Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
Awesome! I have been thinking about my nom for a while, and I think I’ve decided on something. The only reason I hesitated to nominate it is because I feel like I’m “hogging” all the great well-known films, while these hall of fames are for an introduction to new films for a lot of people. But the movie I’m nominating I really think deserves a spot; it came really close in a general hall of fame (you can probably guess it by now).
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
Nomination sent.
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
Nomination sent as well
|
Originally Posted by ahwell (Post 2022385)
Awesome! I have been thinking about my nom for a while, and I think I’ve decided on something. The only reason I hesitated to nominate it is because I feel like I’m “hogging” all the great well-known films, while these hall of fames are for an introduction to new films for a lot of people.
But the movie I’m nominating I really think deserves a spot; it came really close in a general hall of fame (you can probably guess it by now). |
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
I didn't know you enjoyed Revolutionary Girl Utena that much
|
Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 2022468)
I didn't know you enjoyed Revolutionary Girl Utena that much
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
I was thinking K-On!
Quality s*** right there. |
My nomination was my second choice for the Science Fiction field. I'm not sure if it's going to be a hit or not because it's really out there but I enjoyed it.
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
We have 5 on day one and a nice mix of films too!
|
I still plan to join, but I'll be a week or two late starting since I'm away from the 17th to the 23rd.
There are a few films I'd like to watch before deciding on a nomination though. Unfortunately the one I wanted to see the most proved difficult to track down, so even if I do enjoy it, I'll definitely go with something more accessible. Two of the films I'm considering are currently available on Youtube, so it might be between those haha. |
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
I'm glad you are joining. I think this will be a nice fun mix here.
|
Originally Posted by Siddon (Post 2022507)
My nomination was my second choice for the Science Fiction field. I'm not sure if it's going to be a hit or not because it's really out there but I enjoyed it.
Originally Posted by CosmicRunaway (Post 2022591)
I still plan to join, but I'll be a week or two late starting since I'm away from the 17th to the 23rd.
There are a few films I'd like to watch before deciding on a nomination though. Unfortunately the one I wanted to see the most proved difficult to track down, so even if I do enjoy it, I'll definitely go with something more accessible. Two of the films I'm considering are currently available on Youtube, so it might be between those haha. |
Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 2022377)
|
In that image, I count 8 movies that I dislike, 2 that I'm indifferent to, 1 that I can't decide whether I like or not despite multiple viewings, and 3 that I don't think I've seen. :laugh:
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
What's the one you can't decide on?
|
Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 2022616)
What's the one you can't decide on?
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
I've tried to watch that a few times, just could never get into it really.
|
Originally Posted by Miss Vicky (Post 2022615)
In that image, I count 8 movies that I dislike, 2 that I'm indifferent to, 1 that I can't decide whether I like or not despite multiple viewings, and 3 that I don't think I've seen. :laugh:
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by CosmicRunaway (Post 2022628)
Originally Posted by Miss Vicky (Post 2022615)
In that image, I count 8 movies that I dislike, 2 that I'm indifferent to, 1 that I can't decide whether I like or not despite multiple viewings, and 3 that I don't think I've seen. :laugh:
|
Originally Posted by ahwell (Post 2022631)
Which ones, just curious.
That doesn't mean that I actively dislike the other films in the picture that I've seen; I just don't particularly care for them. I have been meaning to give Spirited Away and Howl's Moving Castle second chances, but I was mostly unimpressed with a lot of the Ghibli films I watched or rewatched for the Animation Tournament, so they haven't exactly been a high priority for me. |
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
And there's only 4 that I love on there for the record
|
I love three of the movies shown and one of them isn't eligible.
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
Love 4, Like 8, Don't Like 3, Haven't Seen 3 and don't recognize #9 or #18
And I was seriously considering Rango. And Kung Fu Panda was in the upper choices just for the fun of it. Which is ironic since I can't stand Jack Black in films but I do love the Panda trilogy. And I played around with the idea of 9. |
Originally Posted by edarsenal (Post 2022677)
don't recognize #9 or #18
What are #6 and #11? |
Originally Posted by Miss Vicky (Post 2022680)
Felidae and The Plague Dogs
What are #6 and #11? #11 The Road To El Dorado not exactly sure about #6. It MAY be Box Trolls but I'm not sure |
Originally Posted by Miss Vicky (Post 2022680)
What are #6 and #11?
Originally Posted by edarsenal (Post 2022682)
Thanks!
#11 The Road To El Dorado not exactly sure about #6. It MAY be Box Trolls but I'm not sure I think #6 is Coraline. |
Originally Posted by gbgoodies (Post 2022684)
I think #6 is Coraline.
|
Originally Posted by gbgoodies (Post 2022684)
I think #6 is Coraline.
Originally Posted by Miss Vicky (Post 2022690)
Yep, you’re right. I thought the image looked familiar but couldn’t place it.
Thanks. I knew it looked familiar. I haven't seen the movie yet, but I've seen the DVD cover. :lol: |
Originally Posted by gbgoodies (Post 2022691)
Thanks. I knew it looked familiar. I haven't seen the movie yet, but I've seen the DVD cover. :lol:
|
1. Spirited Away - Loved it, might have nominated it
2. The Lion King - enjoyed it 3. Rango - never saw it 4. Beauty and the Beast - having just seen the live action one this is hopefully a pass 5. Wall:E - my favorite of the group 6. Coraline - loved it, wouldn't mind a rewatch 7. Porco Rosso - This was very close to being my nomination 8. How to Train Your Dragon - loved it 9. _ _ _ _ _ _ - never saw it 10. Corpse Bride - didn't care for it 11. Road to El Dorado - passed on it 12. Watership Down - not impressed with it 13. Bambi - been awhile for me 14. Balto - (i think didn't see it) 15. Howls Moving Castle - admired it didn't love it 16. Nine - liked it 17. Kung Fu Panda - liked it 18. _ __ _ _ _ - never saw it don't know it 19. Happy Feet - never saw it 20. Toy Story 3 - liked it I picked my nomination because it came from a studio not represented in that montage and it came from a decade with one of those nominations |
Originally Posted by Siddon (Post 2022702)
4. Beauty and the Beast - having just seen the live action one this is hopefully a pass
Originally Posted by Siddon (Post 2022702)
7. Porco Rosso - This was very close to being my nomination
|
1. Spirited Away - Don't like it
2. The Lion King - Really don't like it 3. Rango - Can't decide if I like it or not 4. Beauty and the Beast - No likey Stockholm Syndrome: The Movie 5. Wall:E - Love it 6. Coraline - Eh. Okay, I guess 7. Porco Rosso - I don't like any of Hayao Miyazaki's movies and I've seen all of them. 8. How to Train Your Dragon - Love it 9. Felidae - Don't like it 10. Corpse Bride - Like it, don't love it 11. Road to El Dorado - Haven't seen it 12. Watership Down - Respect it, but don't like it. Ugly artwork 13. Bambi - Love it 14. Balto - Haven't seen it 15. Howls Moving Castle - See #7 16. Nine - Like it 17. Kung Fu Panda - Hate it 18. The Plague Dogs - Respect it more than I like it 19. Happy Feet - Liked it at first, don't care for it anymore 20. Toy Story 3 - I'm not a Toy Story fan, but I really like this one Other two images: The Little Mermaid: It's one of the better princess movies, but I'm not fond of it. Fantastic Mr. Fox: Hate it |
I've only seen 3 out of the 20 picture.
#1. Spirited Away - Amazing film! #5. Wall E - Thought it was pretty cool, a little sappy at times. #19. Happy Feet - My wife wanted to see this at the theater, I remember not wanting to see it, but I ended up liking it. |
Originally Posted by Miss Vicky (Post 2022759)
1. Spirited Away - Don't like it
2. The Lion King - Really don't like it 3. Rango - Can't decide if I like it or not 4. Beauty and the Beast - No likey Stockholm Syndrome: The Movie 5. Wall:E - Love it 6. Coraline - Eh. Okay, I guess 7. Porco Rosso - I don't like any of Hayao Miyazaki's movies and I've seen all of them. 8. How to Train Your Dragon - Love it 9. Felidae - Don't like it 10. Corpse Bride - Like it, don't love it 11. Road to El Dorado - Haven't seen it 12. Watership Down - Respect it, but don't like it. Ugly artwork 13. Bambi - Love it 14. Balto - Haven't seen it 15. Howls Moving Castle - See #7 16. Nine - Like it 17. Kung Fu Panda - Hate it 18. The Plague Dogs - Respect it more than I like it 19. Happy Feet - Liked it at first, don't care for it anymore 20. Toy Story 3 - I'm not a Toy Story fan, but I really like this one Other two images: The Little Mermaid: It's one of the better princess movies, but I'm not fond of it. Fantastic Mr. Fox: Hate it I guess I didn't realize you hated animation so much. In reality, animation is actually one of my favorite genres |
Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 2022783)
I guess I didn't realize you hated animation so much.
In reality, animation is actually one of my favorite genres |
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
Boo. Well maybe you will like Miyazakis next movie.
|
Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 2022785)
Boo. Well maybe you will like Miyazakis next movie.
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
I'm not sure i remember how you feel about what I nominated. Will be interesting.
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
Miss Vicky is a wild card for me. A high chance I'll enjoy or already love her noms, and a rarity that she likes one of mine lol
1. Spirited Away - Respect it, but not entirely a fan 2. The Lion King - It may have been the hype when it came out, but I'm sort of so-so on it 3. Rango - absolutely LOVE. Can watch over and over 4. Beauty and the Beast - (No likey Stockholm Syndrome: The Movie) LOVE that remark by Miss Vicky. I enjoy a romance, and surprisingly, for a SS, I enjoy this one. Could be because I've grown up on various versions of this story. 5. Wall:E - LOVE it! 6. Coraline - Own it, every time I've tried to watch it, we fall asleep. Weird. 7. Porco Rosso - Have tried to see it, haven't yet. 8. How to Train Your Dragon - Love this. Not so much the follow-ups though 9. Felidae - Haven't even heard of it. 10. Corpse Bride - Just short of Love, definitely like 11. Road to El Dorado - So-so 12. Watership Down - Been a very long time since I saw it, like, when it came out. Need a rewatch and I'm curious about the new version coming out 13. Bambi - beautiful film. Love it 14. Balto - Didn't like it 15. Howls Moving Castle - Need to see it, haven't 16. Nine - Enjoyed it 17. Kung Fu Panda - Love it despite hating Black 18. The Plague Dogs - Will NOT see it when I heard how sad it is 19. Happy Feet - Liked it, preferred Surf's Up when it comes to the outsider penguin. 20. Toy Story 3 - Was on the fence with this one. |
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
I know Cosmic doesn't like the movie I nominated. Not sure what the rest of you will think.
|
The number of animated films that I genuinely dislike (as opposed to just "not being very fond of") isn't really that high, and the only ones I would actually hate to watch again are both Miyazaki films, and that's mainly because I saw them semi-recently. Since you're not a fan of his work, it can't be either of those at least haha.
|
Originally Posted by CosmicRunaway (Post 2022817)
(as opposed to just "not being very fond of")
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
Looks my nom won’t do as well as I thought it would based on the reactions so far on this thread.
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
Nom sent, i'm very excited.
|
After not being too thrilled by the films I picked out myself, I finally watched one my room mates have been in love with since it came out, and as long as no one else has chosen that one already, it'll be my nomination.
I guess the moral of the story is that I'm bad at choosing my own films haha. |
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
Hash and Cosmic have us up to 7 picks. An incredibly diverse HOF right now.
|
Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 2023095)
Hash and Cosmic have us up to 7 picks. An incredibly diverse HOF right now.
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
I'm really curious to see what the noms are. Hoping to discover something new that I'll love.
|
My film won't be new to you, but based on what you've already written about it, you didn't dislike it, so it should at least be more enjoyable than my previous animated nomination haha.
|
Originally Posted by CosmicRunaway (Post 2023308)
My film won't be new to you, but based on what you've already written about it, you didn't dislike it, so it should at least be more enjoyable than my previous animated nomination haha.
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
I nominated The Last Unicorn. I hadn't seen it since I was a kid, and I also had a lot of grievances with the film when I rewatched it for the HoF. So I wasn't exactly surprised when it placed dead last haha.
|
Originally Posted by CosmicRunaway (Post 2023313)
I nominated The Last Unicorn. I hadn't seen it since I was a kid, and I also had a lot of grievances with the film when I rewatched it for the HoF. So I wasn't exactly surprised when it placed dead last haha.
|
Originally Posted by Miss Vicky (Post 2023312)
I don’t remember what you nominated in the previous HOF. I do recall not liking Rock n Rule in the tournament though.
|
Originally Posted by edarsenal (Post 2023349)
of course you didn't like it, I nominated it in the tournament lol
|
Originally Posted by Miss Vicky (Post 2023351)
Oh that was yours? My memory sucks. I just hope you didn’t nominate it again.
|
Originally Posted by edarsenal (Post 2023349)
of course you didn't like it, I nominated it in the tournament lol
I nominated Rock & Rule in the Animated Film Tournament that Camo hosted. It didn't make it very far.
Originally Posted by Camo (Post 1627908)
Rock and Rule - Cosmic (ROUND 1)
|
Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 2023095)
Hash and Cosmic have us up to 7 picks. An incredibly diverse HOF right now.
So if we stay at #7 do you want to do double noms? If so I would recommend first a reveal because I could go in four different directions based on what I see with the field. I love intellectual diversity and animation has some interesting avenues we could go down. |
Originally Posted by Siddon (Post 2023377)
So if we stay at #7 do you want to do double noms? If so I would recommend first a reveal because I could go in four different directions based on what I see with the field. I love intellectual diversity and animation has some interesting avenues we could go down.
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
I had a hard enough time thinking of one nomination, so I'd rather not have to find a second. If we do go down that route, can I pass on the extra film?
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
I love animation and coming up with a second nomination would be easy enough for me, but I'm not sure I'm keen on committing to watching 14 movies.
|
Originally Posted by Miss Vicky (Post 2023389)
I love animation and coming up with a second nomination would be easy enough for me, but I'm not sure I'm keen on committing to watching 14 movies.
13 now...I'd like to see the reveal |
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
I wouldn't mind doing 14
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
Like I said I'm preferring a number around 10. We will give it a couple more days yet. I'm open to "raffling" off 3 more nominations somehow to make it around 10. I think 14 is a bit steep but I'd go with majority vote.
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
I'm hoping Funny Face decides to join. I told her about it yesterday and she seemed interested, but we'll see. I know she won't want to do it if there are more than ten noms though.
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
I'd be totally cool doing second noms as well if no one else joins. I'm watching a lot of animation for my "personal tournament" right now anyways, so it may actually turn into killing two birds with one stone.
|
Originally Posted by CosmicRunaway (Post 2023371)
Are we perhaps talking about different tournaments? Or are we secretly the same person and I haven't realized it yet? That would certainly be a plot twist haha.
I nominated Rock & Rule in the Animated Film Tournament that Camo hosted. It didn't make it very far. Is this deja-vu? Or am I just confused? What are we talking about again? Who are you? Where's my nurse? This ain't my medication! anyway, I could have sworn I nominate R&R for some kind of animation tournament. Most likely a shift the Matrix. aka Old Fart Mental Capacity |
Originally Posted by Miss Vicky (Post 2023398)
I'm hoping Funny Face decides to join. I told her about it yesterday and she seemed interested, but we'll see. I know she won't want to do it if there are more than ten noms though.
Oh, and if we're looking to keep it at 10 and we dont' get even members perhaps those that volunteered second nominations can bring it up to 10 as a possibility. |
Thinking of a nomination!
|
Originally Posted by Funny Face (Post 2023466)
Thinking of a nomination!
|
Nomination sent. MV will be happy that I did NOT nominate A Goofy Movie...even though I, still, believe it has the best music from all the Disney films.
Also, I wouldn't mind in this particular HoF if nominations went over 10, so if it is decided each person nominates two, I wouldn't have any issues. I'd probably chose something I haven't seen as a second nomination. And of course, of anyone else wanted to nominate A Goofy Movie...:D |
Originally Posted by Funny Face (Post 2023675)
Nomination sent. MV will be happy that I did NOT nominate A Goofy Movie...even though I, still, believe it has the best music from all the Disney films.
Also, I wouldn't mind in this particular HoF if nominations went over 10, so if it is decided each person nominates two, I wouldn't have any issues. I'd probably chose something I haven't seen as a second nomination. And of course, of anyone else wanted to nominate A Goofy Movie...:D I'd like to make a second nom, my original nom has no chance at winning it's going to be very divisive but it's important film from an animation studio that really isn't talked about much. My second nomination could be one of several films that would be "classic" I just ask to take a look at the field and seeing what film is needed. So who else is looking to make a second nomination? |
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
So it looks like we have 8.
Is 8 good with everybody? I think having 2 nominations per person is way too much. I'm good with 8, although maybe someone will join last minute yet. |
Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 2023920)
So it looks like we have 8.
Is 8 good with everybody? I think having 2 nominations per person is way too much. I'm good with 8, although maybe someone will join last minute yet. I think 10-12 makes more sense...what's the runtime of the animated films? Mine is an 1h22min |
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
Anywhere around 8-12 is fine with me.
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
@Citizen Rules you joining us?
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
I'm fine with 8.
I'll still participate no matter how many films there are, but I don't see any point in arbitrarily bumping the numbers up by giving people second noms. |
Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 2023927)
@Citizen Rules you joining us?
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
8 is okay for me as well.
I do see how, since this isn't about who wins, but the movie itself, should we decide to allow one to four of us a second nom to hit the ten mark or even bump it to twelve, I'm okay with that. Not necessary, but I'd be okay with it. |
It doesn't matter to me how many nominations there are. I will not be able to choose a second film, but I'm fine with others getting another choice if the majority vote to inflate the numbers.
Even though I'll be away for a week (starting tomorrow morning), I've just finished pre-writting the review for my own nomination, so I won't really be a week behind when I come back. :cool: |
Other than mainstream animation - Disney, Dreamworks, etc., I know nothing about Anime - I just can't get into it. But if no one minds my list would include no Anime, then I'm willing to participate. As I understand it, I am to pm my nominations. If you're looking for reviews also for the ones nominated, I'll pass. I'm good with rating movies, but I just can't get into doing reviews.
|
Originally Posted by SFMZone (Post 2023974)
Other than mainstream animation - Disney, Dreamworks, etc., I know nothing about Anime - I just can't get into it. But if no one minds my list would include no Anime, then I'm willing to participate. As I understand it, I am to pm my nominations. If you're looking for reviews also for the ones nominated, I'll pass. I'm good with rating movies, but I just can't get into doing reviews.
The rules are that each participant nominates one film, then all participants watch and review every nominated film, then send a ballot to the host with all nominated films ranked in order of best to worst. You don't get to pick and choose which films you watch. |
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
Fair enough, I'll enjoy this HOF from the sidelines.
|
Originally Posted by SFMZone (Post 2023974)
Other than mainstream animation - Disney, Dreamworks, etc., I know nothing about Anime - I just can't get into it. But if no one minds my list would include no Anime, then I'm willing to participate. As I understand it, I am to pm my nominations. If you're looking for reviews also for the ones nominated, I'll pass. I'm good with rating movies, but I just can't get into doing reviews.
|
Originally Posted by SFMZone (Post 2023974)
But if no one minds my list would include no Anime, then I'm willing to participate. As I understand it, I am to pm my nominations. If you're looking for reviews also for the ones nominated, I'll pass.
|
Originally Posted by CosmicRunaway (Post 2024011)
It sounds like what you want to do would be better suited to the Countdowns. For those you can watch whatever films you want before the deadline, then send your list to the host, no reviews necessary.
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by SFMZone (Post 2024012)
Now that sounds like my cup of tea. I'll keep that in mind, thanks.
|
Originally Posted by Chypmunk (Post 2024015)
Pre-1930 countdown is the next one, if interested thread giving details is here.
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
Sorry if rauldc14 made an executive decision and I accidentally skipped over it, but I would personally be for doing second nominations, at least for a couple people. The reason is kind of selfish, and it is that I have a pre-30s blind nom that I've been meaning to watch and I know I won't get around to it soon unless I nominate it for this... I know I could also nominate for the second pre-30s HoF, but I'd rather have three new pre-30s than just two... besides, for those who haven't seen it it could help them for making choices in pre-30s countdown.
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
Will we be hearing of the nominations soon?
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
It will be soon :)
|
Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 2024212)
It will be soon :)
Do you want Ahwell and myself to make second noms to get the count up to ten? |
Originally Posted by Siddon (Post 2024222)
Do you want Ahwell and myself to make second noms to get the count up to ten?
|
Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 2024227)
I'm fine with it if others are.
Cool PM me the list and I'll give you my pick (so it's different from the other noms) |
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
I'm fine with it.
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
if a couple of folks bring it up to 10 or there about, that's fine.
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
I'll just give Siddon time to send his other nomination. I work tonight so I'll post the nominations tomorrow
|
Re: 2nd Animation Hall of Fame
I don't care. I just want to know what the nominations are. I was hoping they'd have been posted by now.
|
|
2nd nom sent, well I've definitely diversified this field
|
| All times are GMT -3. The time now is 06:38 AM. |
Powered by: vBulletin, Copyright, ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
User Alert System provided by
Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) -
vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright © Movie Forums