Rate My Collection! [Archive]

StarSailor

04-07-04, 06:46 PM

Hey people! This is my collection. Please comment. I have to warn you, there are some crappy ones here (I blame my girlfriend; seriously, you'll be able to pick hers out!).

I'll just give you the titles, nothing about the editions. That's take forever.

Here goes:

12 Monkeys
28 Days Later
Alien
Amelie
American Beauty
Analyze This
Back To The Future Trilogy
Blade
The Blair Witch Project
Bounce
Braveheart
Catch Me If You Can
Conspiracy Theory
Cube
Devil's Advocate
Donnie Darko
Existenz
Face Off
Fight Club
Forrest Gump
The Game
Girl, Interrupted
Gladiator
Good Will Hunting
Gone In 60 Seconds
The Green Mile
Heat
Keeping The Faith
A Knight's Tale
Liar Liar
The Matrix
Memento
The Mexican
Mickey Blue Eyes
Minority Report
Miss Congeniality
Monster's Ball
The Negotiator
Ocean's Eleven
Panic Room
Payback
Pearl Harbor
The Perfect Storm
Pirates Of The Caribbean
Predator
Primal Fear
Rain Man
Rat Race
Requiem For A Dream
Rounders
Saving Private Ryan
Seven
Seven Years In Tibet
The Shawshank Redemption
Shrek
Six Feet Under - Season One
The Sixth Sense
Speed
Spy Game
The Story Of Us
Terminator 2
Three To Tango
Lara Croft; Tomb Raider
Trainspotting
Twister
Unbreakable
The Usual Suspects
Vanilla Sky
What's Eating Gilbert Grape

So, what do you guys think. I'm quite proud of it (especially considering I'm a very poor student).

Cheers, Martin :D

LordSlaytan

04-07-04, 09:47 PM

Alien A+
Amelie A+
The Blair Witch Project A+
Braveheart A+
Forrest Gump A+
Requiem For A Dream A+
Saving Private Ryan A+

Rain Man A
Panic Room A
Minority Report A
Memento A
The Green Mile A
Fight Club A
Catch Me If You Can A
12 Monkeys A
28 Days Later A
American Beauty A
Seven A
The Shawshank Redemption A
The Sixth Sense A
What's Eating Gilbert Grape A
Unbreakable A
The Usual Suspects A
Monster's Ball A

Miss Congeniality A-
The Mexican A-
Payback A-
Primal Fear A-
Vanilla Sky A-
Trainspotting A-
Seven Years In Tibet A-
Donnie Darko A-
The Game A-
Girl, Interrupted A-

Conspiracy Theory B+
Gladiator B+
Back To The Future Trilogy B+
Predator B+
The Matrix B+
Mickey Blue Eyes B+
Rounders B+
Shrek B+
Speed B+
Terminator 2 B+

Blade B
Existenz B
Heat B
Pirates Of The Caribbean B
Ocean's Eleven B
Good Will Hunting B

Cube B-
Face Off B-
The Perfect Storm B-
The Story Of Us B-

The Negotiator C+
Bounce C+
Spy Game C+
Rat Race C+

Keeping The Faith C
Devil's Advocate C

Gone In 60 Seconds C-
Lara Croft; Tomb Raider C-
Analyze This C-
Twister C-

A Knight's Tale D+

Liar Liar D
Pearl Harbor D

Three To Tango N/A
Six Feet Under - Season One N/A

I like it.

poeman

04-07-04, 10:54 PM

12 Monkeys = B +
28 Days Later = C
Alien = A-
Amelie = A
American Beauty = A
Analyze This = B+
Back To The Future Trilogy = A
Blade = B-
The Blair Witch Project= A-
Bounce = B+
Braveheart = A+
Catch Me If You Can = B
Conspiracy Theory = C-
Cube = B
Devil's Advocate = B
Donnie Darko = B +
Existenz = C
Face Off = B +
Fight Club = A
Forrest Gump = A +
The Game = C
Girl, Interrupted = B-
Gladiator = A -
Good Will Hunting = B +
Gone In 60 Seconds= C
The Green Mile= A-
Heat = A ( one of the underated one)
Keeping The Faith = C
A Knight's Tale = C
Liar Liar = B
The Matrix = A
Memento = A
The Mexican = B -
Mickey Blue Eyes = C-
Minority Report= A -
Miss Congeniality = B -
Monster's Ball = A -
The Negotiator = B +
Ocean's Eleven = B +
Panic Room = A -
Payback = B
Pearl Harbor = C
The Perfect Storm = B
Pirates Of The Caribbean = B+
Predator = A-
Primal Fear = C
Rain Man = A -
Rat Race = B -
Requiem For A Dream = B
Rounders = B -
Saving Private Ryan = A +
Seven = A-
Seven Years In Tibet = A
The Shawshank Redemption = A +
Shrek = A -
Six Feet Under - Season One= A -
The Sixth Sense= A -
Speed = B
Spy Game = C
The Story Of Us = C +
Terminator 2 = A
Three To Tango = A -
Lara Croft; Tomb Raider = B -
Trainspotting = C +
Twister = B +
Unbreakable = B +
The Usual Suspects = A
Vanilla Sky = B +
What's Eating Gilbert Grape = C +

StarSailor

04-08-04, 12:38 PM

Thanks guys!

My comments:

Lord Slaytan:
I kinda agree with you. However, I would personally rate The Matrix, Gladiator and Ocean's Eleven a bit higher than you did, and I'd rate Payback a bit lower.

Poeman:
How on this cruel, cruel Earth can you rate Three to Tango an A- and, say, Trainspotting, 28 Days Later and Primal Fear a C?!

Guess there's just no accounting for taste! :)

Keep the comments coming!

Cheers, Martin :D

Sinny McGuffins

06-04-04, 08:27 PM

Great collection. But there's not a lot of movies that I'd watch more than twice. I only buy DVDs that I'd watch over and over again.

Psion

06-05-04, 01:21 PM

Same here parky!

Escape

06-15-04, 06:07 AM

12 Monkeys-y
28 Days Later-n
Alien-y
Amelie-n/a
American Beauty-n
Analyze This-n
Back To The Future Trilogy-y
Blade-y
The Blair Witch Project-y
Bounce-n/a
Braveheart-n/a
Catch Me If You Can-n/a
Conspiracy Theory-n
Cube-n/a
Devil's Advocate-n
Donnie Darko-n/a
Existenz-n
Face Off-y
Fight Club-y
Forrest Gump-n
The Game-y
Girl, Interrupted-n
Gladiator-y
Good Will Hunting-n/a
Gone In 60 Seconds-y
The Green Mile-n
Heat-y
Keeping The Faith-n/a
A Knight's Tale-n
Liar Liar-y
The Matrix-n
Memento-y
The Mexican-n/a
Mickey Blue Eyes-n/a
Minority Report-y
Miss Congeniality-n
Monster's Ball-n/a
The Negotiator-n
Ocean's Eleven-n
Panic Room-y
Payback-y
Pearl Harbor-y
The Perfect Storm-n
Pirates Of The Caribbean-y
Predator-y
Primal Fear-n
Rain Man-n
Rat Race-y
Requiem For A Dream-n/a
Rounders-y
Saving Private Ryan-y
Seven-y
Seven Years In Tibet-n
The Shawshank Redemption-y
Shrek-y
Six Feet Under - Season One-n/a
The Sixth Sense-y
Speed-y
Spy Game-n/a
The Story Of Us-n/a
Terminator 2-y
Three To Tango-n/a
Lara Croft; Tomb Raider-n
Trainspotting-n
Twister-y
Unbreakable-y
The Usual Suspects-y
Vanilla Sky-n
What's Eating Gilbert Grape-n/a

Moviez&Dvdz4life

08-07-04, 09:35 PM

Moviez&Dvdz4life

08-07-04, 09:35 PM

Please reply to me with your ratings!

Thanks!

Tazz

08-08-04, 02:40 PM

im bored so why not

1. Matrix Reloaded B+
2. Pirates of the Caribbean A+
3. SW Ep II: Attack of the Clones B-
4. Master and Commander B
5. LOTR: The Return of the King A+
6. The Last Samurai A
7. Black Hawk Down A
8. SpiderMan B+

Ash_Lee

08-08-04, 03:35 PM

1. Matrix Reloaded (2 disc full screen edition) B+
2. Pirates of the Caribbean (2 disc widescreen edition) A+
3. SW Ep II: Attack of the Clones (2 disc full screen edition) Z-
4. Master and Commander (widescreen - that's all they sold it in, i think) A
5. LOTR: The Return of the King (2 disc full-screen edition) A-
6. The Last Samurai (2 disc full-screen edition) B+
7. Black Hawk Down (1 disc widescreen) N/A
8. SpiderMan (Full-screen edition) A

Holden Pike

08-08-04, 06:29 PM

Here, once again is my pathetic list:

1. Matrix Reloaded (2 disc full screen edition)
2. Pirates of the Caribbean (2 disc widescreen edition)
3. SW Ep II: Attack of the Clones (2 disc full screen edition)
4. Master and Commander (widescreen - that's all they sold it in, i think)
5. LOTR: The Return of the King (2 disc full-screen edition)
6. The Last Samurai (2 disc full-screen edition)
7. Black Hawk Down (1 disc widescreen)
8. SpiderMan (Full-screen edition)

Wow, that truly is pathetic!

Grade for ALL discs where you have purposefully bought the full-screen edition: F
As for the few others...
Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl, B+
Master & Commander: The Far Side of the World, B
Black Hawk Down, C+

Garrett

08-08-04, 06:54 PM

Putting aside the fact that most are full screen:

1. Matrix Reloaded (2 disc full screen edition) B-
2. Pirates of the Caribbean (2 disc widescreen edition) C
3. SW Ep II: Attack of the Clones (2 disc full screen edition) C-
4. Master and Commander (widescreen - that's all they sold it in, i think) ?
5. LOTR: The Return of the King (2 disc full-screen edition) A-
6. The Last Samurai (2 disc full-screen edition) B-
7. Black Hawk Down (1 disc widescreen) C
8. SpiderMan (Full-screen edition) A-

Overall Average: B-