View Full Version : Superman vs Magneto
sunfrog
01-08-04, 08:57 PM
If Superman and Magneto fought, Magnus would incase Supes in a planet of pure metal so dense he couldn't bust out. He would also squeeze Supes cojones in a metal vise.
CujoLink
01-09-04, 12:43 PM
I think Magneto would win, he's way to smart to be beaten by Supes, Before he actually fought him he would know all about him, he would kill him if needed but probably not.
It could alter by where they fought. In a city Magneto could easily buy time to pull off his master schemes by just putting some peoples life in threat, like throw a bus or two.
I think Magneto would win, he's way to smart to be beaten by Supes, Before he actually fought him he would know all about him, he would kill him if needed but probably not.
It could alter by where they fought. In a city Magneto could easily buy time to pull off his master schemes by just putting some peoples life in threat, like throw a bus or two.
Superman can move almost at the speed of thought. He thinks about doing something and executes it almost as fast. For example:
Superman can go up into space, out of Magneto's sight completely, Magneto would have no idea where he would be. Superman could see the hairs on Magneto's arm from space. In half a second, Superman could fly in, crush Magneto, and be in the North Pole making lunch before Magneto could think of the wry quip he usually throws out before smashing someone. Magneto's powers are somewhat limited as well in comparison to Supes, who has a variety of powers, one being almost complete invulnerability. Superman thinks, moves, and reacts on a different level. His perception of time is different. Many times I have seen a scene where a wind is felt, and people are looking around wondering just where that wind came from. Meanwhile Supes has been by, done a few tasks and moved on. As Superman approached (once or twice, breeched) the speed of light, relativity suggests time would appear to slow and stop for him. Magneto on the other hand would lurch and putter about wondering why he is wearing a tutu all of a sudden. He would then pass out from a small air implosion next to his ear, perhaps created by superman applauding his new get-up. Next thing he knows he is waking up in a plastic prison on the planet Bleen. It should only take him about 3 light years to get back.
Magneto rocks, but these are apples and oranges here...
:( You took all the fun out of this thread.
:( You took all the fun out of this thread.
I did? bummer, was it not a Supes vs Magneto discussion?
:confused:
CujoLink
01-13-04, 03:16 PM
Well........Magneto has a helmet :p
Well........Magneto has a helmet :p
So did the creepy kid in 5th grade. :eek:
cjblaze2001
04-18-04, 09:16 PM
If magneto was on any planet with metal he is unstoppable because he could create and magnetic forcefield around his body that is unbreakable. I believe magneto is smarter and would have too much power with all of the metal around him and would stick KYRPTONITE or what ever it is up supermans butt and create a huge metal bat and hit him to the depths of space. But if superman was in space and so was magneto superman would kick his butt.
Garrett
04-18-04, 09:26 PM
As much as I dislike him, Superman would probably win.
chicagofrog
01-25-05, 11:51 AM
but but but... does Superman have metal particles in his blood too? if yes, he's lost, s. comicbooks for reference!
Tea Barking
01-25-05, 02:05 PM
Galactus would smite them both :cool:
http://pc59te.dte.uma.es/cdb/series/marvel/bitmaps/galactus.jpg
I'll say it again. People who can alter time will beat people who can't.
chicagofrog
01-25-05, 02:19 PM
not if you kill 'em before they have an occasion to...
But see, this doesn't make sense, as you can't kill anyone or do anything when time is stopped. Superman is an alien and percieves time differently than humans or mutants (unless said mutant has time slowing/changing capabilities as well ie proteus). It all comes down to whether or not Mags would have kryptonite. If he didn't, his magnetic powers (controlling magnetic fields/waves) would have no effect on a creature of such foreign density of mass. As we have been shown in both the films and the comics, there is not enough metal in blood for magneto to manipulate, hence mystique injecting the tubby guard with a bunch of metal, which could of course never happen to superman. It's one fo the reasons I am not a big Superman fan. He is just too strong. He would still win easily, every time vs an old man who lurches and putters about. At this point in time in the comics, Magneto is actually dead, and won't be beating anyone. I'm sure they will bring him back sonner or later though, as they do with EVERY character that ever dies in (marvel) comics (boooooooo).
blibblobblib
01-25-05, 03:33 PM
Magento would so win! Iv'e met him, (in case no one knew ;) )and even though his arm is around me, i felt in awe of his immense power...he is the Almighty....When i left his company, all my credit cards were wiped and i couldnt get home from London. plus he had sneekly bent my car keys...the swine.
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v318/mrlast/copyofp1010161.jpg
Look at those magnetic fingers! Immense!
blibblobblib
01-25-05, 04:55 PM
Yay! ;)
HellboyUnleashed
01-25-05, 10:12 PM
magento would kill superman within minutes. magneto would find a big deposite of kryptonite in metal rocks and bring it down on superman before he could think and superman would die a terrible death. But i also think that batman could kill them both. Batman is the best superhero because he thinks on his feet and doesnt need any superhuman powers.
AboveTheClouds
01-25-05, 10:16 PM
magento would kill superman within minutes. magneto would find a big deposite of kryptonite in metal rocks and bring it down on superman before he could think and superman would die a terrible death. But i also think that batman could kill them both. Batman is the best superhero because he thinks on his feet and doesnt need any superhuman powers.
Flawed Logic. It's not like Magneto has any special powers except his magnetic personality (hehe) he could throw cars or whatever at Superman, but Superman could punch through the damn things, or simply throw them back. If Magneto even left himself open for a brief second Superman would take advantage of it and beat magneto to dust. And for Magneto to find the kryptonite it would take him a little while.. Because i'm sure he'd have to go to krypton to get it.
Richard Hell
01-25-05, 10:50 PM
Magneto would own Superman, for there is so many ways to kill superman, magneto could make giant tractor full of kyrptonite and throw it at him. But in the end its a comic so super man would some how win.
and yet there arent "so many ways to kill" Magneto??? He controls metal, he isnt superfast, doesnt have x-ray vision, or super strength, how would he even know which direction to throw a giant tractor to hit the big S-man?
chicagofrog
01-26-05, 08:27 AM
Magneto is actually dead, and won't be beating anyone. I'm sure they will bring him back sonner or later though, as they do with EVERY character that ever dies in (marvel) comics (boooooooo).
Sedai! ssshhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh! don't divulge so much, some new fans of comics may not wanna know...
(and you and me know that his daughter has better looks... so what about her becoming the new master of magnetism??
- so sure he's gonna be back? what about the Phoenix then, her death was a bigger surprise, wasn't it? and replacing her by her daughter too, i dunno, she doesn't have Jean's loooong history...)
undercoverlover
01-26-05, 02:46 PM
ill put this simply as this is probably how it would be anyway
Supes wins because he always does, he always beats the bad guy no matter how smart he or she is
Krackalackin
05-21-05, 04:52 PM
Galactus would smite them both :cool:
http://pc59te.dte.uma.es/cdb/series/marvel/bitmaps/galactus.jpg
There's no doubt about that. Superman would go down quick and hard against Galactus. It would be like swatting a fly. How about this one, Silver Surfer Vs. Superman.
This is a good one. Now, I dont know about all that different demention of thinking for Superman. From reading his comics, he thinks pretty plainly. He's no Thanos or Galactus, that's for sure. But his biggest Problem in a fight with Silver Surfer is well, there's a lot actually, lol. Not only can Silver Surfer re-arrange molecules but he can also change matter into different matter. Imagine the hysterical scene of Silver Surfer turning Superman's arm into a block of Kryptonite? LOL. That would be funny. But ofcourse, Superman is Superman and he would be resistant to such things But Superman's also matched with brains, sensory perception, speed, and almost Strength. We'll say Superman has a slight edge with strength. Also, Silver Surfer has a vast pool of Cosmic energy to reign down on Superman with his fists. Superman can take a lot naturally, but I don't think he could take the Surfer when all is said and done. Silver Surfer has too many advantages. I think Superman would be more than powerful enough to reach the silver Surfer up close to smash him in the face, but I don't think Superman could take him.
Here's a good one, How about Wolverine vs. The Hulk
X Factor vs. The X-men
Thor vs. Superman
Galactus vs. Thanos
Thanos vs. Silver Surfer
Juggernaut vs. The Hulk
Psylocke vs. Jean Grey
Apocalypse vs. Galactus
Apocalypse vs. Superman
and yet there arent "so many ways to kill" Magneto??? He controls metal, he isnt superfast, doesnt have x-ray vision, or super strength, how would he even know which direction to throw a giant tractor to hit the big S-man?
Depends on how powerful he really is, cause can magneto do thousands of things at once or not? As in continuesly throw tractors in every direction at once and then pull them back and throw them again, while covering himself in a shield of about 2m thick of metal. Using radar or something to tell where superman is. Is there really a definite answer to this or not? I don't think so, so lets continue the debate!!
sunfrog
06-13-05, 11:51 PM
There are different types of kryptonite so some of it might be magnetic. All magneto has to do is creat a kryptonit web around the earth so Superman can't fly away then park a giant kryptonite meteor on Metropolis. The meteor would be so big it would affect Supes no matter wher on earth he was. Then just leave the meteor there until Supes dies of weakness.
Then just leave the meteor there until Supes dies of weakness.
die of weakness?? ok let's just say he dies from radiation poisoning or something it's more credible :p
If Superman has Iron in his blood then he is a toast, no iron.... Maggie is a burnt bagel.
vBulletin® v3.8.0, Copyright ©2000-2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.