of other movies but these are the ones I've seen so far.

Re: Unforgiven v Million Dollar Baby
 

People like Million Dollar Baby?

Re: Unforgiven v Million Dollar Baby
 

I do..lol! :D

I do. :D

That's probably what my ranked Eastwood list would look like, except swap the first two around.

So? Even though I'm not much of a fan of him in the first place, what does that have to do with it?

Re: Unforgiven v Million Dollar Baby
 

Of all the ones on Tyler's list, Mystic River is by far the worst.

Re: Unforgiven v Million Dollar Baby
 

Unforgiven and MDB are pretty much the same film. Both have Eastwood, an 'out-of-shape' but previously expert master teaming up with a completely disposable Morgan Freeman (included for the sole purpose of explicating Eastwood himself), taking on a new, nobler challenge that rekindles the spirit of his previous line of work while redeeming himself for the crimes he committed under it.

The films differ only in the way they choose to portray the opposing aspects of the cleansing act of murder. Both films even end on the same note, retaining a very slight degree of moral ambiguity while prompting us to take the situation positively. Finally, both films examine hugely familiar visual and stylistic territory, with MDB possibility being slightly more novel because it was women's boxing.

Nevertheless, Unforgiven is better, because it was a good degree less emotionally 'manipulative.'

Re: Unforgiven v Million Dollar Baby
 

Both in my top 10. Both great films. Sad to see that nobody like MDB since it is a great film. Unforgiven is awesome too.

Nothing mate! ;)

And which is the best?

Re: Unforgiven v Million Dollar Baby
 

Disagree with Mystic River being the worst obviously. What exactly makes Mystic River a bad film?

Re: Unforgiven v Million Dollar Baby
 

When I'm right, I'm right lol! It doesn't happen much though..:D

The Outlaw Josey Wales

I didn't say it was bad, but it was the only one on his list which I gave as low as . The major problems are that the "mystery" is too obvious to be a mystery, and that the acting by Sean Penn, Tim Robbins and a couple of the women is outright poor. I still cannot fathom how it got the two male acting Oscars, but overall, I suppose with all its problems that it's still OK.

Re: Unforgiven v Million Dollar Baby
 

Unforgiven. Not even close.

Re: Unforgiven v Million Dollar Baby
 

It's close, I bet my bottom dollar. Not here however lol :D

I am with this gentleman.

Re: Unforgiven v Million Dollar Baby
 

I think I would have to choose Unforgiven. I never really watched Million dollar baby, it didn't interest me at all.