Movie Forums (http://www.movieforums.com/community/index.php)
-   Movie Reviews (http://www.movieforums.com/community/forumdisplay.php?f=3)
-   -   The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's (http://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?t=49083)

SilentVamp 04-17-17 04:41 PM

The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
1 Attachment(s)




Well, here we are again, preparing ourselves for yet another countdown. This time it is the 1940’s. This is a decade countdown that I have been anxiously awaiting.


The 1940’s was a time of world war and, ultimately, the post-war era. The films are very reflective of those two things. There seemed to be a variety of movies in every genre. From the light-hearted comedy to the serious drama. From westerns to musicals. From dark noirs to films that have a more nostalgic feeling to them. And, of course, films about war. Just the various names of the directors (i.e. Ford, Hitchcock, Welles, Capra, Kurosawa, Hawks, etc.) lets you know that this period produced some of the best quality and most well-made movies in film history.


I really started to become interested in older films when I was about 12 years old. I wasn’t entirely ignorant of the “classics”, though. I come from a family where movies of all sorts were widely watched by them. So I knew of such people as Spencer Tracy, Humphrey Bogart, Cary Grant, Gene Kelly, Katharine Hepburn, Alan Ladd, John Garfield, Gary Cooper, Veronica Lake, and so on. But, for whatever reason, during that time in my life (I really couldn’t tell you why), I would watch a black and white movie, or a colorful musical, on TV whenever the opportunity was there. I would “discover” someone “new” like Ray Milland or Joel McCrea or Greer Garson, and then if I saw one movie with them, I would then have to see another. And it was because of this that I began my obsession with films from that era. The 1940’s are my favorite decade when it comes to movies, and it is because of that fact that I was interested in running the 1940’s countdown. I thought that it would be a lot of fun for me, and I really hope that it will be fun for all of you, too.


Rules and Other Important Stuff to Remember

-Any film is eligible that was released from 1940 to 1949
-All lists should be PM’d to me, of course
-You must be a member for one month in order to submit a list
-If you are new to this sort of thing, you are asked to submit a list of what you consider to be your top 25 films from the 1940’s, with your top favorite being #1 and least favorite #25
-Partial lists will be accepted after Monday, July 31st
-The deadline for all lists will be Sunday, September 3rd
-All lists are final
-Please don’t share any part of your list until the films have been revealed on the countdown so that none of your votes will be disqualified
-The countdown will begin on Sunday, September 10th



For help regarding films to watch, and to consider for your lists, the following ones have been nominated in the various Hall of Fames:
Blithe Spirit
Foreign Correspondent
Late Spring
Letter From an Unknown Woman
The Shop Around the Corner
The Magnificent Ambersons
Brief Encounter
Leave Her to Heaven
The Best Years of Our Lives
(won)
The Great Dictator
Nightmare Alley
Out of the Past
The Third Man
Double Indemnity
The Lady from Shanghai
The Set-Up
Pinocchio
So Proudly We Hail
Red River
The Big Sleep
(won)
The Maltese Falcon
Scarlet Street
The Killers



And, of course, the films that were nominated in both of the 1940’s HoFs are an excellent way to find more to consider:
Waterloo Bridge
The Suspect
Murderers Among Us
Shadow of a Doubt
How Green Was My Valley
Rope
Arsenic and Old Lace
The Little Foxes
Laura
(won)
The Thief of Bagdad
Pursued
Fantasia
I Remember Mama
His Girl Friday
Odd Man Out
Gentleman Jim
Mr. Lucky
Beauty and the Beast
Day of Wrath
Body and Soul
The Sea Wolf
Ride the Pink Horse
The Ghost and Mrs. Muir



Don’t forget the 1940’s Recommendations thread that Camo created for us.


And if there is a film that I missed, and should now be added to the list of HoF films, please let know.


So, in conclusion, there will be 5 months of film-watching. Let’s try for an excellent turnout for this because it is a very worthy decade to have its own countdown, and it should definitely not be ignored.




Lists Received
7thson
77topaz
Beatle
Camo
Captain Spaulding
cat_sidhe
Citizen Rules
Clazor
cricket
dadgumblah
Dannii
Destiny
donniedarko
edarsenal
Fabulous
Frightened Inmate No. 2
Gangland
gbgoodies
Gideon58
GulfportDoc
Harry Lime
HashtagBrownies
Holden Pike
I_Wear_Pants
jal90
Jeff Costello
jiraffejustin
Iroquois
Kaplan
Loner
mark f
Marlon Brando
matt72582
Miss Vicky
MovieMeditation
Mr Minio
NedStark09
neiba
Nestorio_Miklos
Nope1172
Pussy Galore
rauldc14
re93animator
sarah f
seanc
Sexy Celebrity
Siddon
SilentVamp
SkyDog
spookiemoviemania
The Gunslinger45
the samoan lawyer
Thursday Next
TokeZa
urkillinmesmalls
Yoda

Harry Lime 04-17-17 06:09 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
Great! Thanks for volunteering to run the countdown, SilentVamp.

cricket 04-17-17 06:21 PM

I've got about 30 favorites so far with about 100 left on my watchlist. I've got work to do.

Citizen Rules 04-17-17 06:31 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
We're in good hands with Vamp doing the 40s Countdown!

The 1940's are a great decade (notice that I typed are as opposed to were...to me the 40's are only a click away, then they magically reappear on my TV screen)....I'm very excited about the 40s Countdown! This should be epic!

A big Thank You to SilentVamp for doing this for us:)

gbgoodies 04-18-17 12:11 AM

@SilentVamp Thank You! :up:

The 1940's is one of the best decades for movies. I'm looking forward to this countdown. :)

Thursday Next 04-18-17 08:01 AM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
Looking forward to this, glad you are hosting Vamp!

As with the previous decade, I've got about 12 definites, a cluster of other movies that could round out the top 25 and a watchlist about a mile long. I'm trying to be selective with my watchlist though, as I won't get round to everything.

Cobpyth 04-18-17 09:33 AM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
I already have a great top 25, but I'm sure I'll discover some great new stuff in these next five months (especially since I'm going to have a lot of free time on my hands), so you can expect to receive my list a few days before the deadline.

Thanks for hosting this, @SilentVamp!

Camo 04-18-17 09:42 AM

Glad you are doing this, i know you'll do a great job Vamp :up:

Like Cobpyth i can send a list of 25 that i'd be happy with right now but i've got tonnes left on my watchlist. I've watched quite a few for this already and i have really liked the majority, actually i'm already at the stage where i'm eliminating films from the 25 and feeling bad about it because i like them alot. Great decade.

Jeff Costello 04-18-17 04:10 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
Looking forward to it SV !

This will be my first MoFo countdown and I plan to go on a 40's flicks watching spree before it.

If you don't mind asking, are the set dates definite or could they possibly be postponed for a tiny bit ?

The Gunslinger45 04-18-17 04:59 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
I have a top 25 right now, but there is some more Noir flicks I want to watch.

Camo 04-18-17 05:06 PM

Originally Posted by Jeff Costello (Post 1689676)
Looking forward to it SV !

This will be my first MoFo countdown and I plan to go on a 40's flicks watching spree before it.

If you don't mind asking, are the set dates definite or could they possibly be postponed for a tiny bit ?
Obviously it's not my call but i don't think there should be any extension, that's already the longest we've been given as a deadline i believe at over 4 months.

SilentVamp 04-18-17 05:54 PM

Originally Posted by cricket (Post 1689178)
I've got about 30 favorites so far with about 100 left on my watchlist. I've got work to do.
That is an average of 20 films per month. You can do it! :)


Originally Posted by Cobpyth (Post 1689485)
I already have a great top 25
Originally Posted by Camo (Post 1689486)
Like Cobpyth i can send a list of 25 that i'd be happy with right now
I had a list of 25 films last year already for this countdown. I thought it was pretty good. I thought that I would end up using that one. But I have watching a lot of movies in the past few months that are really making me reconsider what I have on the list. It will probably take me the whole 5 months just to decide which ones are on the list, and then I have the ordeal of where they should be placed.


Originally Posted by Jeff Costello (Post 1689676)
If you don't mind asking, are the set dates definite or could they possibly be postponed for a tiny bit ?
I think it is best that these are the set dates. I did the math (and by "math" I mean counting the days on the calendar) at least 5-6 times. Truthfully, I have something that I will be going out-of-town for in early November. With what I had figured out, we would be finishing the countdown just in time for that. I really didn't want to up and leave this for awhile and then come back and finish it. That wouldn't be fair to anyone here. And I thought 5 months would be a sufficient amount of time for everyone (especially because I think it was 5 months last year for the 1950's - please correct me if I am wrong :)) to watch whatever they needed to watch and to then send a list in. 4 months seemed too soon, and 6 months seemed maybe a little too much.

Jeff Costello 04-18-17 06:45 PM

Originally Posted by SilentVamp (Post 1689723)
I think it is best that these are the set dates. I did the math (and by "math" I mean counting the days on the calendar) at least 5-6 times. Truthfully, I have something that I will be going out-of-town for in early November. With what I had figured out, we would be finishing the countdown just in time for that. I really didn't want to up and leave this for awhile and then come back and finish it. That wouldn't be fair to anyone here. And I thought 5 months would be a sufficient amount of time for everyone (especially because I think it was 5 months last year for the 1950's - please correct me if I am wrong :)) to watch whatever they needed to watch and to then send a list in. 4 months seemed too soon, and 6 months seemed maybe a little too much.
Yeah, no worries;) I was just asking, because I figured I'd have a pretty decent amount of time in September, to prepare myself for the countdown even better.

5 months will be just fine !

Nope1172 04-18-17 07:39 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
Very excited for a countdown that I don't have to do any work for. I have a lot of movies to watch to get ready though.

rauldc14 04-18-17 07:53 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
Looking forward to this! Thanks SV! Back to back Wisconsin presenters for the decade list!

SilentVamp 04-20-17 07:21 PM

Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 1689794)
Looking forward to this! Thanks SV! Back to back Wisconsin presenters for the decade list!
Oh, that's right! I didn't even think of that. Well, that just puts the pressure on me then to do a good job. You did such a good job with yours that I can't fail now. I can't make Wisconsin look bad. I can't make it look like they have any dummies here who don't know how to handle one of these countdowns. :D

cricket 06-01-17 08:38 PM

20 40's movies watched for me in May.


Come on folks!

Camo 06-01-17 08:42 PM

Originally Posted by cricket (Post 1711257)
20 40's movies watched for me in May.


Come on folks!
Dang. I've watched about 30 40's movies all in for this. I already have a ridiculously tight list, i'm heartbroken any time i have to remove something.

rauldc14 06-03-17 09:00 AM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
My list is going to be fairly tight too. I'm sure I'm going to see a few in the next couple months that should be on my list.

ShopkeeperTriumph 06-04-17 08:15 AM

Don't count me in one hundred percent, but I may be able to squeeze a list in before September. I think a few people already know on here that I'm kind of a flake when it comes to these things. :p

rauldc14 06-04-17 10:17 AM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
Any lists in yet?

SilentVamp 06-04-17 01:49 PM

Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 1712487)
Any lists in yet?
Not yet.

I was considering really working on mine soon. I have more than enough to do it, but I will hold off until I have seen all of the movies in the HoF. That decision came to me when I realized that there were a few movies that I regretted when it came to the last two countdowns (either not on my list and that were on my list). I've even regretted some of the placements of those films.

I want to really try to be as solid as I can with my list this time. Hopefully no regrets with this one.

The problem for me is that I think this is such an incredibly strong decade for film that I think I may be just a little unhappy with whatever films I add on the list because there is always going to be another one that I want to include. I think I will doubt myself no matter what.

SilentVamp 06-04-17 01:55 PM

By the way, just as a little note of no real significance (but it kind of is :)), I updated the first post with the nominations from the current HoF and added them to the list.

NedStark09 06-04-17 02:27 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
I sent my Movie List in it took me a while for I remember movie names but not what year sometimes.

SilentVamp 06-04-17 06:00 PM

Yes, we do indeed have our first list from NedStark!

Now it feels like it has officially begun. :D

HashtagBrownies 06-06-17 03:25 PM

Originally Posted by SilentVamp (Post 1689088)
-Partial lists will be accepted after Monday, July 31st
*Looks nervously at the noir list*

Citizen Rules 06-06-17 03:43 PM

Originally Posted by HashtagBrownies (Post 1713830)
*Looks nervously at the noir list*
Noir is your friend:cool:...so no need to be nervous, unless you meet a dangerous femme fatale who convinces you to knock off the local liquor store;)

Citizen Rules 06-12-17 02:55 AM

Originally Posted by NedStark09 (Post 1712560)
I sent my Movie List in it took me a while for I remember movie names but not what year sometimes.
I can't remember years of movies either, so I just Google it. Glad you sent in a list.....

I hope all us good MoFos are watching some 1940's movies and sending in a list of their 25 favorites (details are on the 1st post of this thread):p

ShopkeeperTriumph 06-12-17 03:13 AM

Ok, I was debating it, but I'll start getting at least a couple of 40's movies in every week to contribute to the list.

I know what'll be locked in for #1 no doubt already, though. :p

NedStark09 06-12-17 04:10 AM

Casablanca and citizen Kane have to be up there least in the top 5

rauldc14 06-12-17 05:39 AM

Originally Posted by NedStark09 (Post 1717376)
Casablanca and citizen Kane have to be up there least in the top 5
Those are locks for sure. Double Indemnity will be up there too.

ShopkeeperTriumph 06-12-17 06:32 AM

Originally Posted by NedStark09 (Post 1717376)
Casablanca and citizen Kane have to be up there least in the top 5
Well, I meant mine personally, but oh yeah, absolutely. :p

Citizen Rules 06-12-17 01:48 PM

I know some people think old movies aren't for them...sure they are! They just haven't watched the right ones yet!

In the decade of the 1940's, there's plenty of:
full color movies, glorious B&W too, great westerns, thrillers, crime noir, who done it mysteries, drama, romance and of course comedy and more!

Almost any type of movie that you like to watch today was also made in the 40s.

The best way to get into old movies, is to look for genres or subject matter that you are already interested in. So what are you guys interested in? Post it and I or someone else can make a recommendation:)

cricket 06-12-17 02:05 PM

Originally Posted by Citizen Rules (Post 1717524)
The best way to get into old movies, is to look for genres or subject matter that you are already interested in. So what are you guys interested in? Post it and I or someone else can make a recommendation:)
Porn?

Citizen Rules 06-12-17 02:08 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
You mean Stag Films;)...I think that's what they called it back then.

Chypmunk 06-12-17 03:20 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
Ok, I think we can perhaps mark that request as answered :D

SilentVamp 06-13-17 01:52 PM

Originally Posted by NedStark09 (Post 1717376)
Casablanca and citizen Kane have to be up there least in the top 5
Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 1717383)
Those are locks for sure. Double Indemnity will be up there too.
I just assumed that Casablanca and Citizen Kane would be in the top 5 (unless there is some major surprise, of course), but I don't know if Double Indemnity will be in top 5. I thought it would be top 10, but not top 5. I, of course, am basing it on films that I think deserve a top 5 position more than that one (and there are a few), but I will probably be wrong in the end.

Citizen Rules 06-19-17 11:00 PM

Are you guys going to send in a list for the countdown?

Time's a ticking;) but there's still 3 months left until the deadline on, Sept 3rd, to get those list in! (details on 1st post)


I know that the long time MoFos will participate, but how about you newer people? You're MoFo's too:) and this is a BIG community board wide thing, it's what we do here!

So show your MoFo spirit and make sure to get your list in, but first watch some 1940s movies:p

Cynema De Bergerac 06-20-17 12:48 AM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
Citizen Kane #1
Casablanca #2
I'm pretty sure It's a lock

SilentVamp 06-20-17 05:09 PM

Originally Posted by Cynema De Bergerac (Post 1721870)
Citizen Kane #1
Casablanca #2
I'm pretty sure It's a lock
I think it could very easily be the opposite.


Originally Posted by Citizen Rules (Post 1721794)
Are you guys going to send in a list for the countdown?
I was looking over the films that I have on a couple of lists. The last two lists consist of 106 films, which were then narrowed down to 61. Now when I look at the list of 106, I see movies that I don't want to take off of it.

I knew this was going to be hard, but I really didn't think I would have this much of a problem with it.

Cynema De Bergerac 06-20-17 05:16 PM

Originally Posted by SilentVamp (Post 1722118)
I think it could very easily be the opposite.

Same here tbh :beatty:

SilentVamp 06-20-17 05:35 PM

List #2 is in!

The Gunslinger has sent in his list!

Guaporense 06-21-17 03:56 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
Do short films count?

mark f 06-21-17 05:53 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
I think they always have.

The Gunslinger45 06-21-17 08:08 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
Originally Posted by Guaporense (Post 1722643)
Do short films count?
Duck Amuk made the 50's list. Shorts are good

SilentVamp 06-21-17 08:16 PM

Originally Posted by Guaporense (Post 1722643)
Do short films count?
I never heard one way or the other that they wouldn't count.

And like he said:
Originally Posted by The Gunslinger45 (Post 1722879)
Duck Amuk made the 50's list. Shorts are good
I thought the same thing when I saw that you asked that, Guap.


So, if there are some films that you think deserve to be on it, go ahead and include them.

Citizen Rules 06-22-17 01:14 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
I need some recommendations for this countdown!:)
There's 10 weeks left until the deadline and I want to watch some 1940's movies, so I can send in my top 25 list.

So give me some 40s movie recommendations please:p

SilentVamp 06-22-17 01:53 PM

@Citizen Rules
I have a feeling that if I recommended something to you, you will have seen it. :yup:
Except for the film Kitty, of course. :)

Citizen Rules 06-22-17 02:02 PM

Originally Posted by SilentVamp (Post 1723321)
@Citizen Rules
I have a feeling that if I recommended something to you, you will have seen it. :yup:
Except for the film Kitty, of course. :)
Kitty (1945)
http://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/comp...78i/294679.jpg

This one right?...I found it online and should be watching it soon. It's highly rated but I've never seen it, so should be a real treat:)


SilentVamp 06-22-17 02:08 PM

Originally Posted by Citizen Rules (Post 1723328)
Kitty (1945)
http://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/comp...78i/294679.jpg

This one right?...I found it online and should be watching it soon. It's highly rated but I've never seen it, so should be a real treat:)

That's the one. :yup:


Just for the fun of it, I will have to try to come up with a list and we'll see how many you've seen. :) There's one in my mind already that I have talked about (and no, it is NOT The Pride of the Yankees :D - but I still recommend it to everyone even if they have already seen it - like you!) - but I can't recall if you've ever said that you've seen this particular movie or not. Yeah, that will be my goal for the day. Try to create this list for you. :) I've got absolutely nothing else happening today. :nope:

Citizen Rules 06-22-17 02:10 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
Ha, that's cool:p...and you know even if I've seen one before, it's probably been like over a decade, and so I do need to watch it again.

I want to watch a whole bunch of 40s movies before I send in my voting list:)

The Gunslinger45 06-22-17 03:33 PM

Originally Posted by Citizen Rules (Post 1723308)
I need some recommendations for this countdown!:)
There's 10 weeks left until the deadline and I want to watch some 1940's movies, so I can send in my top 25 list.

So give me some 40s movie recommendations please:p
I highly suggest He Walked by Night from 1948. A Hollywood adaptation of an actual manhunt for a thief, burglar and cop killer. Very well shot, lots of shadows, and full of suspense.

Thursday Next 06-22-17 05:14 PM

Originally Posted by Citizen Rules (Post 1723334)
I want to watch a whole bunch of 40s movies before I send in my voting list:)
According to your lists you have not yet seen Brighton Rock. I think it would be up your street.

https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/i...wy3U3RdQ0j7FgQ

Citizen Rules 06-22-17 05:22 PM

Originally Posted by The Gunslinger45 (Post 1723379)
I highly suggest He Walked by Night from 1948. A Hollywood adaptation of an actual manhunt for a thief, burglar and cop killer. Very well shot, lots of shadows, and full of suspense.
Good one! I've seen that once before, but I can hardly remember it as it was like 10 years ago, so I will try to watch it again. I love noir and I remember it was unique in how the story was told as we see it from the eyes of the cop killer on the run.

Originally Posted by Thursday Next (Post 1723438)
According to your lists you have not yet seen Brighton Rock. I think it would be up your street.

https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/i...wy3U3RdQ0j7FgQ
Nope, I haven't seen Brighton Rock, I'll watch that after I watch Kitty (1948)


Cool that's 3 movies I would never have considered, thanks! Keep them coming:p

SilentVamp 06-22-17 05:28 PM

@Citizen Rules
I am going to take a chance and throw a bunch of film titles out there of ones that I enjoyed.
Like I said, you will probably have seen a few of these (I have a feeling which ones those might be), but I will still mention them, anyway, just in case.

The Corn Is Green
Gaslight
The Uninvited
Thirty Seconds Over Tokyo
Going My Way
The Miracle On Morgan's Creek
Heaven Can Wait
The More The Merrier
Now Voyager
The Palm Beach Story
The Man Who Came to Dinner
Random Harvest
Penny Serenade
The Letter
Here Comes Mr. Jordan
Abe Lincoln in Illinois
Remember the Night
Life With Father
The Heiress
Adam's Rib
Portrait of Jennie
Fort Apache
3 Godfathers
The Picture of Dorian Gray
(this was the movie that I wasn't sure if you'd said anything about having seen it when I mentioned it awhile ago)
The Blue Dahlia
Gentleman's Agreement
My Darling Clementine
The Razor's Edge
Twelve O'Clock High
Sorry, Wrong Number


And of course The Pride of the Yankees. :D Never forget that one! :D :D



Anyway, I tried to come up with enough of a variety of films. I didn't want the list to be too stuck in one genre.

The Gunslinger45 06-22-17 05:28 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
Oh yeah Brighton Rock was good too.

Citizen Rules 06-22-17 08:15 PM

@SilentVamp thanks for the movie recommendations. That helps, as I haven't seen some of those...while others I had forgot all about

I put links in to the IMDB movie page as I was reading about each one, so why not? it saves time for someone else who wants to click and look:p

I haven't seen these:
Here Comes Mr. Jordan Just requested it
3 Godfathers Just requested it too
The Corn Is Green Bette Davis:up: I have this one but haven't ever watched it.
The Picture of Dorian Gray I hope I can find this one.
The Blue Dahlia Veronica Lake, woohoo!
My Darling ClementineJohn Ford cool and my library has it even cooler.
Remember the NightNot sure if I seen this but I have most all of Barbara Stanwyck's film so I'll watch it:p

I've seen these and you got some nice choices there too! I'll try to watch some of these, before the deadline.

Gaslight
The Uninvited
Thirty Seconds Over Tokyo
Going My Way
The Miracle On Morgan's Creek
Heaven Can Wait
The More The Merrier
Now Voyager
The Palm Beach Story
The Man Who Came to Dinner
Random Harvest
Penny Serenade
The Letter
Abe Lincoln in Illinois
Life With Father
The Heiress
Adam's Rib
Portrait of Jennie
Fort Apache
Gentleman's Agreement
The Razor's Edge
Twelve O'Clock High
Sorry, Wrong Number

The Pride of the Yankees!

Guaporense 06-22-17 08:16 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
This: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0041386/
This: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0163040/
This: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0038182/?ref_=nv_sr_1

SilentVamp 06-23-17 04:35 PM

Originally Posted by CitizenRules (Post 1723531)
The Picture of Dorian Gray I hope I can find this one.
I hope you can find that one, too. I only own it recorded off of TV. I never got around to buying the tape, or now the DVD. I was really hoping my library had a copy because this countdown put me in the mood to watch it again, but they don't. :( And we all know I can't watch my videotape of it. :(

Remember the NightNot sure if I seen this but I have most all of Barbara Stanwyck's film so I'll watch it:p
And if you like, you could also watch Remember the Day after Remember the Night. :D Completely different sort of film, but if you are a fan of Claudette Colbert, you get her in there. As for me, I get some John Payne with it. :)

Going My Way
The More The Merrier
Penny Serenade
Oh, gosh darn it! I was really hoping that these three would be movies that would've been a first-time-viewing for you. Oh, well. :)


Abe Lincoln in Illinois
YOU'VE SEEN THIS MOVIE??? :eek: I thought I was the only one! At least I am the only one I know of that has seen it. :)

rauldc14 06-23-17 04:40 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
My fifties list was very tough but this one may be harder. It's going to be a tough one to settle in on a 25.

Citizen Rules 06-23-17 04:53 PM

@SilentVamp

The Picture of Dorian Gray
was easy for me to find online:p, I also find Blue Dahlia and Kitty. But I'm going to have to try harder for My Darling Clementine and Remember the Night

And if you like, you could also watch Remember the Day after Remember the Night. :D Completely different sort of film, but if you are a fan of Claudette Colbert, you get her in there. As for me, I get some John Payne with it. :)
Huge fan of Claudette Colbert:). So I will check that one out.

Oh and I really like Jean Arthur and The More The Merrier was a fun film, but it's been awhile so I'd like to see it again.

Abe Lincoln in Illinois (1940)

YOU'VE SEEN THIS MOVIE??? :eek: I thought I was the only one! At least I am the only one I know of that has seen it. :)
Unless I'm getting it confused with Young Mr Lincoln (1939)...so I'll really will try to watch it, because now I'm curious to which one I've seen.

SilentVamp 06-23-17 11:49 PM

@Citizen Rules
Maybe this will help you to remember which Lincoln film it was that you saw:

Abe Lincoln in Illinois - Raymond Massey

Young Mr. Lincoln - Henry Fonda


I like both of them. I don't know if Abe Lincoln in Illinois will make my 40's list, but Young Mr Lincoln is definitely a contender for my 30's list.

Citizen Rules 06-23-17 11:52 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
Nah doesn't help:p I looked those two movies up after you asked me and I'm still perplexed?

rauldc14 06-23-17 11:52 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
Young Mr. Lincoln was decent, but I haven't seen Abe Lincoln in Illinois.

SilentVamp 06-23-17 11:52 PM

Well, I tried. :D

Citizen Rules 06-23-17 11:55 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
I know, I'll check my library. I'm pretty sure that's where it came from. OK back in a couple minutes.

Citizen Rules 06-23-17 11:58 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
I checked...my library has Young Mr. Lincoln...but doesn't have Abe Lincoln in Illinois. So I've must have seen Young Mr. Lincoln.

Vamp, you might be the only one who's seen Abe Lincoln in Illinois:D

SilentVamp 06-24-17 12:09 AM

Originally Posted by Citizen Rules (Post 1724324)
Vamp, you might be the only one who's seen Abe Lincoln in Illinois:D
It sure looks like it, doesn't it? :)

I will sit through any film that features Lincoln. I don't know why I do because I just spend my entire time thinking things like "That's not how it happened". Those two films (or any, really) aren't too terribly accurate (but they are typical biopics of their eras - so what can you expect?!), but I ended up liking those two films enough to where I can overlook any sort of inaccuracies. And I really like both of them (particularly Henry Fonda) as Lincoln. So that helps to make the films more enjoyable for me to watch.

gbgoodies 06-24-17 12:15 AM

Originally Posted by Citizen Rules (Post 1724037)

Abe Lincoln in Illinois (1940)
Originally Posted by SilentVamp (Post 1724016)
YOU'VE SEEN THIS MOVIE??? :eek: I thought I was the only one! At least I am the only one I know of that has seen it. :)

I saw it years ago because it was mentioned in an episode of "The Dick Van Dyke Show", (when they're IDing Lincoln in a picture, and Rob calls him "The real Raymond Massey".)

But it's been a long time since I've seen it, so it's on my list of movies to rewatch for this countdown.

Frightened Inmate No. 2 06-24-17 12:28 AM

Originally Posted by Citizen Rules (Post 1724324)
Vamp, you might be the only one who's seen Abe Lincoln in Illinois:D
i've seen it and it's good.

SilentVamp 07-10-17 02:29 AM

As it is now after midnight where I live, I will make the announcement that we are now at the 2 month mark.

Only 2 months to go until the deadline to get your lists in by September 3rd.


As a reminder, if you are not intending to send in a full list of 25 films, then you can send your partial list after July 31st.


Also, two more lists are in. One from Camo and the other from 77topaz. :up:


With only 4 in, this countdown already looks like it is going to be a really good one. So keep the lists coming!

gbgoodies 07-10-17 02:46 AM

Originally Posted by SilentVamp (Post 1733278)
As it is now after midnight where I live, I will make the announcement that we are now at the 2 month mark.

Only 2 months to go until the deadline to get your lists in by September 3rd.


As a reminder, if you are not intending to send in a full list of 25 films, then you can send your partial list after July 31st.


Also, two more lists are in. One from Camo and the other from 77topaz. :up:


With only 4 in, this countdown already looks like it is going to be a really good one. So keep the lists coming!

Camo sent you his list? Hopefully that's a good sign that he's only taking a break, and he'll be back soon.

Miss Vicky 07-10-17 11:03 AM

Originally Posted by gbgoodies (Post 1733285)
Camo sent you his list? Hopefully that's a good sign that he's only taking a break, and he'll be back soon.
I wouldn't get too hopeful. He emailed the list to me and asked me to send it to Vamp.

gbgoodies 07-10-17 10:31 PM

Originally Posted by gbgoodies (Post 1733285)
Camo sent you his list? Hopefully that's a good sign that he's only taking a break, and he'll be back soon.
Originally Posted by Miss Vicky (Post 1733385)
I wouldn't get too hopeful. He emailed the list to me and asked me to send it to Vamp.

Now I'm not sure what to think. He sent his list in through MV, so that's a bad sign, but he wanted his opinion to count, so that's a good sign.

If he wasn't planning on ever coming back, he wouldn't care about the countdown, so he probably wouldn't have bothered sending in a list, so I'm still going to hold out hope that he comes back soon. :)

SilentVamp 07-11-17 01:12 AM

Originally Posted by gbgoodies (Post 1733811)
Now I'm not sure what to think. He sent his list in through MV, so that's a bad sign, but he wanted his opinion to count, so that's a good sign.

If he wasn't planning on ever coming back, he wouldn't care about the countdown, so he probably wouldn't have bothered sending in a list, so I'm still going to hold out hope that he comes back soon. :)
I, of course, would love to see him come back here, but I had a feeling that he wasn't going to make another appearance, unfortunately.

Because of that, I'd already planned on asking if he still wanted to send in a list. He just got to sending it to me before I could ever ask him. I know he was looking forward to the countdown. So I felt that he definitely should still be a part of it, and I am happy to see that he didn't need me to ask him for a list because that showed that he still had a lot of interest in participating in the countdown.



Also, our 5th list has arrived by way of Siddon.

Harry Lime 07-11-17 09:49 AM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
Haven't been around much lately, a bit busy, but I'm going to get my list in soon just in case. Ain't never missed a countdown yet and ain't gonna start now!

rauldc14 07-11-17 10:34 AM

Originally Posted by Miss Vicky (Post 1733385)
I wouldn't get too hopeful. He emailed the list to me and asked me to send it to Vamp.
Tell him to get his a$$ back here

Harry Lime 07-11-17 03:12 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
List sent!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n4JpDUMXBqo

TokeZa 07-12-17 10:02 AM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
Sent my list in :D

edarsenal 07-13-17 12:54 AM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
First time popping into this thread; I will be getting my list in within the next week or so

VERY happy to see you running this SV!!!

Pussy Galore 07-16-17 09:57 AM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
I always love those countdowns, it gives me a motivation to really get deep into a decade.

Here are the films of the 40's I haven't seen from the 40's that are available at my library that looks interesting to me (I'd like some comments to see which one I should prioritize):

The Letter (1940) William Wyler
The Mark of Zorro (1940) Rouben Mamoulian
Waterloo Bridge (1940) Mervyn Leroy
The Sea Hawk (1940) Michael Curtiz
49th Parallel (1941) Michael Powell
Ball of Fire (1941) Howard Hawks
The Devil and Daniel Webster (1941) William Dieterle
The Talk of the Town (1942) George Stevens
In This our Life (1942) John Huston
The Major and the Minor (1942) Billy Wilder
Sahara (1943) Zoltan Korda
The Keys of the Kingdom (1944) John M Stahl
Dead of Night (1945) Multiple directors
The Picture of Dorian Grey (1945) Albert Lewin (never read the book)
Dark Passage (1946) Delmer Daves
The Bishop's Wife (1947) Henry Koster
Born to Kill (1947) Robert Wise
Brute Force (1947) Jules Dassin
Green for Danger (1947) Sidney Gilliat
Call Northside 777 (1948) Henry Hathaway
Shoeshine (1948) Vittorio de Sica
The Snake Pit (1948) Anatole Litvak

Siddon 07-16-17 10:07 AM

Originally Posted by Pussy Galore (Post 1736947)
I always love those countdowns, it gives me a motivation to really get deep into a decade.

Here are the films of the 40's I haven't seen from the 40's that are available at my library that looks interesting to me (I'd like some comments to see which one I should prioritize):

The Letter (1940) William Wyler
The Mark of Zorro (1940) Rouben Mamoulian
Waterloo Bridge (1940) Mervyn Leroy
The Sea Hawk (1940) Michael Curtiz
49th Parallel (1941) Michael Powell
Ball of Fire (1941) Howard Hawks
The Devil and Daniel Webster (1941) William Dieterle
The Talk of the Town (1942) George Stevens
In This our Life (1942) John Huston
The Major and the Minor (1942) Billy Wilder
Sahara (1943) Zoltan Korda
The Keys of the Kingdom (1944) John M Stahl
Dead of Night (1945) Multiple directors
The Picture of Dorian Grey (1945) Albert Lewin (never read the book)
Dark Passage (1946) Delmer Daves
The Bishop's Wife (1947) Henry Koster
Born to Kill (1947) Robert Wise
Brute Force (1947) Jules Dassin
Green for Danger (1947) Sidney Gilliat
Call Northside 777 (1948) Henry Hathaway
Shoeshine (1948) Vittorio de Sica
The Snake Pit (1948) Anatole Litvak
Devil and Daniel Webster is a personal favorite, a wholly unique film experience. Brute Force might manage to crack your top 25 it's good enough.

cricket 07-16-17 10:25 AM

For you PG, I'd start with Dorian Gray and Shoeshine.

mark f 07-16-17 02:06 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
Those are all essential, not "deep" into the '40s, but my faves are:

The Devil and Daniel Webster
The Mark of Zorro
Dead of Night
Dark Passage
49th Parallel

Citizen Rules 07-16-17 02:38 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
I've been watching 1940's movies about the war, that's WWII for you youngsters;)

One of the best is:

Twelve O'Clock High (1949)

It's more about the inner-personal struggles of a flight commander (Gregory Peck) as he faces the decision to send young men off on bombing missions over Germany, knowing many of them won't come back. It's a damn good psychological movie about mental anguish.

edarsenal 07-16-17 02:49 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
Twelve O'Clock High IS an excellent movie and a serious contender for my 40's List.

Mark of Zorro has always been THE Zorro movie for me.
Waterloo Bridge was nominated by CR in the first 40's HoF. Sad, but VERY good.
The Letter is a DEFINITE for anyone who enjoys Bette Davis
The Bishop's Wife is a light hearted rom/com which I rather like.

Mr Minio 07-16-17 03:59 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
I have only 26 flicks from the 40's on my Letterboxd watchlist (probably more on another watchlist). I probably won't watch even half of them on time.

edarsenal 07-16-17 05:06 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
that's my worry too. Though I do know the large collection I do have will be hard enough to cut down.
And the way I see it, there are always a number of movies that show up that I discover through the list. So it kinda works out.
But yeah, so many movies to see and THEN cut down to 25!!

SilentVamp 07-16-17 05:15 PM

Originally Posted by Pussy Galore (Post 1736947)
The Letter (1940) William Wyler
Waterloo Bridge (1940) Mervyn Leroy
Ball of Fire (1941) Howard Hawks
The Devil and Daniel Webster (1941) William Dieterle
The Talk of the Town (1942) George Stevens
The Snake Pit (1948) Anatole Litvak
I would say to give any of those a try.

The Bishop's Wife (1947) Henry Koster
This is a fairly "light" picture, but I don't mind it at all.

The Picture of Dorian Grey (1945) Albert Lewin
I've kind of been pushing for people to watch this one. I really like it. It is coming on TV here in a couple of days, and I want to make sure to watch it because I haven't seen it in so long, but it, nevertheless, was always one of my main contenders for my list.

The Major and the Minor (1942) Billy Wilder
It isn't bad. I don't think it would be one to necessarily make your list, but I think it is an OK movie to just watch sometime.

Originally Posted by Citizen Rules (Post 1737005)
I love this movie!!!
And I have nothing more than to say that about the film. :)




Other than the ever important The Pride of the Yankees :D that I want folks to watch, there is another film that I hope people see before the countdown. This is one that I haven't seen mentioned much - if at all (I believe I listed it a couple of posts back). Now Voyager with Bette Davis and Paul Henreid. I watched it again about 2 weeks ago, I think. I just really, really like that one. I hope others will see it before the countdown and maybe they will like it enough to consider it for their lists, too.

SilentVamp 07-16-17 05:20 PM

Originally Posted by Mr Minio (Post 1737041)
I have only 26 flicks from the 40's on my Letterboxd watchlist (probably more on another watchlist). I probably won't watch even half of them on time.
Well, if you only see watch half of them, and you think there are enough that you like, you can always submit a partial list.


Originally Posted by edarsenal (Post 1737062)
that's my worry too. Though I do know the large collection I do have will be hard enough to cut down.
And the way I see it, there are always a number of movies that show up that I discover through the list. So it kinda works out.
But yeah, so many movies to see and THEN cut down to 25!!
You see, my problem that I have had with these lists is that there is always one that I realized I'd forgotten (because it shows up in the countdown), and then I regret not having that one on the list instead. It is very frustrating.

Citizen Rules 07-16-17 06:53 PM

Originally Posted by Pussy Galore (Post 1736947)
I always love those countdowns, it gives me a motivation to really get deep into a decade.

Here are the films of the 40's I haven't seen from the 40's that are available at my library that looks interesting to me (I'd like some comments to see which one I should prioritize):
PG, of the movies you posted I seen these and I put what I think is the film you should watch first in bold.

Waterloo Bridge
(1940) Mervyn Leroy...God I love this movie! It's bittersweet...and it's in my Top 10 Favorites. Please watch that one!

The Snake Pit
(1948) Anatole Litvak...I've been meaning to nominate this for an Hof.

The Letter (1940) William Wyler...solid film!

I've seen the rest of these and there all well worth watching,
In no particular order:
Ball of Fire (1941) Howard Hawks
The Talk of the Town (1942) George Stevens
In This our Life (1942) John Huston
The Major and the Minor (1942) Billy Wilder
Sahara (1943) Zoltan Korda
Dark Passage (1946) Delmer Daves
The Sea Hawk (1940) Michael Curtiz
The Bishop's Wife (1947) Henry Koster
Call Northside 777 (1948) Henry Hathaway

Mr Minio 07-17-17 01:24 AM

Originally Posted by SilentVamp (Post 1737072)
Well, if you only see watch half of them, and you think there are enough that you like, you can always submit a partial list.
I've seen enough 40's masterpieces to submit a full list right now, but I will still wait. Even though I doubt any new film will make its way into it.

edarsenal 07-17-17 12:50 PM

Originally Posted by SilentVamp (Post 1737072)
You see, my problem that I have had with these lists is that there is always one that I realized I'd forgotten (because it shows up in the countdown), and then I regret not having that one on the list instead. It is very frustrating.
I think I've gotten to the point where there's gonna be SOMETHING I missed that REALLY should have been and try to accept it as an actuality. It's STILLl aggravating lol but I try.

Chypmunk 07-17-17 12:57 PM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
I've been blowing hot and cold on this one for a while now and think I've finally decided to sit this one out and just watch what transpires - I'm not gonna rely on decades old memories in some cases so I'd need to rewatch far too many to send in a list I was genuinely happy with and unlike the 50s and sci-fi I just don't have the enthusiasm for watching little else but 40s for a while.

Camo 07-18-17 07:32 AM

Originally Posted by Chypmunk (Post 1737472)
I've been blowing hot and cold on this one for a while now and think I've finally decided to sit this one out and just watch what transpires - I'm not gonna rely on decades old memories in some cases so I'd need to rewatch far too many to send in a list I was genuinely happy with and unlike the 50s and sci-fi I just don't have the enthusiasm for watching little else but 40s for a while.
That's too bad. Do you think there's enough you like and remember to send a partial list?

Chypmunk 07-18-17 07:41 AM

Originally Posted by Camo (Post 1738013)
That's too bad. Do you think there's enough you like and remember to send a partial list?
I'm not a fan of partial lists and I'm not gonna do the films a disservice by 'guessing' at the order for a full one. Sadly I've just been struggling to find the right humour to knuckle down for this one ... I'll still enjoy watching the countdown unfold though :yup:

Camo 07-18-17 08:49 AM

Originally Posted by Chypmunk (Post 1738017)
I'm not a fan of partial lists and I'm not gonna do the films a disservice by 'guessing' at the order for a full one. Sadly I've just been struggling to find the right humour to knuckle down for this one ... I'll still enjoy watching the countdown unfold though :yup:
Still too bad but understandable.

Pussy Galore 07-18-17 09:53 AM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
Watched 44th Parallel, Northside 777 and The Bishop's Wife, enjoyed them all.

I'd rank them like that

#1 Parallel
#2 Northside
#3 Bishop

rauldc14 07-18-17 10:48 AM

Re: The MoFo Top 100 of the 1940's
 
I should get a preliminary list going. Still definitely some stuff I need to see.

SilentVamp 07-18-17 01:18 PM

Originally Posted by Chypmunk (Post 1738017)
I'm not a fan of partial lists and I'm not gonna do the films a disservice by 'guessing' at the order for a full one. Sadly I've just been struggling to find the right humour to knuckle down for this one ... I'll still enjoy watching the countdown unfold though :yup:
Well, that is a disappointment (I was going to suggest a partial list, as well), but what can be done about it when your mind is made up? :)


I have watched a few films now, but not necessarily FOR the countdown. I pretty much know what are the strongest contenders, and I know which ones will most likely make the list. It is the order that I really need to decide upon (although my top 3 would've always been my top 3 - no need to worry about those).

The reason I have been re-watching movies is mainly because this countdown has just put me in the mood for them. Some of the re-watches have been based on the lists that I have received, actually. I have watched some "new" ones as well. These lists have either reminded me of something that I haven't seen in a long time, or they have made me think that I have never seen the film before and I need to watch it to see why it is so well-liked.

And then there are the ones that I already know I really like that I have been re-watching just to re-watch them (today it will be The Picture of Dorian Gray - I have nothing else to do this afternoon and I might as well watch that again).

So I haven't re-watched anything for the sole purpose of what I should put on the countdown. But there happen to be some of the "new" films that have made it onto my contender list.


All times are GMT -3. The time now is 03:16 PM.

Powered by: vBulletin, Copyright, ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright © Movie Forums