Re: Animation Hall of Fame
|
Night On The Galactic Railroad was my 6/9, liked it quite a bit. Glad Waltz With Bashir made the top five seemed like the most polarizing film i had it at 2.
|
Re: Animation Hall of Fame
|
Re: Animation Hall of Fame
Treasure Planet.would have been 6TH if it's votes were included.
|
Castle of Cagliostro was my #3. It improved alot on a rewatch for me.
|
Re: Animation Hall of Fame
|
Re: Animation Hall of Fame
|
Re: Animation Hall of Fame
|
Re: Animation Hall of Fame
Well that's that. An expected blowout! Was a very fun Hall of Fame though and congrats to GBG for winning!
|
Re: Animation Hall of Fame
waAAAAAAAAAALLeeee
|
The moment i saw the nominations i knew there was no way WALL-E was not going to win, i am surprised that Tokyo Godfathers was second though. My List:
01.WALL-E 02.Waltz With Bashir Both top five animated films and among my favourite films of all time. They are pretty interchangeable and i thought about giving Bashir the extra point but i think i prefer WALL-E slightly. 03.Castle of Cagliostro 04.Tokyo Godfathers These two were pretty close, gave the slight edge to Cagliostro because i was amazed how much it improved for me. 05.Secret of Nimh 06.Night on the Galactic Railroad Treasure Planet Wouldn't say any of these are among my favourite animated films but Nimh was another that improved greatly, wasn't a massive fan of it as a kid and Galactic i liked quite a bit. Treasure Planet was my #7 before it was excluded, as i said in my review some things i really liked but others like the humour i wasn't a fan of. 07.Madagascar 2 08.All Dogs Go To Heaven 09.The Last Unicorn Already explained these in my earlier posts, All Dogs didn't hold up as an adult, liked Madagascar more than i expected too and really wish i'd seen Unicorn when i was younger. Congrats gbg :up: And thanks alot for hosting Raul great job it was alot of fun :up: |
I can also post jal90's list if you want since he sent me it by accident :laugh:
|
Re: Animation Hall of Fame
Apparently I deleted my ballot when I cleared out my PM box awhile back, so I don't remember the exact order I had them in. I'm really surprised by how well Tokyo Godfathers did, especially considering the fact that even I didn't have it at #1. I think I had it at #3, behind Wall E and Waltz With Bashir.
|
Re: Animation Hall of Fame
You are correct Miss Vicky. Here is a look at everybody's lists, with Treasure Planet being taken out of everybody's:
Miss Vicky 1. WALL•E 2. Waltz With Bashir 3. Tokyo Godfathers 4. The Secret of NIMH 6. Night on the Galactic Railroad 7. All Dogs Go to Heaven 8. Madagascar 2 9. Castle of Cagliostro 10. The Last Unicorn Cosmic 01. Tokyo Godfathers 02. Waltz with Bashir 03. Wall-E 04. Castle of Cagliostro 05. Night on the Galactic Railroad 06. The Last Unicorn 07. The Secret of Nimh 09. All Dogs Go to Heaven 10. Madagascar: Back 2 Africa Clazor 1 The Secret of NIMH (1982) 2 WALL-E (2008) 3 Tokyo Godfathers (2003) 4 The Castle of Cagliostro (1979) 6 Waltz with Bashir (2008) 7 Night on the Galaxy Railroad (1985) 8 The last Unicorn (1982) 9 All dogs go to heaven (1989) 10 Madagascar 2 (2008) gbgoodies 1) Wall-E (2008) 2) Madagascar 2 (2008) 4) Tokyo Godfathers (2003) 5) Waltz with Bashir (2008) 6) The Secret of Nimh (1982) 7) Castle of Cagliostro (1979) 8) Night on the Galactic Railroad (1985) 9) All Dogs Go To Heaven (1989) 10) The Last Unicorn (1982) Camo 01.WALL-E 02.Waltz With Bashir 03.The Castle of Cagliostro 04.Tokyo Godfathers 05.The Secret of Nimh 06.Night On The Galactic Railroad 08.Madagascar 2 09.All Dogs Go To Heaven 10.The Last Unicorn Rauldc14 1. Wall E 2. Castle of Cagliostro 3. Secret of Nimh Night on the Galactic Railroad All Dogs Go To Heaven Tokyo Godfathers Madagascar 2 Waltz With Bashir 10. The Last Unicorn Jal 1. Wall-E 2. Night on the Galactic Railroad 3. The secret of NIMH 4. Castle of Cagliostor 5. All dogs go to heaven 6. Tokyo Godfathers 7. Waltz with Bashir 8. Madagascar 2 10. The last unicorn Topsy 1.wall-e 2.secret of nimh 3.all dogs go to heaven 4.tokyo godfathers 5.waltz with bashir 6.the castle of cagliostro 7.night on the galactic railroad 8.the last unicorn 9.madagascar 2 Tattmmw2 1 Tokyo Godfathers (2003) 2 Castle of Cagliostro (1979) 3 Wall-E (2008) 4 Night on the Galactic Railroad (1985) 6 The Secret of Nimh (1982) 7 All Dogs Go To Heaven (1989) 8 Madagascar 2 (2008) 9 The Last Unicorn (1982) 10 Waltz with Bashir (2008) |
Waltz WIth Bashir did really well overall, happy about that. Few high placings, few in the middle and only you, Jal and tat had it near the bottom. Sad MM didn't finish as he gave it .
|
Re: Animation Hall of Fame
Sorry bro. I was happy with Cagliostros finish as well. Glad you liked it.
|
Originally Posted by rauldc14 (Post 1626294)
Sorry bro. I was happy with Cagliostros finish as well. Glad you liked it.
|
Re: Animation Hall of Fame
Maybe I will like your part 2 nomination more :)
|
Re: Animation Hall of Fame
Congrats, GBG!
I'm super happy with how NIMH finished. Had hoped it would end up somewhere in the middle, but 3rd was above and beyond. Thanks guys! :up::up: |
Thank You Raul for doing a great job hosting this HoF. :up:
I'm glad everyone enjoyed WALL-E so much. Thanks everyone, and I hope you all remember WALL-E when you submit your list for the Sci-Fi Countdown. :) Am I the only one who didn't think it was a lock to win? I thought it might come in second or third behind Waltz with Bashir and Tokyo Godfathers.
Originally Posted by Camo (Post 1626303)
It's fine mate. Was expecting it, was actually expecting a few to really hate it and only tat seemed to. Think i'm most surprised and pleased at how high gbg had it, was it expecting it to be something she really dislikes.
|
| All times are GMT -3. The time now is 08:45 PM. |
Powered by: vBulletin, Copyright, ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
User Alert System provided by
Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) -
vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright © Movie Forums