Re: Best Picture Hall of Fame Part 2
 

Going back over what’s ineligible, I saw you mentioned The Godfather, but I didn’t see it amongst any of the winners in any past HOF.
Unless I missed it somewhere?

I guess I am wrong, but it's been nominated at least 2-3 times including the last best picture one.

Re: Best Picture Hall of Fame Part 2
 

Understood. It wouldn’t have changed my nominee regardless.
Are we still looking For one more person?
Anyone ask Comsicrunaway?

I won't be joining this one for the same reason I didn't join the last one; there's an awful lot of Best Picture winners that I either didn't like, or just have little to no interest in seeing. Thanks for thinking about me though!

I also want to catch up on the major 2019 films I haven't seen yet before the deadline for the Film Awards, but I haven't managed to watch anything since the thread opened. I should really work on that before the Film Noir HoF gets up and running haha.

Re: Best Picture Hall of Fame Part 2
 

One more would be ideal I would say

I kinda thought The Godfather had won some HoF, but nope. I checked and here's the stats:

19th HoF
#2 The Godfather

Best Picture HoF
# 4 The Godfather

Re: Best Picture Hall of Fame Part 2
 

If we can't get another one, does anyone object to me randomly picking one from a decade not represented? 8 just feels like a good number to me.

Why don't we beg someone to join first (@menition thing)? Maybe get a new member or someone who's never been in an Hof. I think if we give it a couple of days another person or two will join.

Re: Best Picture Hall of Fame Part 2
 

I’m fine with just 7. But it’s up to you guys of course.

Re: Best Picture Hall of Fame Part 2
 

I'm fine with 7 too. Besides I'm wanting to do the Film Noir which I've put on the backburner for this HoF. However if more people want to join that's a plus, so I hope they do:up:

Re: Best Picture Hall of Fame Part 2
 

There's also the possibility of someone joining AFTER the nominations are revealed. So that may get us the #8, or even #9.

What decades have been represented?

Re: Best Picture Hall of Fame Part 2
 

I’ve been wondering the same thing. I’m curious what is represented.

Re: Best Picture Hall of Fame Part 2
 

That gives up too much. A reveal on Sunday...

And so it was written: God did rest on the seventh day, for He was dying to know The Reveal and did not want to miss any of it.
Here sayeth the Lord

basically

somewhat

Re: Best Picture Hall of Fame Part 2
 

Are we ready for the 7 nominees?

Re: Best Picture Hall of Fame Part 2
 

Yes!

Re: Best Picture Hall of Fame Part 2
 

I am! 🙂

Re: Best Picture Hall of Fame Part 2
 

Me three!

Re: Best Picture Hall of Fame Part 2
 

Here are the 7! I will update the front page and add pictures after the ceremony!

Gandhi
Platoon
Unforgiven
Braveheart
American Beauty
The Departed
The King's Speech