Russian Language Hall of Fame

[neiba]

Solaris (1972)

So... not sure what to think of this. I think I loved it, but Tarkovsky has this way of making me totally depressed and with no energy after his films. It happened in every single one of his films I watched so far and Solaris is no exception.

I felt kind of lost during the first part cause I was not sure about what the story had the intention to portrait. I understand that it is necessary so we can understand the main's character in a better way, though, so in that sense I liked the continuous feeling of depression and unwillingness to live (at least I interpreted that way)
Then it became more and more interesting when they get to the ship. The fact that the corridors and most of the rooms are almost always empty and silent contributes to the general feeling of the film.
The pacing is so slow that it gets almost excruciating (in a good way), like Tarkovsky is forcing the viewer to reflect on his own past even if the memories are not happy.
Hari is a great character, as well as Kevin, but I think this film is about something more important than all the characters taking part in the story. It has the ability to transform into something personal to each viewer, like every piece of great art.

Just a though: 2001: A Space Odyssey kept coming to my mind while watching this. Will not say if it's a better film or worse, don't know, don't care. But the two films may complete each other on a combined vision of humanity's past and future, delivered by two absolute masters of cinema.

4 +

[rauldc14]

Visitor to a Museum

https://78.media.tumblr.com/6d2e14f4a7f3bfdd141f2a5efcb69fc7/tumblr_nc06miUya51tgkpruo3_r1_1280.png

A very interesting desolate and hellish world is created by the director here. The setting is very haunting and gives off an eerie vibe in this post apocalyptic world. I very much enjoyed the scenery with the mountain of trash, the fire in the windows, and the sea and it's storms. I will also say I was pretty engaged in what was going on in the first half. The movie then seems to take a Lynchian turn and disengages me. I began to wonder what was really going on. I guess it really didn't matter because I seemed to care less and less. Overall, it does a lot of things well, it just doesn't keep it up and follow through. Some scenes near the end seemed a bit dragging which takes down my overall view of the film as well. Still, an interesting nom.

3

[Ultraviolence]

I'm very busy this week with college, many tests, and October is the busiest in my job. I make tombstones, in anticipation of the Day of the Dead (September 2), there comes much service. So, this week I'll not be able to see more movies, but next week I'll take the time to finish this HoF. Only one missing! Cosmic kindly provided me Ivan Lapshin with English Subs!

[Citizen Rules]

Visitor to a Museum

...I very much enjoyed the scenery with the mountain of trash, the fire in the windows, and the sea and it's storms. I will also say I was pretty engaged in what was going on in the first half.

The movie then seems to take a Lynchian turn and disengages me. I began to wonder what was really going on. I guess it really didn't matter because I seemed to care less and less...
Exactly how I felt about the movie. The ending didn't do much for me, but I loved the fire and the trash. Don't know why sci-fis always have lots of trash in the future:p

[rauldc14]

I'm be looking to watch Ivan on Monday or Tuesday and then that's a wrap from me

[Citizen Rules]

I'm be looking to watch Ivan on Monday or Tuesday and then that's a wrap from meI'd suggest reading about Ivan, before watching it. I was confused what was going on, but had I read a little about it, I might have gotten more out of the film.

[neiba]

I've already watch Ivan Lapshin and Leviathan. I'm really tired so won't write nothing about them tonight (also reallyconcerned about elections on Brazil, so can't focus). Just to let everyone know that I've only one watch to go and I'll finish this before the deadline.

[rauldc14]

My Friend Ivan Lapshin

I liked this well enough. It's supported by a very good screenplay in my opinion. The dialogue and the subtitles are easy to follow and flow real well with the film. The highlight of the film is the tremendous camerawork for me, as well as the film having quite a bit of incredibly looking shots. I guess I wasn't completely drawn to the characters but I certainly cared enough about them that it didn't put a damper in the filmwatching. It's a shame that I don't really have a lot to say for the film, but I am glad I saw it and it seems like a worthy contender in this Hall of Fame.

3.5

[rauldc14]

I just sent in my list to Justin as well

[Ultraviolence]

Brazil has been on fire lately. Elections and their repercussions are going crazy here, I have not watched Ivan yet, I'm going to watch (finally huh?) tonight or tomorrow (it's a holiday)! I'll send my list monday morning, is that okay? If not, let me know and I'll find a way!

[jiraffejustin]

Brazil has been on fire lately. Elections and their repercussions are going crazy here, I have not watched Ivan yet, I'm going to watch (finally huh?) tonight or tomorrow (it's a holiday)! I'll send my list monday morning, is that okay? If not, let me know and I'll find a way!

Monday is fine :up:

[Ultraviolence]

I just sent in my list to Justin! :)

[rauldc14]

I still think Stalker is the favorite but after that who knows what happens

[jiraffejustin]

neiba TokeZa

Can I get a status update? Just to know how long I should leave this open.

[neiba]

neiba TokeZa

Can I get a status update? Just to know how long I should leave this open.

Sending you my list in 5 minutes! :)

[TokeZa]

neiba TokeZa

Can I get a status update? Just to know how long I should leave this open.

I will send it as soon as possible!

[jiraffejustin]

All the votes are in except for mine, I'll finish watching Leviathan this weekend and get the results up on either Sunday or Monday.

[rauldc14]

All the votes are in except for mine, I'll finish watching Leviathan this weekend and get the results up on either Sunday or Monday.

Sweet, look forward to it man!

No time soon, but a Japanese one would be cool.

[jiraffejustin]

I didn't finish Leviathan, so you can either consider my nom in or out. It didn't win, so I guess it's whatever. Sorry, I didn't finish up, guys. I won't keep y'all waiting any longer.


8th Place - 17 Points
Planeta bur
http://www.lpafilmfestival.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/ESTRELLA_PLANETA-BUR_DE-Pavel-Klushantsev_800.jpg
Highest vote: 3rd place

[jiraffejustin]

7th Place - 21 Points
Leviathan
http://sensesofcinema.com/assets/uploads/2017/12/LeviathanHEADER-750x400.jpg
Highest Vote - 1st Place

[jiraffejustin]

6th Place - 25 Points
My Friend Ivan Lapshin
https://s3.drafthouse.com/images/made/ivanlapshin3_717_426_s.png
Highest Vote: 3rd Place (x2)

[jiraffejustin]

Tie 4th Place - 30 Points
Ballad of a Soldier
https://oldschoolmanblog.files.wordpress.com/2010/11/0022.jpg
Highest Vote: 3rd Place (x2)





Tie 4th Place - 30 Points
Visitor of a Museum
https://i.pinimg.com/originals/69/c0/cb/69c0cb3ad769d3c0a447f348858bbf31.jpg
Highest Vote: 1st Place

[jiraffejustin]

3rd Place - 39 Points
Stalker
http://www.cageyfilms.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/stalker_10.jpg
Highest Vote: 1st Place (x2)

[jiraffejustin]

2nd Place - 41 Points
The Cranes Are Flying
https://4.bp.blogspot.com/-SjpAuRFSuPU/U3hCZpu3KaI/AAAAAAAAJMU/h9462t9rr54/s1600/008-the-cranes-are-flying-theredlist.jpg
Highest Vote: 1st Place

[jiraffejustin]

The Winner - 49 Points
Solaris
https://3.bp.blogspot.com/-wx7ate6Vj7w/WcNkvC1VcHI/AAAAAAAAIR8/ZBQvl_oFj4Uu24Y5yAgkKvvStAYSq2SvQCLcBGAs/s1600/Solaris%2B2.jpg
Votes: 1st Place (x2), 2nd Place (x4), 4th Place, Would have been my #1 too

[rauldc14]

So happy Solaris won! And glad Cranes beat Stalker too!

[Citizen Rules]

Thanks @jiraffejustin (http://www.movieforums.com/community/member.php?u=76459) for hosting this. It was a nice slower paced Hof, like how Russian cinema is paced:) I'm glad I joined as I got to see a bunch of Russian classics that I would have not seen otherwise.

Happy to see Solaris win, but surprised Stalker came in at #3. I expected those two to finish 1,2 and in any order.

This is my voting list:

1 Solaris (1971)
2 Stalker (1979)
3 Ballad of a Soldier (1959)
4 The Cranes Are Flying (1957)
5 Planeta bur (1962)
6 Leviathan (2014)
7 My Friend Ivan Lapshin (1985)
8 Visitor of a Museum (1989)

I think all of the movies were noteworthy noms.

[jiraffejustin]

I think Raul doomed Stalker's chances. He's not much of a fan, I take it.

[CosmicRunaway]

I knew Planeta Bur would finish last when I decided to nominate it, so there's no surprise there haha. Here was my list:

01. The Cranes are Flying
02. Solaris
03. Planeta Bur
04. Visitor of a Museum
05. Stalker
06. Ballad of a Soldier
07. Leviathan
08. My Friend Ivan Lapshin

Thanks for hosting JJ! I wouldn't have minded waiting a bit longer since you only had one film left, but I assume you made the best decision for you, so don't worry about it. Hopefully we'll see you in future HoFs if you have the time. :up:

[rauldc14]

What was your list looking like Jiraffe?

[rauldc14]

Here's my list

1. Solaris
2. Cranes are Flying
3. Ballad of a Soldier
4. My Friend Ivan Lapshin
5. Visitor to a Museum
6. Leviathan
7. Planeta Bur
8. Stalker

[jiraffejustin]

What was your list looking like Jiraffe?

Something like this:

1. Solaris
2. The Cranes are Flying
or 2. Stalker
4. Visitor of a Museum
or 4. My Friend Ivan Lapshin
6. Planeta Bur
7. Ballad of a Soldier

I've seen the first 40 minutes or so of Leviathan, it was trending in a positive direction. I wouldn't have been surprised to see it nab the 6th spot on my list. For this hall of fame, that isn't too bad of a spot to occupy. A lot of great films were nominated, and none of them are films that I am upset about seeing. Thanks to everybody who participated.