Christopher Nolan vs. David Fincher
 

http://i.imgur.com/sftEUH7.png?1
http://i.imgur.com/urVAcpo.png?2

Re: Christopher Nolan vs. David Fincher
 

Fincher. I'm not even a Nolan hater. I just think Fincher is leagues ahead of him in skill.

Re: Christopher Nolan vs. David Fincher
 

Fincher by a nose for me. I just love The Social Network and Zodiac so much. Very close for me though.

Re: Christopher Nolan vs. David Fincher
 

Fincher. I Love the Dark Knight trilogy, but I can't argue against Fight Club, Seven, The Game and Panic Room.

Re: Christopher Nolan vs. David Fincher
 

Both are favorite of mine. I appreciate both director way more than PTA and Tarantino...

I have to go with Fincher because he never let me down and all his movies are genius and brilliant. I have 3 movies of him in my Top 25 (Zodiac, Fight Club and Se7en)

:up::up::up::up:

Re: Christopher Nolan vs. David Fincher
 

Fincher.

More talented on a visual level AND a better storyteller in my opinion.

Re: Christopher Nolan vs. David Fincher
 

Fincher for me too. SE7EN, Zodiac, the social network and Fight Club are all great films for me.

Re: Christopher Nolan vs. David Fincher
 

They scratch different itches. Fincher's a better filmmaker, but Nolan just has more interesting ideas. Nolan's films would be interesting even to describe to people, or in other mediums entirely, whereas Fincher's get their power largely from the skill with which they're executed.

I tend to really like high concept films, though, so I find myself more excited for Nolan's releases than Fincher's, but they're very hard to compare objectively.

Fincher for me

Neither is a favorite for me, but Fincher has more movies that I like.

Re: Christopher Nolan vs. David Fincher
 

Poor Nolan :laugh:

I'm sure his billion will comfort him.

Doubt that'll be enough when he needs to wake up every morning knowing 11 people on Movie Forums prefer David Fincher

We are an elite group. Rotten Tomatoes ain't got nothing on us.

Methinks Nolan's too popular to be loved by the cool kids.

Re: Christopher Nolan vs. David Fincher
 

Fincher is more talented.

Re: Christopher Nolan vs. David Fincher
 

Fincher for his overall body of work.

Re: Christopher Nolan vs. David Fincher
 

Fincher EASILY, but man Memento was amazing.

Re: Christopher Nolan vs. David Fincher
 

Not even a contest, David Fincher.