Oscar's Best Picture 2017
 

Here are the nine nominees for Best Picture at the Academy Awards.



Arrival
Fences
Hacksaw Ridge
Hell or High Water
Hidden Figures
La La Land
Lion
Manchester by the Sea
Moonlight

Re: Oscar's Best Picture 2017
 

Why no Silence?

Re: Oscar's Best Picture 2017
 

Deadpool got robbed.

Re: Oscar's Best Picture 2017
 

The only one I've managed to see so far is La La Land, which I liked very much. I would be tempted to call it a lock at this point with all the hype surrounding it and only Moonlight and Manchester by the Sea has a hope of challenging it, surely.

Re: Oscar's Best Picture 2017
 

I voted for Hacksaw Ridge, however, I'm also fine with either Manchester By The Sea, Arrival, or Moonlight.

Re: Oscar's Best Picture 2017
 

Got more catching up to do for best picture than I expected. Four that will make my 2016 top ten are here though. Manchester, Fences, Hell Or High Water, La La Land. Good on you Academy. I have also seen Arrival.

#seansomainstream

Re: Oscar's Best Picture 2017
 

Manchester by the Sea. Although I'd happily see Moonlight nab it.

Re: Oscar's Best Picture 2017
 

I've seen 4 of the 9. I really wanted to still see Lion or Moonlight, but I don't think they are playing anywhere near here anymore.

I believe Hell or High Water is on DVD already and I think Hacksaw Ridge will be in a few weeks.

I could see Hidden Figures anyway but is it really worth it? HOLDEN?

Re: Oscar's Best Picture 2017
 

This. This. THIS!

Re: Oscar's Best Picture 2017
 

I've seen none of these.

Re: Oscar's Best Picture 2017
 

Of the four I've seen, I'm not sure any are Miss Vicky friendly. Perhaps Manchester, but I doubt it.

You would hate La La and Fences,

Maybe Arrival would be ok, but I doubt it.

Re: Oscar's Best Picture 2017
 

Unfortunately, I think La La Land is gonna sweep. I just filled out the Oscar pool and most of the ones it was nominated for feel like are going to go to it, deserved or not.

Re: Oscar's Best Picture 2017
 

Deserved! Great film!

I'm gonna have to disagree with you, rauldc14. I get what they were going for, but their resurgence/homage to the studio musical missed the mark and ended up being this bland regurgitation with an irritating color palette. With some of those scenes they "modernized" (i.e, the first number between Gosling & Stone in the styling of that of Fred & Ginger's from Top Hat) just felt like a copy and paste attempt into the 21st century. I will agree that it is technically sound though.

Out of the 1/2 of what I saw on that list, my vote either goes to Manchester or Hell or High Water.

Re: Oscar's Best Picture 2017
 

Only watched Moonlight.

My pick is Moonlight, my favorite of 2016, but La La Land will probably take it. It seems like everything Academy voters love.

Re: Oscar's Best Picture 2017
 

One complaint I heard a lot on the internet is that many people feel La La Land was nominated simply because Hollywood loves themselves and a musical like that does just that. As I haven't seen the movie yet, can you explain if that's a fair complaint or not?

I've only seen Hell or High Water, a very good movie that I don't think should have even been considered in an average year.

Yup, I like it. Don't know if it is one of the very best nine films of the entire year, but it is good, well made, and worth seeing. Fascinating footnote of scientific and U.S. history.

The complaint isn't really on the film itself from most people, I find La La Land to be great, personally. I guess you could find the argument that it's a good example of Oscar bait, but I don't see it. The complaints I think are mainly from the constant predictability of the voters; they love nostalgia pieces, and films focused on Hollywood, or any kind of production, which La La Land falls into in many ways. See The Artist, or Birdman, great films, and I would argue at least in Birdman's case was the "right" choice for best picture, but they probably both won for the wrong reasons.