Log in

View Full Version : Dark City


skizzerflake
11-01-16, 10:50 PM
Dark City

Some spoilers follow. Dark City is one of those movies I have to come back to now and again, this time after I accidentally broke my DVD copy and had to go on a quest for a Blue Ray version to replace it. Seemingly the best we will ever see from Director and Co-Writer Alex Proyas, Dark City didn’t make any money in its original release in 1998, but it subsequently became a cult film, with me as one the cult members. When I mention the film to someone, they usually draw a blank and ask what sort of movie it is. I made up a genre, which is noir/sci-fi/fantasy/German Expressionist. The look of the movie and some of its sets were borrowed for use in the later Matrix series, which was filmed at the same studio in Australia.

Dark City takes place on an extraterrestrial planet, engineered by The Strangers, spider-like energy beings who occupy pale human male corpses, dressed in black long coats and hats. Strangers are averse to sunlight, chlorine and salt and hence have engineered the city so it is always dark. The Strangers are a perishing race, condemned by their hive mind. They are fascinated by human adaptability and want to understand how humans think. To that end, they have abducted numerous humans. Each day the humans are put to sleep at midnight, have memories removed and inserted and begin each day not realizing what came before, all to help the Strangers in their attempt to understand us. The Strangers have psychokinetic ability, and use it to rearrange the city each night, so they can study how humans react.

The story begins when John Murdock (Rufus Sewell) wakes up in a grimy bathtub, bloodstained and disoriented, seemingly having murdered a woman. He is alerted by phone by the strange Doctor Schreber (Kiefer Sutherland), that he is in danger from the Strangers, and goes on the run. Eventually he remembers his name and that he’s married to a nightclub singer Emma (Jennifer Connelly, prior to plastic surgery). The city he lives in is a nightmare, a mashup of a lot of cities, always dark and wet, populated by people who fall asleep at midnight when the Strangers change their memories. John, however, is resistant, can “tune” as the Strangers call it, and is gradually discovering what is going on. The Strangers have enlisted a human detective, Frank Bumstead (William Hurt), who is seeking John, presumably for the murder of the dead woman. Meantime, John and Emma have images in their minds of a place called Shell Beach, a sunny place full of salt water, someplace the Strangers can’t go. Everybody in Dark City has heard of Shell Beach, but nobody knows where it is. When Dr. Schreber restores John’s memory, he realizes that he has the same psychokinetic abilities as the Strangers. He also realizes that he has to overcome the hold the Strangers have on the humans.

The first thing I have to acknowledge about Dark City is that it’s not an easy movie. It really benefits from several watchings. The entire movie has the sort of non-logic that comes with dreams, as though you think you should understand something but it’s always just out of reach. The look of the film is truly amazing and very dark. The plot is sci-fi and noir detective, but the look is like some sort of off-center voyage into films like The Cabinet of Dr Caligari, Nosferatu and Metropolis. The German Expressionist silent film influence is all over this movie. It also channels the look of some noir films, plots of Twilight Zone episodes and strong hints of Franz Kafka. Apparently Proyas wrote the story and was assisted by Lem Dobbs and Dave Goyer with the screenplay. I don’t think it has an antecedent in a book, but is an original story. From what I have read, it was a troubled production and the final product is somewhat cobbled together, but as it is, Dark City is really worth watching. It challenges your picture of what a sci-fi story can be and puts you into this dark dream world where little makes sense or has continuity. Once you do get a grip on what’s going on, it’s full of fascinating, multi-layered plot twists. The film is somewhat slow to develop, giving you a chance to immerse yourself in the surrealistic environment. You should watch it at night when your brain’s right hemisphere (the part of your brain that’s intuitive and visual rather than logical or verbal) can take over and you won’t expect a linear, logical plot. Watching it at night will also keep the Dark City…well, dark. In a cinematic world where fantasy and sci-fi seem to be completely dominated by big budget superhero movies that are just boring predictable clones of each other, this gem is really a pleasure. If you missed it, see it now and if you saw it and didn’t understand it or like it, watch it again.

4.5

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gt9HkO-cGGo

TJ Sigmier
05-27-24, 02:25 PM
Dark City was a fun film with a great and diverse cast. I would love to see this film giiven a decent 4K/Blu ray edition. It was a nice blending of Nior and Sci-Fi slathered in a mystery. The lighting was amazing and a restoration would help to give the images greater depth and volume.
Another title needing that 4K/Blu ray love is The Keep, still no decent edition...just a dvd edition, and not a very solid copy...but it's bettet than a VHS copy, LOL!!!!

skizzerflake
05-27-24, 03:07 PM
Dark City was a fun film with a great and diverse cast. I would love to see this film giiven a decent 4K/Blu ray edition. It was a nice blending of Nior and Sci-Fi slathered in a mystery. The lighting was amazing and a restoration would help to give the images greater depth and volume.
Another title needing that 4K/Blu ray love is The Keep, still no decent edition...just a dvd edition, and not a very solid copy...but it's bettet than a VHS copy, LOL!!!!

I have a DVD that dates way back, do wish for a better version. The closest I have come was a box set that used it as filler, but it's still DVD, though not a bad one.

Same thing with The Keep, another old favorite. That one has the added asset that my first watching was trapped in a beachfront hotel during a nor'easter that "exploded", trapping us in the building with flooded roads. I enjoyed the movie, but had to dry out my car the next morning.

skizzerflake
05-27-24, 03:27 PM
Dark City was a fun film with a great and diverse cast. I would love to see this film giiven a decent 4K/Blu ray edition. It was a nice blending of Nior and Sci-Fi slathered in a mystery. The lighting was amazing and a restoration would help to give the images greater depth and volume.
Another title needing that 4K/Blu ray love is The Keep, still no decent edition...just a dvd edition, and not a very solid copy...but it's bettet than a VHS copy, LOL!!!!

Just checked Amazon. There is a blue ray version of the movie, as well as a Dark City that's a LA police expose and a completely different fictional version, another LA noir, interestingly starting Charlton Heston and featuring Jack Webb and Harry Morgan, outside of the Dragnet universe.

GulfportDoc
05-27-24, 08:11 PM
Yes, here's the one you're referring to:

Dark City (1950)

Stars: Charlton Heston, Lizabeth Scott, Dean Jagger, Viveca Lindfors, Jack Webb, Harry Morgan, Ed Begley, Don Defore, and Mike Mazurki.
Director: William Dieterle, DP: Victor Milner, Score: Franz Waxman. Paramount PIctures.

I was surprised that, with all the heavyweights involved in this noir, that the end product was rather mediocre. Veterans Dieterle, Milner, and Waxman evidently could not overcome the average screenplay, despite the fact that the story sounds good on paper.

A bookie joint is busted by the police. The owner (Heston) decides to set up private poker games to fleece unsuspecting players. One businessman (Defore) gets set up, and ends up losing a $5000 check that wasn't his. He subsequently commits suicide. The guys in the poker game start getting murdered. Turns out the businessman's brother (Mazurki) is avenging his brother's death. Heston's girlfriend (L. Scott), a chanteuse, is trying to convince Heston to take their relationship more seriously, but he doesn't want to settle down. Heston subsequently goes looking for Mazurki, and the story winds down from there.

There were several faults in the screenplay. There was too much film showing Scott performing songs, for no real reason. The story could have been structured better.

Still, it was absorbing to see Heston in his first appearance (and starring) in a feature motion picture. His action showed nuance, and he had plenty of charisma. Likewise Dean Jagger gave a first rate performance as the police chief.

Of note were Jack Webb and Harry Morgan, who of course later co-starred in the long running TV series Dragnet. It was peculiar seeing Webb as a slime ball. He actually had some chops. If you've never seen Pete Kelly's Blues (1955), he was excellent in it. Morgan has been in a million of them. He also had an excellent run as Col. Sherman T. Potter in the TV series, MASH ('74-'83).

And it's worth mentioning that the title was used in the titles for at least two marvelous books on film noir: Eddie Muller's superb Dark City: the Lost World of Film Noir; and Spencer Selby's Dark City, the Film Noir.

This is a picture worth watching for the actors. Otherwise it has the feel of a "B" crime drama.

Doc's rating: 6/10

skizzerflake
05-27-24, 11:19 PM
Yes, here's the one you're referring to:

[LEFT] Dark City (1950)

Stars: Charlton Heston, Lizabeth Scott, Dean Jagger, Viveca Lindfors, Jack Webb, Harry Morgan, Ed Begley, Don Defore, and Mike Mazurki.
Director: William Dieterle, DP: Victor Milner, Score: Franz Waxman. Paramount PIctures.
[SIZE=2]
I was surprised that, with all the heavyweights involved in this noir, that the end product was rather mediocre. Veterans Dieterle, Milner, and Waxman evidently could not overcome the average screenplay, despite the fact that the story sounds good on paper.


We're actually looking for a Blue Ray version of the sci-fi-fantasy-noir movie of the same name with Keifer Sutherland, Jennifer Connelly and William Hurt. I understand that it drew inspiration from The Maltese Falcon, Twilight Zone and Franz Kafka, quite a crew to bring into one story....definitely sci-fi-noir. Somehow this excellently weird movie seems to have sunk into obscurity, but they do have it on Amazon as well as the other two movies called Dark City. It's a director's cut, not sure whether that's good or not.

GulfportDoc
05-28-24, 08:34 PM
We're actually looking for a Blue Ray version of the sci-fi-fantasy-noir movie of the same name with Keifer Sutherland, Jennifer Connelly and William Hurt. I understand that it drew inspiration from The Maltese Falcon, Twilight Zone and Franz Kafka, quite a crew to bring into one story....definitely sci-fi-noir. Somehow this excellently weird movie seems to have sunk into obscurity, but they do have it on Amazon as well as the other two movies called Dark City. It's a director's cut, not sure whether that's good or not.
I sent you a P.M.

TJ Sigmier
05-30-24, 01:39 PM
Thanks Guys, sorry for the confusion, I do have the Bllu ray of Dark City (1998). Yeah there is also a newer film with the same name (2020) but not the same film. So many films seem to be reciveing a remaster/restoration when being upgraded to a 4K format. This is definatly one that would benefit from such an upgrade.

As the tech for film restoration becomes more efficient and cost effective, going back when moving to doing a 4K/8K format becomes more possible all the time.
https://youtu.be/FxqhywhPGL4

skizzerflake
06-08-24, 11:44 PM
Thanks Guys, sorry for the confusion, I do have the Bllu ray of Dark City (1998). Yeah there is also a newer film with the same name (2020) but not the same film. So many films seem to be reciveing a remaster/restoration when being upgraded to a 4K format. This is definatly one that would benefit from such an upgrade.

As the tech for film restoration becomes more efficient and cost effective, going back when moving to doing a 4K/8K format becomes more possible all the time.
https://youtu.be/FxqhywhPGL4

One of my all time favorites in what might be a genre of one or at least a few...noir-sci-fi-fantasy. I wish the movie had more notoriety. It's oddly timeless in that it doesn't really fit in any place any of us have ever been, so it can't really get dated. The logic of the movie is really strange.

TJ Sigmier
06-13-24, 02:52 PM
Right SkizzerFlake, but that is part of it's charm and attraction. And really, it does make sence with in it's own context. Alien obduction/sampling/experiment/test subjects within a Alien "Skinner box" ~ still a very under rated film.

Taz
07-24-24, 08:30 AM
I was on the set for this movie and in a couple of scenes as an extra, lol. Long time ago now, when I was living in Sydney.