View Full Version : 20 Questions MoFo Style
I am unsure whether this is a good idea or not, but am hopeful that maybe some people will respond to it. My favorite part of MoFo is when people get active conversations going about specific movies. My hope is by basically mixing the idea of the Rate The Last Movie and Grill a MoFo thread, that it will happen more frequently. I know a lot of people don't like to write reviews and those that do don't have the time to write one on every single movie they see. So if you come here post the movie you have just watched and answer the twenty questions in the post below. It will hopefully be an easy and expedient way for people to probe a bit deeper into the movie they have just seen. By answering these questions hopefully others that have seen the movie will respond to your answers. Simple and hopefully fun.
I want this to be a fluid thread. This is not a game, so you don't have to answer every question for every movie. The questions are not scientific or set in stone, so feel free to tweak and adjust as you see fit. Shoot any ideas to me about questions you would change or expound upon as well. I will put the questions in the next post of the thread for easy replying or copy/paste.
A few of your fellow MoFos helped me out with coming up with the questions. Thank you guys very much for that, you know who you are, and I hope you will participate.
20 Questions
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
9. What would you tell people about the script?
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you?
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be?
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years?
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
Mr Minio
11-04-14, 06:45 PM
21. Did the movie give you a boner?
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/b/bc/PathsOfGloryPoster.jpg/220px-PathsOfGloryPoster.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
Want to eventually watch all Kubrick, this one showed up on Netflix.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
I would love to say I related to Douglas's character, but he is much more bad ass than me.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Very and this is not by accident. He is our hero throughout.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
General Mireau. He is the antagonist and a scene chewer. I loved this character.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Mostly. A couple of soldiers didn't impress me.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Bleak
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
Yes, unfortunately not in a good way. That happens to me a lot in the classics.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
Great when they are in town. The movie looked fantastic on Netflix HD quality. Looks a bit dated in the battlefields, but not as much as some older movies.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
Tight. well written but not flowery.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
Not really, it is more about the scenes as a whole.
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
The court martial was fantastic because it was so infuriating. The opening scene between the two Generals is a close second.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
War films usually make me melancholy, true here.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
Not at all
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
I would have liked it to be longer for more character exposition. Possibly could have been a favorite if I would have fell in love with any of the characters. Maybe re-watches would help with that.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
Strangelove but probably because if the Kubrick connection. It is anti-war for sure, but not satire.
16. Did you check your watch while watching the film?
No, the film is really tight at 90 minutes.
17. After watching did you want to hug or slug the director?
Hug, for only the second time watching a Kubrick
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
Strangelove, 2001, Clockwork, The Shining, Full Metal Jacket, Eyes Wide Shut.
Thus far I only like his war movies, and I don't love those but think they are really well done. I think The Shining is fine, but with the love it gets that may as well be hate.
19. Will you recommend this movie to a friend?
Yeah, as a good not great war film.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
3.5
21. Did the movie give you a boner?
My thread doesn't accept those.;)
Sexy Celebrity
11-04-14, 07:16 PM
I'll do this with Nightcrawler.
http://www.movieforums.com/community/attachment.php?attachmentid=18267&stc=1&d=1415142045
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
Jake Gyllenhaal.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
Rick, the assistant to Louis Bloom. Because I know what it's like to be involved with a sociopath.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Well, who was the protagonist? Louis Bloom was the main character and he's more the antagonist. If it's Rick, then yes, I did.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
Forgetting the whole "protagonist" thing, my favorite characters were Louis Bloom (Jake Gyllenhaal) and Nina Romina (Rene Russo). There really weren't that many characters in the movie. I did also really like Detective Fronteiri (Michael Hyatt) for getting all up in Jake's face at the end.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Jake Gyllenhaal did, I'd say.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Nihilistic.
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
I may have been, but I don't remember it well.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
There were a lot of night scenes.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
I think the script is alright, but I also think the movie relies heavily on Jake Gyllenhaal's star power. Without someone like him involved, I think Nightcrawler is the kind of movie that might not get made.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
Some people have said the movie has some great lines, but I didn't really notice anything that pops out.
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
Hmmm... not particularly one scene, but everything involving Jake and that house filled with all the dead bodies, him filming the killers and then him and Rick going after the killers at the diner and filming that whole thing. The police chase, etc.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Interested. Entertained. Fascinated. I was never bored, thank God.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
The ending.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
I would change the ending somehow.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
Fight Club.
16. Did you check your watch while watching the film?
Once, but not because the movie was boring me. Just needed to know the time.
17. After watching did you want to hug or slug the director?
To hell with the director. Give me the actor.
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
I think this was his first movie?
19. Will you recommend this movie to a friend?
Absolutely.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
rating_4 right now. Possibly higher someday.
21. Did the movie give you a boner?
Well, it might surprise you, but no. Of course, I don't really remember for sure.
Mr Minio
11-04-14, 07:19 PM
My thread doesn't accept those.;) My body does.
BlueLion
11-04-14, 07:20 PM
Blade Runner
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
It was actually a rewatch. I was sitting in my room, thinking of what to watch, and for some reason I just felt like rewatching Blade Runner. I guess it's something to do with the atmosphere of the film.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
I wouldn't really say I could relate to any of the characters.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
I guess.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
Rachael, duh.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
To some extent, yes.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Dark.
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
Yes, it's one of my favorite things about the film.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
Many things. I think it's a visually stunning film.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
Not too complex, but it doesn't spoonfeed you, which is good.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
"Quite an experience to live in fear, isn't it? That's what it is to be a slave."
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
Probably the intro, or any scene which is similar to it.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Confusion. But I don't mean this in a bad way, or in regards to the film or its plot.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
Not really.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
This is a tough question. I'd choose to include something truly shocking, probably, but that would change the tone of the film completely.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
Probably Solaris. I think it has a few things in common with Tarkovsky's film, but not the same level of depth or complexity.
16. Did you check your watch while watching the film?
Once, maybe, but I do that with most films.
17. After watching did you want to hug or slug the director?
Neither.
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
I've seen Alien, Gladiator, Black Hawk Down, Prometheus, The Counselor and Thelma and Louise.
19. Will you recommend this movie to a friend?
Yes.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
Three and a half stars out of five.
Citizen Rules
11-04-14, 07:30 PM
Great idea for a thread Sean! It's great to see people post more than just a rating for the film they just watched.
I like it that you say this is fluid so we can skip questions or tweak them to suit our needs.
I'm glad to see you used a few of my questions that I suggested:) And all the questions are good ones!...This should be a fun thread if we all support it...AND it can be a great way to learn a bit more about films too.
Citizen Rules
11-04-14, 07:38 PM
Mackenna's Gold
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_6qgeWVXWLfY/S_FhJ0GGY9I/AAAAAAAAAwo/Z_UwdGWffLM/s1600/Mackenna%27s+Gold.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
Someone at MoFo mentioned it.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
Not at all, the characters were about 2 dimensional as they come.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
It had a star studded cast but NONE of the characters stood out. Omar Sharif played the antagonist and did have onscreen charisma.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
The tone was much like a modern CG blockbuster type movie, heavy on gimmicks, light on character development. There was even a big special effects earthquake scene. But still a fun movie.
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
No, it didn't stick out, which is a good thing.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
Despite the fact that it was shot in Monument Valley, the cinematography itself was pretty standard for 1969 styles.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
No.
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
The escape on a river raft with 6 people AND horses, down a raging river with a waterfall...was excited.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
None really.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
Good question;) Seeing how the film didn't try to be high brow or artistic...No, it didn't insult my intelligence like some films do.
16. Did you check your watch while watching the film?
Another good question...yes I did in a way, as I checked to see how long until the movie was over on the DVD.
17. After watching did you want to hug or slug the director?
I'd probably just shake his hand and say, ahh it was kind of fun.
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
Honestly at this point I don't remember who directed it.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
3
Bonus question (that I just made up) Was there a hot actresses in the movie?
Why yes, there was! Camilla Sparv
I'll follow Sexy's lead since I just saw Nightcrawler Sunday.
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/d/d4/Nightcrawlerfilm.jpg/220px-Nightcrawlerfilm.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
Positive buzz coming from TIFF
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
Not even a little bit.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
I better not have. A true anti-hero.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
Probably Paxton's, though this is Gyllenhaal's movie through and through.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Gyllenhaal sure did, my favorite performance of his.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Amoral
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
At times. I liked it but may not if it was overused, thankfully it wasn't.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
Beautiful. I compared it to Michael Mann in my review. Hazy crime drama.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
Excellent. Gyllenhaal has quite a few stand out monologues.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
There was a line I was going to remember to quote in my review. I didn't, but trust me it was goood.:D
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
I think Gyllenhaal's and Russo's date. It was the turning point where you knew things were going to go full on freaky.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
I have said it a few times already. It is weird for this type of movie but I just felt happy to be entertained.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
No, you certainly have to suspend your belief a bit but this does not lead to insult for me here.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
Russo's character. I don't know how, but I did not like her at any point.
17. After watching did you want to hug or slug the director?
Hug
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
Sexy is correct, this was his first. I have seen a few he has written.
19. Will you recommend this movie to a friend?
Definitely
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
4
Miss Vicky
11-04-14, 08:04 PM
http://www.angelfire.com/music6/walteregan/TorysMovies/Top100/quills.jpg
Quills (Philip Kaufman, 2000)
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
Well this time around I watched it because I nominated it for the Fifth Hall of Fame. I was initially drawn to it because it looked really dark and sexy.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
There were several, actually. I related to de Sade because I enjoy writing and I share his views on sexuality and religion. I also related to both Maddy and Simone as they both come from a place of naivete when it comes to sex, but both find a way to explore their sexuality and challenge the expectations set upon them by society and the men in their lives.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Of course. I really enjoyed de Sade's lust for life and his passion for words. The film has a great deal of humor and much of that comes from Rush's lines. On the other hand, in many ways I feel like du Coulmier was the real protagonist and I looked upon him in a very favorable way.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
The Abbe du Coulmier, of course. I really enjoyed watching his journey from naivete to depravity. Also, he's played by Joaquin Phoenix and is sexy as hell.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Definitely. I think Rush in particular really chewed up the screen and disappeared into the role of de Sade.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Dark.
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
Not really, no.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
I really liked the use of some of the objects in the film, like the peepholes and the mirrors.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
It's a fantastic mix of dark humor and sexuality.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
There are plenty. De Sade's quip about God stands out the most, though: "He strung his own son up like a side of veal. I shudder to think of what he'd do to me."
But there's also a little exchange between du Coulmier and de Sade when the abbe catches Maddy in de Sade's room:
"You know you're not to entertain visitors in your quarters."
"I'm entertaining you now."
"But I'm not a beautiful young prospect, ripe for corruption."
"Don't be so sure."
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
When du Coulmier orders de Sade to strip. It's meant to be a power play, a way for du Coulmier to get de Sade under control and finally silence him, but it's really apparent that de Sade - even stripped of every tangible thing he has - still holds the power and will not be cowed by anyone.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Is horny an emotion? :laugh:
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
No.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
Honestly, nothing comes to mind.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
No.
16. Did you check your watch while watching the film?
No.
17. After watching did you want to hug or slug the director?
Hug, of course.
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
I've seen The Unbearable Lightness of Being (which was, indeed, unbearable) and Invasion of the Body Snatchers, which I really enjoyed much to my surprise.
19. Will you recommend this movie to a friend?
I recommend this movie to everybody.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
5
BlueLion
11-04-14, 08:06 PM
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
Beautiful. I compared it to David Mann in my review. Hazy crime drama.
Surely you mean Michael Mann?
I must admit, my expectations for this film are sky-high. I can't remember the last time I looked forward this much to a new release, I really can't wait to see it. Seems like just my kind of film.
Surely you mean Michael Mann?
I must admit, my expectations for this film are sky-high. I can't remember the last time I looked forward this much to a new release, I really can't wait to see it. Seems like just my kind of film.
Yeah, my bad. I'll change. Don't know who the hell I was thinking of.
BlueLion
11-04-14, 08:11 PM
You were probably thinking of this dude http://www.imdb.com/name/nm2052942/
You were probably thinking of this dude http://www.imdb.com/name/nm2052942/
That's it. Can't get enough Tyler Perry sitcoms.
cricket
11-04-14, 09:04 PM
High and Low (1963)
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/6/6a/HIGH_AND_LOW_JP_.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
I'm currently focusing on 1963 in anticipation for the future 60's list. This seemed like one of the must sees.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
No
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Yes, I did. He was a tough businessman, but still a good man.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
I liked his long term right hand man who turned on him. I thought he had guts.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Yes, I thought so.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Precise
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
No
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
Nothing special, it's not something I always make particular note of. Everything always looked good.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
Intelligent
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
The dialogue was all very good, but there was not any single line that I thought was like that.
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
The scene on the train about 45 minutes in.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Anger, excitement
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
No
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
Nothing
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
No
16. Did you check your watch while watching the film?
No
17. After watching did you want to hug or slug the director?
Neither
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
Yes; The Seven Samurai, Rashomon, Dersu Uzala, Ikiru, Yojimbo, and Sanjuro.
19. Will you recommend this movie to a friend?
Yes
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
4.5
Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion
http://filmcriticism.files.wordpress.com/2009/09/cap002-1.jpg?w=497&h=185
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
I wanted to see what my Criterion DVD looked like, and my friend hadn't seen it.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
I could relate to the central character because even though he was a smug murderer, he was totally unpredictable and he was meant as a symbol for a larger societal ill.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
He was a pathetic character who was full of power, so I didn't look up to him, but as a representative of the adage that "power corrupts" he served his purpose well.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
His lover, who played kinky sex murder games with him but taunted his inadequacies was also a favorite.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Gian Maria Volonte and Florinda Balkan, as the characters mentioned above, were perfect. Some of the supporting cast were a bit overdone but that was to serve the film's purpose.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word: Satiric.
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
Since it's by Ennio Morricone and is one of his weirdest, I would say "yes", like everybody else.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
Oftentimes the camera prowled amongst the settings and the characters, leaving the viewer surprised at where it ended up. Even some of the most-static long shots conveyed a sense of movement by having the characters walk toward or away from the camera. The few overhead shots were particularly satirical, providing political commentary.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
Highly-original, thought-provoking, thrilling (will he get caught or not?), satirical, absurdist, scary (since it's not that far-fetched).
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
Many but here's one - "Others have the task to educate and to cure. We have the duty to repress! Repression is our vaccine! Repression is civilization!"
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
The scene where he confesses, goes home and awaits his arrest. The high-ranking police come and "prove" he didn't do it.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
The initial emotion is laughter, but later I felt disgust at the institutionalized abuse of power in some (most? all?) governments.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted? Hell no.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
I would have trimmed some unnecessary exposition in the latter section of the middle third of the film.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching? Z, The Tenth Victim
16. Did you check your watch while watching the film? What watch?
17. After watching did you want to hug or slug the director?
Hug, congratulate and have a friendly conversation with. Too bad he died at an early age from cancer.
18. Have you seen other films from this director? Yes - The Tenth Victim
19. Will you recommend this movie to a friend? Certainly.
20. What is your rating on a five star scale? 3.5+
The Sci-Fi Slob
11-05-14, 09:45 AM
http://img.over-blog.com/212x300/3/85/36/69/Images-2/Image-24/Dead-End.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
I'd been meaning to watch it for a while and review it on my blog.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and
how?
Yes, Frank Harrington - he was pissed off pretty all of the film.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Yes, he was hilarious!
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and
why?
His wife because she was funny and stupid at the same time.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
No.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word: Slapstick.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
Dark, atmospheric and creepy.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
A collection of funny gags and cliches.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
Will this f*cking nightmare ever end? - Frank Harrington
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
The final scene when Frank Harrington chases the ghost of a woman into the woods with a shotgun shouting "I coming for you you f*cking bitch aahhhh!" :D
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
It made me laugh.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
More on-liners from Frank Harrington.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
Yes, horror comedys like Shaun of the Dead, Zombieland and Tucker and Dale vs Evil.
16. Did you check your watch while watching the film?
Nope.
17. After watching did you want to hug or slug the director?
Hug and kiss.
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
Nope.
19. Will you recommend this movie to a friend?
Yes, it's hilarious. :up:
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
rating_4
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/b/bc/Interstellar_film_poster.jpg/220px-Interstellar_film_poster.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
It's Nolan. What else am I doing on a Friday more important.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
Tom, who is the son.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Yeah. Very likable character
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
Murph. She is the emotional core.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Not really. I felt like I was watching the actors.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Ponderous
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
I was aware of every sound blaring from the speakers. Including the score.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
Fantastic to look at. Many memorable shots.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
Not all bad, but if anything bogs down the film, it is the script.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
We used to look up at the sky and wonder at our place in the stars, now we just look down and worry about our place in the dirt.
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
The first flight through the worm hole was pretty great.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Equal parts bewilderment and exhilaration.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
I may not be smart enough to have my intelligence insulted because no.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
Less emphasis on the "science" and more emphasis on the relationships.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
Gravity though i am not really sure why
16. Did you check your watch while watching the film?
No
17. After watching did you want to hug or slug the director?
I would give him a fist bump.
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
Seen them all, like them all. Love some, this probably won't be one.
19. Will you recommend this movie to a friend?
Go see it. Nolan makes movies worth watching in the theater.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
3
Godoggo
11-08-14, 01:53 AM
20 Questions
Ballast
http://i61.tinypic.com/35lut09.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
It's one of my absolute favorites and I wanted to watch it with someone.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
Yes. I could relate to all of them in their isolation as well as their strong need for one another.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Yes. Very much so. These were people who faced with tragedy are just doing the best they know how to do. They are far from perfect, but they are survivors that connect with each other to become something more.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
The neighbor. He is someone who wants to help, but doesn't really know how. The fact that he tries makes me really like him.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Completely. All the main actors had never acted before this film. It never once felt anything other than authentic. You feel like your looking into a window at real people living real lives.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word: somber
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
There isn't one.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
The realism
9. What would you tell people about the script?
It's stripped down. The entire movie is stripped down. There isn't much more said than what needs to be said. Words do not tell the story in this film.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
No, not really. Outside the context of the entire movie there isn't a line that would mean much.
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
The scene when Lawrence and Marlee confront each other about his twin and her husband.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Sadness and hope.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
Not at all.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
I don't think it's perfect, but I think it's the way it needs to be so I would leave it alone.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
No
16. Did you check your watch while watching the film?
No
17. After watching did you want to hug or slug the director?
No movie has ever made me want to do either. I would tell him great debut though.
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
There are none
19. Will you recommend this movie to a friend?
I already did.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
4.5
What movie did you watch? :)
Godoggo
11-08-14, 02:47 AM
Oh, good grief. I can't believe I forgot to put the name of the movie. :facepalm:
I edited it in.
Never even heard of Ballast Godoggo. I will check it out.
What do you guys think of the questions? I changed the hug or slug the director question, I didn't feel that one was going over so well. Any other that seem poor?
Sexy Celebrity
11-09-14, 08:59 PM
Come up with 50 or 100 questions and allow people to pick 20 out of them. Different movies may require different kinds of questions.
Come up with 50 or 100 questions and allow people to pick 20 out of them. Different movies may require different kinds of questions.
Good thought for a possibility. Going to need some help with that though, and no boner questions.:)
Godoggo
11-09-14, 09:17 PM
What do you guys think of the questions? I changed the hug or slug the director question, I didn't feel that one was going over so well. Any other that seem poor?
Yeah, I didn't really get that question.
I don't think the would you recommend this to a friend question is necessarily a bad one, but I don't think it requires any thought about the movie itself. You could pretty much assume that if someone gives a movie a high rating that they would recommend the movie to a person that liked that type of a movie. It ends up being a question that doesn't give any extra information.
My suggestion would be to continue to replace questions as the game progresses that don't seem to be working. I realize every question might not be the best fit for every movie, but if you give people to many choices to pick from they may go for what's easiest to answer rather than what causes them to think more critically about the movie.
It's a great game. I like it much more than someone just throwing a rating up. It can also be a helpful exercise for people to put some thought into how they feel about a movie.
Citizen Rules
11-09-14, 10:31 PM
I like this thread, it's a great idea. I'm bit disappointed to see it off to a slow start.
I started to do another movie with the 20 question and after 15 minutes, I accidentally deleted my post. I thought about starting over, but didn't want to spend that much time.
That made me realize that 20 questions are too time consuming for people to answer.
How about 5 questions? or 7? People will only do that which is easy.
Some of the 20 questions are good. BUT when I read a post here for a movie I never seen, most of the questions that are answered don't really tell me what I need to know....if I would like the movie?
There's always this thread (http://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?t=5936) which I replied to several times. :)
I like this thread, it's a great idea. I'm bit disappointed to see it off to a slow start.
I started to do another movie with the 20 question and after 15 minutes, I accidentally deleted my post. I thought about starting over, but didn't want to spend that much time.
That made me realize that 20 questions are too time consuming for people to answer.
How about 5 questions? or 7? People will only do that which is easy.
Some of the 20 questions are good. BUT when I read a post here for a movie I never seen, most of the questions that are answered don't really tell me what I need to know....if I would like the movie?
I will keep tweaking. I actually thought it got a decent response but then died over the last couple of days. I am going to keep posting in it and see what happens.
Citizen Rules
11-09-14, 10:47 PM
Maybe you could post here and ask the MoFo reviewers what questions they liked answering and which they didn't care for. Also ask the readers which questions they liked reading the responses too.
I realized right off the bat some question were fun to read and others didn't seem to work. Maybe if you ask for input?
Cobpyth
11-09-14, 10:55 PM
I'll answer the questions for the two films I watched this evening. Cool thread, Seanc!
Aliens (1986)
http://s3.foxfilm.com/intlportal//52570d2b56c39.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
I really like the first one and hadn't watched this praised sequel yet, so I felt it was time to finally fix that.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
Ellen Ripley of course!
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Yes.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
Bishop, the Artificial Human. Ellen was prejudiced against him because of her former experiences, but in the end he proves himself a true hero!
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Definitely!
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Thrilling!
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
At times I was.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
The lighting was dark, gritty, "filthy" and alien-like. It works perfectly.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
The plot works perfectly as a sequel and a well constructed, thrilling action film. The dialogue wasn't especially impressive and felt a bit cheesy at times, but it didn't particularly bother me.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
"Get away from her, you b*tch!"
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
The scene where Ripley aims to rescue the girl from the Alien Queen.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
I was full of adrenaline.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
Not really.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
I'd make some of the dialogues between the soldiers in the first half of the film less cheesy and more interesting content-wise to build up their characters.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
Alien obviously and also several war films.
16. Did you check your watch while watching the film?
No. I never check my watch during films.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be?
I would probably ask him a question about the special effects in the movie (how he realized and edited certain scenes with the aliens in a believable way).
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
I've now seen 5 of Cameron's 8 films (including this one). I haven't seen True Lies, The Abyss and Piranha Part Two: The Spawning (yet).
19. Will you recommend this movie to a friend?
Definitely. If you liked the first film and if you're in the mood for some very well executed action, this is a film for you!
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
4-
It's not as subtly crafted as the first film, but this sequel is a blast that offers plenty of thrilling entertainment!
Next film is coming...
What do you guys think of the questions? I changed the hug or slug the director question, I didn't feel that one was going over so well. Any other that seem poor?
Maybe you could post here and ask the MoFo reviewers what questions they liked answering and which they didn't care for. Also ask the readers which questions they liked reading the responses too.
I realized right off the bat some question were fun to read and others didn't seem to work. Maybe if you ask for input?
I thought I did.:D
Citizen Rules
11-09-14, 11:01 PM
Sean, I just wanted to make sure if I posted some question suggestions (that's a tongue twister) that it would be OK with you.
Sean, I just wanted to make sure if I posted some question suggestions (that's a tongue twister) that it would be OK with you.
Of course.:up::up:
Godoggo
11-09-14, 11:06 PM
20 Questions
Captain America: The First Avenger
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
It wasn't my turn to pick. ;)
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
Mmm. Not really on a personal level, but the good characters are written in a very relatable way.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Yeah. He lacks the edge and flair that I prefer in my super heroes, but I didn't find him quite so bland on this rewatch.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why? Red Skull of course. Hugo Weaving makes a great villain.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles? I don't know about lost, but it's well cast and well acted.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word: retro
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie? Yes
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography? Nothing note-worthy
9. What would you tell people about the script? It's classic super hero style stuff going on here.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable? Nothing. I'm just a kid from Brooklyn. ~ Steve Rogers
11. What was your favorite scene and why? I guess I really like the end when he meets Nick Fury because you know The Avengers are going to get together.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel? Fun isn't really an emotion, but it's a fun movie meant to be entertaining and have fun watching so whatever emotional state that puts you in is it.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted? No, not insulted. It's not meant to be an intellectual movie so it doesn't actively engage the brain, but I don't feel stupid for having watched it either.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be? I think I'd write in some snappier dialogue. Captain America isn't edgey so I wouldn't bring that element into it, but I think the dialogue could be amped up a bit.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching? Yes, The Avengers and that I didn't remember Captain America in that movie a whole lot.
16. Did you check your watch while watching the film? No
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be? Hmmm.. I think I'd ask him if he could change one thing about the movie what would it be?
18. Have you seen other films from this director? Yep. He directed the biggest disappointment of my life (at least in regards to movies)
19. Will you recommend this movie to a friend? If they were big fans of comic book movies.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
3
Sexy Celebrity
11-09-14, 11:08 PM
I don't like the "Did you check your watch while watching the film?" question.
If you want an opinion... that one just seems unnecessary to me.
Sexy Celebrity
11-09-14, 11:09 PM
Also, I don't like the question "What do you have to say about the script?"
Because to me -- I'm not watching a script. A script is something you read. I'm watching a movie.
Citizen Rules
11-09-14, 11:12 PM
Cesar Chavez
http://images.redbox.com/Images/EPC/Kiosk/7430.jpg
1. Why did you choose this movie to watch?
I like history.
2. Describe the tone or feeling of the film:
It's semi documentary style. Mostly low key with a few scenes of indignation as the strikers were abused.
3. What would you tell people about the movie?
It's not exciting or action packed, but a small Indy film that covers an import part of recent history that many people are unaware of.
4. Have you seen other films from this director?
No
5. Is this like the type of film you usually watch?
Yes, I like Indy films and films about recent history.
5. What is you rating on a five star scale?
rating_3
Godoggo
11-09-14, 11:13 PM
I will keep tweaking. I actually thought it got a decent response but then died over the last couple of days. I am going to keep posting in it and see what happens.
I think it's gotten a good response as well. The last two days have been weekend days, so that's to be expected.
I also want to say that I really like the what would you ask the director question in place of the other. For some movies that is going to be one of the best questions, I think.
Citizen Rules
11-09-14, 11:15 PM
I don't like the "Did you check your watch while watching the film?" question.
If you want an opinion... that one just seems unnecessary to me. Ugh:eek:... that was my question that I originally suggested...but I agree SC, it's not a good question.
Sean, on Cesar Chavez I used some of the original questions (reworded) and made up my own. I used only 5 (yes I can't count), still that took awhile to write.
Godoggo
11-09-14, 11:17 PM
I don't like the "Did you check your watch while watching the film?" question.
If you want an opinion... that one just seems unnecessary to me.
I'm not crazy about that question either. Like Cobpyth answered, I never do that. It's going to be the same answer every time. From both of us apparently.
I do like the script question though. It's a part of what goes into making a movie and sometimes a weak script hurts an otherwise good movie and sometimes a good script is wasted because the actors and director are incapable of living up to it.
Frightened Inmate No. 2
11-09-14, 11:18 PM
i have a tendency to check the time often whenever i watch a movie on my computer out of habit, so it has nothing to do with whether i'm bored by it. not sure how it is for everyone else.
The watch question is one of the ones that is going to get changed. I agree with you guys.
Citizen Rules
11-09-14, 11:20 PM
All right, all right....the watch idea was mine already. So was hugs or slugs for the directors, now a defunct question.
:cool:
Sean what do you think of the 5 questions I used in my last review here?
All right, all right....the watch idea was mine already. So was hugs or slugs for the directors, now a defunct question.
:cool:
I think the intention behind the questions is spot on. They just needed to be worded a little different.
Frightened Inmate No. 2
11-09-14, 11:23 PM
Were you waiting for the movie to end?
Cobpyth
11-09-14, 11:24 PM
The Elephant Man (1980)
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/2/27/TheElephantManposter.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
I bought it on DVD several weeks ago and I've been wanting to watch it for quite a long time as it's a well regarded film by David Lynch.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
I could relate to the title character, because the film made it very easy to feel empathic towards him. I probably will never know how it truly is to live in his condition, but I felt a great deal of compassion with him nevertheless.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Yes. Both The Elephant Man himself and Hopkin's character were good men.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
If The Elephant Man is the protagonist, I'll go with Hopkin's character, because he is pretty much the only other character the film spends a lot of time with.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Yes. Very much so.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Humane.
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
Yes! It's a beautiful score.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
The black and white cinematography fits the film very well. I don't think the film would've worked that well in color. It adds to the grim atmosphere.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
It's sentimental, but in a fittingly reserved way.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
"I am not an elephant! I am not an animal! I am a human being! I am a man!"
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
There were plenty of great scenes, but the scene where The Elephant man gets a nocturnal visit and gets humiliated in his room by a large crowd of people with the odd circus music as the music score is quite disturbing and therefore very effective.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Compassionate.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
No.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
I would've fleshed out Anne Bancroft's character a little bit more perhaps, but besides that, it was pretty much perfectly done, in my opinion.
Maybe it would also be interesting to watch an even more realistic depiction of The Elephant Man's life without all the fiction that was added to this movie's plot for dramatic and narrative reasons.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
Freaks (1932)
16. Did you check your watch while watching the film?
No.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be?
If I would ever have the possibility to ask David Lynch a question, it wouldn't be about this film, because I think I very much understood the artistic choices he made here.
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
Yes. I've seen 7 of Lynch's 10 films. I still have to see Dune, Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me and Inland Empire. I'm also planning on watching the TV series he directed and wrote, Twin Peaks!
19. Will you recommend this movie to a friend?
If someone is looking for this kind of film, I will definitely recommend it.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
4
All right, all right....the watch idea was mine already. So was hugs or slugs for the directors, now a defunct question.
:cool:
Sean what do you think of the 5 questions I used in my last review here?
I like the what would you tell people in place of the would you recommend. Godoggo sent some good ones to me as well. I will look at it closer tomorrow.
Sexy Celebrity
11-09-14, 11:25 PM
I do like the script question though. It's a part of what goes into making a movie and sometimes a weak script hurts an otherwise good movie and sometimes a good script is wasted because the actors and director are incapable of living up to it.
Well, when I first read that question while doing my 20 questions for Nightcrawler, it bothered me. I dunno, there's something snotty and elitist about it. I mean, imagine asking these questions to a casual movie watcher if they just exited the movie theater -- "So, did you like THE SCRIPT???" You'd get people thinking, WTH?
Something better might be --
"What did you like about the story? What didn't you like about the story?"
Or even --
"Do you think the movie was written well?"
Or --
"Did you like the way the story unfolded?"
That whole word -- SCRIPT -- just bugs me here.
@Cob, I just watched Elephant Man a month or so ago and had a lot of the same reactions. My favorite Lynch so far. I really like the B&W in this. If it wasn't for Hopkins presence, I would have thought I was watching something from the 40's probably.
Well, when I first read that question while doing my 20 questions for Nightcrawler, it bothered me. I dunno, there's something snotty and elitist about it. I mean, imagine asking these questions to a casual movie watcher if they just exited the movie theater -- "So, did you like THE SCRIPT???" You'd get people thinking, WTH?
Something better might be --
"What did you like about the story? What didn't you like about the story?"
Or even --
"Do you think the movie was written well?"
Or --
"Did you like the way the story unfolded?"
That whole word -- SCRIPT -- just bugs me here.
I could maybe reword it. I really like having something about the script though. I am a dialogue guy though, I really respond to good writing.
Sexy Celebrity
11-09-14, 11:32 PM
I could maybe reword it. I really like having something about the script though. I am a dialogue guy though, I really respond to good writing.
Yeah, well, to me good writing isn't just the dialogue.
Plus, you had a dialogue question -- "Were there any quotes from the movie that stand out to you?"
Sexy Celebrity
11-09-14, 11:33 PM
This thread is becoming the making of a thread. This thread is a Charlie Kaufman movie.
Citizen Rules
11-09-14, 11:37 PM
...
Something better might be --
"What did you like about the story? What didn't you like about the story?" I like that question, it's easy for everyone to relate to. And if I read someones answer it will help me to decide if the movie is something I should watch. But it could be written like this:
What did you like or dislike about the story?
Sexy Celebrity
11-09-14, 11:38 PM
I like that question, it's easy for everyone to relate to. And if I read someones answer it will help me to decide if the movie is something I should watch. But it could be written like this:
What did you like or dislike about the story?
Yeah, yeah, yeah, thank you.
Godoggo
11-09-14, 11:43 PM
I think the intention behind the questions is spot on. They just needed to be worded a little different.
I was just going to say that same thing. I took both questions too literal. Change did you check your watch to did you stay engaged during the whole movie and it's essentially the same question, but I'm not thinking literally about time.
I never think literally - it works against understanding movies and being funny. :)
Citizen Rules
11-09-14, 11:46 PM
Did you get bored during the film?.......how's that?
This thread is becoming the making of a thread. This thread is a Charlie Kaufman movie.
You make three posts saying script doesn't matter and then you bring up one of the greatest script writers of all time. I never know when you are trolling or not Sexy.;)
Citizen Rules
11-09-14, 11:53 PM
I think this thread is going good and I'm glad people who will be writing and reading the reviews are saying what they like/dislike.
I originally wrote this question:
16. Did you check your watch while watching the film?
So I can say that, Did you get bored during the film? is a better wording of it.
I'm out of here, good night:)
Sexy Celebrity
11-09-14, 11:56 PM
No, no, no -- scripts matter. Script questions in this thread, however -- if you want to be perfect about it -- are what we're dealing with here.
I think this is all becoming too neurotic, though. The original questions you posted were fine. Sure, there might be issues with them, but so what? You deal with it and live with it.
You coulda made "Interview Yourself About A Movie" where people have to come up with their own questions each time -- but probably nobody would do it, then. Just like nobody posts in my "Post to Yourself" thread. And, you didn't make "Interview Yourself About A Movie" anyway.
Frightened Inmate No. 2
11-10-14, 12:08 AM
don't reword the script question. the fact that Sexy is bothered by it means that it's a good question.
Sexy Celebrity
11-10-14, 12:15 AM
don't reword the script question. the fact that Sexy is bothered by it means that it's a good question.
If you're really an inmate, I hope it's almost your day for the electric chair.
Godoggo
11-10-14, 12:25 AM
I never think literally - it works against understanding movies and being funny. :)
It really does. I've tried to train my brain from being too literal, but my natural tendency is to think that way.
rauldc14
11-10-14, 12:30 AM
I think Elephant Man is my favorite Lynch. It's between that and Eraserhead, but I like Elephant Man a tad more.
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/d/db/American_Splendor_film.jpg/220px-American_Splendor_film.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
I remember loving it but have not returned to it in the more than ten years since its release.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
I don't completely relate to Harvey, but I can certainly relate to his world view at times.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Mostly no. Harvey would be a hard man to be around much.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
Joyce. Once she enters Harvey become challenged as a character a bit, which is great. They are also very funny playing off each other.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Most definitely. The evidence is on the screen with the breaking of the fourth wall as well.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Unique
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
Very, in the best way possible. The score is fantastic.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
The movie has a very unique style and look but not doing anything amazing in this department in the traditional sense.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
Very well written. The dialogue was fresh and fun.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
Ordinary life is pretty complex stuff.
It is said a couple times and sums up the movie pretty nicely.
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
Very tough. The phone conversation when Harvey convinces Joyce to move to Cleveland stands out. It is funny and a turning point in the story arc. Plus the very next moment she arrives and the movie has one of its funniest moments.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Despite the lead character, the movie is quite hopeful to me. I wonder if others feel that way about it.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
Not in the least
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
I wouldn't change a second.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
Sideways
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you?
I just love the tone and the characters. This movie isn't teaching me about life, but is an amazing slice of life.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be?
Did you ever question your decision to mix fictional narrative with documentary style?
I hope not. It is one of the things that makes this movie so unique and endearing.
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
No, it is a husband/wife combo. I have only even heard of one of their other films.
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years?
The very unique style. The equally unique characters.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
5
In case you have not noticed, I was thrilled to return to this movie. Going to be up there with my favorites.
Sexy Celebrity
11-10-14, 09:34 PM
I really liked American Splendor when I first saw it. I own it, but I haven't returned to it in years.
I really liked American Splendor when I first saw it. I own it, but I haven't returned to it in years.
I was the exact same. Do it, you won't be disappointed.
TheUsualSuspect
11-10-14, 11:22 PM
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/0/0d/Ten_to_midnight.jpg/220px-Ten_to_midnight.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
After getting the dvds in our new shelf, the wife and I decided to start going down the list, alphabetically. 10 to Midnight was #1.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
Surprisingly enough, the daughter. She had a sarcastic attitude that fits me pretty well.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Not really, he was a cardboard cutout detective and a terrible father.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
The killer. He seemed so well put together on the surface, but his insane phone calls show his true nature. I felt like he had the most diversity.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Not really, a lot of the acting was unintentionally funny.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Naked
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
The opening score had a classic 80's riff to it.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
Flat, yet very creatively careful to hide the male penis whenever the killer was naked.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
It's a generic detective crime thriller about catching a killer of women.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
"No we wont" BANG.
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
When the killer attacks the nurses, it was well staged and tense. Also the ending is very memorable.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Unintentional laughter for a lot of it. Appreciation for 80's films for the rest.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
Some of the expository dialogue will do that.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
Better acting, make it more natural and not so "ready"
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
Death Wish, Play Misty For Me, Black Christmas, American Psycho
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you?
The two memorable scenes had the strongest impact.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be?
Do you love having nudity in your films.
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
King Solomon's Mines...yup.
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years?
The killer always killed people naked.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
3
Citizen Rules
11-11-14, 03:58 PM
Chéri (2009)
http://mimg.sulekha.com/english/cheri/cheri_m.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
The cover looked interesting.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?She was a courtesan, a french high society prostitute, nothing in her character I could relate to.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why? None, except Kathy Bates who shined in her brief on screen time.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word: Chick Flick. I don't mean that deragorty either. I think women might like this film much better than most guys....Ladies have you seen this one???
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be? I would cast someone other than Michelle Pfeiffer, Frances Tomelty both were lack luster. Or perhaps the director failed at getting a good performance out of them.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale? 3 out of 5
Sexy Celebrity
11-15-14, 12:50 AM
Dumb and Dumber To
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
I had to see it! It's Dumb and Dumber To! I saw the first movie in a theater when it came out twenty years ago.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
I liked Fraida Felcher (Kathleen Turner). She's a big slut and she's played by Kathleen Turner, so she's a powerhouse of a slut.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Harry and Lloyd? I prefer Harry. Lloyd can be really irritating.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
I liked a lot of them... Fraida, Penny, Adele, the characters played by Rob Riggle, Billy in 4C, the old woman at the old folks' home.....
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Yes.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Boring.
Even though it's not completely boring, there is a tiredness running through the whole thing.
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
I don't remember a score. I do remember songs on the soundtrack and I thought it had a good soundtrack.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
Hmmm... it just reminded me of the first Dumb and Dumber movie.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
A great story with lame jokes. Some bad sections, a bad ending. Probably could have used a few more rewrites or just some more spontaneity.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
Not really quotable, but I remember when Harry first sees Fraida Felcher (Kathleen Turner). He thinks she's a man and he says, "Excuse me! Sir!" It made me laugh.
Also, the old woman in the old folks home -- "You can cross that one off your bucket list!" You've all heard it in the trailer, but it's actually a good one and that scene is a pretty good scene. Well, it's a pretty good scene for Dumb and Dumber To, at least.
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
I loved Harry interacting with the Stephen Hawking-like character at the KEN Conference. It's not really that much of a spectacular scene, but I love jokes aimed at Stephen Hawking like that. The movie's at its peak when they all get to that KEN Conference.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Frustrated.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
No. It's Dumb and Dumber To. If anything, my intelligence felt praised.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
Jim Carrey's Lloyd Christmas character should have stayed catatonic at that hospital. Jeff Daniels' Harry Dunne character could have pulled off the movie all by himself. This may look like a return to Jim Carrey's "old ways" but it is SO not a Jim Carrey movie. He is downright unnecessary in this. And he looks so old. I think the biggest problem with this movie is Jim Carrey brings nothing fresh and exciting to it. He is SO OVER and this will be the definitive proof. I say this as a fan of his, too. He just doesn't have it anymore.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
Just the first Dumb and Dumber movie.
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you?
The weirdness of it. The film gives me a dreary outlook on sequels to movies that are at least twenty years old now. Suddenly I'm not so keen on seeing a great Beetlejuice 2, something like that. People get OLD... and they look it. And it affects the film. Dumb and Dumber To looks like it should have taken place entirely in that old folks' home, instead of just featuring one scene there.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be?
Can I have my $12 back?
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
Yes. (this is a dumb question, I think, btw)
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years?
Probably Harry Dunne's butt. You see it a lot.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
2.5
Sexy, I can't decide whether I want to see this or not. Thanks for the review and 20 questions though. You are probably helping me make my decision.
Godoggo
11-15-14, 03:18 PM
All these mofos are seeing that movie at the theater and I bombed somebody with it. :( The ads for it make me angry. Jim Carrey looks like a [insert bad word here].
Off to do my twenty questions. :)
Sexy Celebrity
11-15-14, 03:26 PM
Sexy, I can't decide whether I want to see this or not. Thanks for the review and 20 questions though. You are probably helping me make my decision.
I'm working on your unconscious mind, messing with your future decision.
Frightened Inmate No. 2
11-15-14, 03:28 PM
doesn't really matter though because he has no free will.
Sexy Celebrity
11-15-14, 03:28 PM
All these mofos are seeing that movie at the theater and I bombed somebody with it. :(
Like a terrorist attack?
Godoggo
11-15-14, 04:23 PM
]20 Questions
Le Trou
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
It's a movie hall of fame nomination
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
Relate to personally? No. The movie does clearly have you empathizing with the characters plight and understanding their relationship to one another.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably? Yes, because of their solidarity and their bond.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why? I guess Claude. It's very hard to like him though and not see him through the eyes of the other men.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles? Oh, yeah.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word: tense
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie? It doesn't have one.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography? Simple. Lots of close ups.
9. What would you tell people about the script? It's stripped down and essential
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable? I don't remember exactly what is said but something about there is truth, but truth doesn't always matter.
11. What was your favorite scene and why? I think the scene where Roland first lifts up the floorboard and they start hammering at the cement. It is so tense, because you are sure they are going to get caught. However, it's the movie as a whole that has so much impact. It's not easily broken down into scenes.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel? Nervousness.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted? Absolutely not
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be? I don't really know. Again, I think it's a move that needs to be exactly as it is. I wouldn't want backstory on the other characters besides the one there is. The dialogue is exactly as needed as is the camera work.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching? Not really. Other prison movies crossed my mind.
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you? I kept thinking about what made Gaspard the way he is compared to the other men. What made it is nature to betray and to serve his own needs while one man could be trusted even though he would pay the cost to do so.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be? If you knew this would be your last film, would this still be the film you wanted to make.
18. Have you seen other films from this director? No
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years? The sounds of the digging and the prison. I will remember this as a movie about the different nature of men.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
4
Citizen Rules
11-15-14, 04:23 PM
http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/images/reviews/177/1223276803_2.jpg
Describe the tone of the film. Action, excitement but with some depth and intelligences. With a sub plot of a love triangle.
What if anything, did you notice about the cinematography, music score, sets or production? It was a color film from 1953, but not Technicolor. It was a rare Anscocolor film. A strange looking color process that left some colors looking muted and off. The colors shifted during some scenes or pulsated. But still watchable.
What would you tell people about the script? Better than most early 50s westerns, with some interesting commentary on human behavior. Worth watching.
What was your favorite scene and why? Unlike other movies of the time period, during the Mescalero Apache attack, they were shown to be intelligent in their methodology. In one scene the soldiers from the fort are trapped in a large rocky depression in the desert. The Apaches surround them on the high rocks, then send out riders to implant spears around the perimeter of the pit so the archers on the rock rim can site in and rein arrows down on their position.The attack was filmed in a menacing way and was the best part of the film.
What is you rating? rating_3
Godoggo
11-15-14, 04:26 PM
Like a terrorist attack?
Yep. I used negative reinforcement on all these people. I wouldn't turn the movie off until they gave me all the information and money I wanted. It didn't take long.
I'm working on your unconscious mind, messing with your future decision.
Well, me and my dad were just talking about the original, we are both big fans. I didn't think he would want to see this one but he does, so tomorrow afternoon I will most likely be seeing it.
Godoggo
11-15-14, 04:46 PM
Apparently one of the questions should be what is the name of the damn film you just watched. ;)
Citizen Rules
11-15-14, 04:54 PM
Who me?:cool:
Sexy Celebrity
11-15-14, 05:08 PM
Well, me and my dad were just talking about the original, we are both big fans. I didn't think he would want to see this one but he does, so tomorrow afternoon I will most likely be seeing it.
If you're a big fan of Dumb and Dumber, you NEED to see Dumb and Dumber To.
I love Dumb and Dumber, but I would not call myself a big fan of it. I watched it again last year and that was the first time I had seen it in years.
Dumb and Dumber To is a faithful sequel to the original movie. It's just not as good. It's like (and I thought of this while watching the thing) doing LSD or something and you have a weird Dumb and Dumber related trip. "Is this really happening?! Why are Harry and Lloyd older and driving a hearse? Why is Kathleen Turner in this? Is that a female idiot character??"
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/b/b4/Snowpiercer_poster.jpg/220px-Snowpiercer_poster.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
I have heard a lot of buzz over the past few months.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
Not really. Not that kind of movie.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Mostly. Not really enough character development to look upon anyone with much emotion.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
Really didn't have one, see above. This is despite all the raves I have heard about Swinton's character, who seemed like a Hunger Games rip off to me. Also one of my favorite actors shows up in the last third, and I still could have cared less.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
The acting was fine. In my opinion they just were not given anything of substance to work with.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Violent
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
Yeah, it was rather subdued, which is fine by me.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
The set pieces in the train all looked fine, although nothing made me go wow. Everything outside of the train looked horrendous. Very artificial looking.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
It is not existent. The dialogue is just a means of getting us to the brutality.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
Not in the least
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
If I have to choose one it would be the final scene in the engine room.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Indifference
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
Yeah, I think this movie wants you to believe in its themes of class warfare and climate change. Like I said with the dialogue those talking points just get you to the brutality. They are not explored with any kind of thoughtfulness.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
Cut out half the action sequences. Concentrate on some character and theme development. Okay, maybe that is more than one thing.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
Hunger Games
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you?
None
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be?
Do you feel like this movie is really making any sort of social commentary?
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
No
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years?
I probably won't remember anything tomorrow.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
1
The Gunslinger45
11-20-14, 07:48 PM
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/9/98/John_Wick_TeaserPoster.jpg
20 Questions
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
Heard good things From the folks about it. Also, Keanu in an action movie.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
Not really.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Yes and no. On one hand he is a contact killer, but on the other hand he left the biz, got married, his wife died, and the bastards killed his puppy!
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
The concierge at the Continental Hotel for his dry humor, and Willem DaFoe because Willem DaFoe is awesome.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Not really. They played them well, but not lost in it.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Violent
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
Not really. Focused more on the action.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
The camera was pulled back and not a lot of shaky cam. At least none that I noticed.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
Very linear and simple.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
John Leguizamo: The car belongs to John Wick.
Russian Mob Boss: Oh...
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
The scene where Keanu shoots up the night club.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Sad when they killed that cute little puppy! Also when the wife died.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
No. But it was not challenged either.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
The set up in the beginning.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
I thought that this is a lot better then the majority of the PG-13 "action" movies that usually come out now a days.
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you?
The ending of the film had an 80's feel to it. Car chases, shoot outs and finally a fist fight in the rain.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be?
What films influenced you while making this movie?
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
No. This is his director debut.
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years?
Keanu f***ing s*** up!
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
4
Godoggo
11-22-14, 10:51 PM
Pollock
20 Questions
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
I wanted to give it another try. I thought I may have been unjustly harsh the first time around.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
No.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
No
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
The border collie and the crow
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles? It's well acted
but it's acted, if that makes sense. I felt like
I could sense some of the choices they made so I would say no.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Dreary
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie? No. I don't think there was one.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography? It seemed a bit gray. Flat.
9. What would you tell people about the script? I think some of it was unnecessary. I think it may have been too focused on having people say profound things that felt very "art worldy" it didn't feel natural.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable? "I'm not a phony, you are. " said over and over
11. What was your favorite scene and why? When Pollock knocks over the Thanksgiving dinner table after yelling "No!" It was so overwrought that it was funny.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel? Empty
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted? Not insulted exactly. I did feel that it pulled some "this is a really important movie" tricks.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be? I think I would say this of a lot of biopic movies: if you're going to make a movie about a real person make him/her real. Don't just reduce the person to their reputation.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching? Basquiat, because it's about an artist, but that person felt real.
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you? That people can be so talented but it gives them no satisfaction.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be? Why Pollock?
What was it about him that made you need to tell the story of his life?
18. Have you seen other films from this director? No.
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years? I'll remember that it watching it felt gloomy without any pay off.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
2.5
I have always felt like I should see Pollock because I love Harris and unlike a lot of film buffs, I kind of have a thing for bio pics. I have always skipped it for some reason, your answers don't make me want to change that much.
Godoggo
11-22-14, 11:06 PM
Don't let that detour you. I've never liked the film, but it got good reviews and I know a lot of people that liked it. I just felt like I understood nothing about the characters and it frustrated me. There would be all this emotion onscreen and I didn't understand it.
My friend felt the exact opposite of me. I think it might be one of those movies that I feel differently than the majority on.
Citizen Rules
11-24-14, 03:26 PM
I just reviewed this movie on my review thread but thought that the 20 Questions would explain more of why I hated this film:mad:
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/0/07/Naked_Lunch_film_poster.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
I had seen and liked another of the director's movies.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
No! the main character was a drug addicted bug exterminator, lost in a hallucination.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Nope, he just wondered around the film in a drug induced state.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
I actually liked the talking alien-bug typewriter, that was the best part of the film as the typewriter serves as a narrator and Weller's subconscious.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Yes, Peter Weller is a top notch actor, he's pretty smart about the Roman Empire too.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word: Bizarre
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
No
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
It was superb, really looked great.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
Over the top. A good idea for a movie, but with no balance. Less is more.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
"Exterminate all rational thought. That is the conclusion I have come to."
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
When he was sort of bonding with his talking typewriter.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Unconformable at times.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
Yes, when the director chooses a close up of a alien-bug and then holds that shot for a long time and brightly lights it, so that the viewer can see the alien is a cheesy prop.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
Total script rewrite.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
Videodrome
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you?
The disturbing scenes, which had a negative impact.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be?
Are you on drugs?;)
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
Videodrome, The Fly
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years?
Never to rewatch it.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
rating_2
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/b/b8/Chef_2014.jpg/220px-Chef_2014.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
I am always interested in what Favreau has going on.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
I could relate somewhat to Favreau's chef. Not in the way he was so great at his job but in his kind of every man search for contentment.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Yes, he is flawed but in the ways most of us are, not tragically.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
There are some good ones but I liked his son. Watching that bond grow is the emotional core of the film.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
One of those movies where everyone is fine, no one stands out all that much.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Light
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
Yes, it fits the tone of the film well.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
Solid. I enjoyed the food porn. The food truck stands out as well.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
Solid writing. Felt mostly natural. People will remember the Twiiter mechanic.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
No
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
The second scene between Favreau and Hoffman that propels us into the heart of the film.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Hopeful and encouraged
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
I would have done something different with the ending, but I felt more manipulated than insulted.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
I would change the ending.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
Other Favreau movies.
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you?
Favreau's character working through how to better connect with his son.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be?
What was the logic behind the ending? It doesn't seem to fit the characters you spent the whole film developing.
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
I think most. He has some misses for sure but I love his intimate stuff like this. He is not an auteur, but I think the way he writes his own characters and the way he comes across in those films is great. He appeals to my sensibilities.
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years?
I will remember the light hearted nature and the father/son realtionship.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
3.5
Godoggo
11-27-14, 01:19 PM
@ Citizen. I don't like that movie and never understood why anyone would try to make adapt the novel into something visual.
I have a paperback copy of the book that is tattered and in horrible shape from several readings, but I've seen the movie once and will never revisit it.
http://i46.photobucket.com/albums/f145/ifiswan/8ff9bd9f-6819-4ccb-9550-74e6875cd9b8_zps77115bb5.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
I've been making my own music lately and recently started taking piano lessons, so there is a bit of relatability in the story for me.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
Definitely the main character, Andrew. Both of us are young musicians (though he is far more skilled than I am) and highly ambitious, and there are small things that were similar between us as well, such as the fact that he still sees movies with his dad.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
For sure. He's a flawed character no doubt, but he has ambition which is something I can definitely relate to, and overall I feel he was a good person.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
Fletcher. He was the villain of the film and actually, he pissed me off a few times but man was he a joy to watch. Absolutely fascinating character.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Oh man. This is THE movie where actors get lost in their roles.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Rhythm
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
Yes. In fact, it inspires me to seek out more jazz music. I need to get a Buddy Rich album.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
Very good, though it won't win any awards. I liked it because it often complimented the film without being show-offy in a "oh look, here's a pretty shot" way.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
It's incredibly, incredibly intense. Full of humor, full of great lines.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
"There are no two words in the English language more harmful than good job." You don't have to agree with it to recognize that as a great line.
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
The final scene. There is no question.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Drive. Ambition. Inspiration. Felt sorry for Andrew more than a few times.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
No, this isn't that kind of movie.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
I can't really think of anything I would change. It's a very solid movie.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
For some reason, I thought of The Social Network. Another movie about young people with incredible ambition.
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you?
Just the relatability of the main character for me. It's pretty inspiring.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be?
What is the moral of the story? In other words, how do you perceive Fletcher as a teacher?
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
This was his debut film.
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years?
Fletcher and the final scene.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
4+
Thanks for sharing Swan. I told you the other night I was on the fence about this one. I will add it to the watch list.
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/4/41/TOIL_poster.jpg/220px-TOIL_poster.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
Heard about it on a couple of casts. Plus I like Moss quite a bit from Mad Men.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
I related to Duplass's character. He is a middle class married man dealing with some typical problems.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
There are basically two characters in this movie. They both have their moments, which is kind of the whole point.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
They were believable. I don't think always natural, but believable.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Bizarre
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
Mostly in a good way. Reminded me of Punch Drunk Love at times.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
Really only two set pieces and they were fine. They try to show off the land scapes a bit while they are in the car which looked good.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
Functional, not at all memorable.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
None
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
The dinner party which basically propels us to the third act.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Bewildered
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
No. This may seem odd if you have seen the film, but it is relatable in many ways.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
A more clear purpose to the unnatural elements.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
Only Punch Drunk because of the score.
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you?
The marriage struggle.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be?
Why did you choose to leave the unnatural elements so ambiguous.
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
This is a debut film.
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years?
The bizarre nature of the narrative won't be forgotten even if I didn't always love it.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
2.5
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/a/a3/Birdman_poster.jpg/220px-Birdman_poster.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
One of the most talked about movies of the year thus far.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
Lots of great characters, but none relatable on a real level.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Mostly no, but Inarritu does a good job of humanizing enough that you don't loathe him.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
Norton's Mike. A character you love to hate. Really great performance.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Every single one. Best acted movie of the year by a long shot.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Dour
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
Tremendous score. Jazz drum. Never heard anything quite like it. Fit the tone perfectly.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
The appearance of one long take has been much talked about but really can't be talked about enough. If this doesn't win a cinematography award there is something wrong. I wasn't surprised to find out it was the same DP as on Gravity.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
Tremendous. My favorite of the year so far.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
A thing is a thing, not what is said of that thing.
Actually a quote on the dressing room mirror but I have heard it a couple times on interviews and I really like it.
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
There are a whole lot of really good scenes in this movie. Keaton confronting the critic is the pinnacle though.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Immersed. Is that an emotion? This film just engrossed me. Its not a world I want to live in, but it is one I want to visit, probably frequently.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
Maybe the final scene. I haven't decided yet. Stay tuned to MoFo for more after a revisit.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
The finale is definitely the most problematic aspect for me.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
Venus In Fur. Another movie this year that I loved. Similar claustrophobic atmosphere centering around a stage play. Both movies have tremendous scripts.
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you?
Keaton's performance is one of those once in a lifetime ones. I would put it up there with some of the great ones.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be?
Did you prefer the ending that it seems like everyone else preferred?
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
Biutiful (Liked it a lot), Babel (disliked it), Amores Perros will be seen soon.
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years?
The performances and technique. Hopefully I will be watching it for the third or fourth time. It feels like one of those for me.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
4
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/2/21/ThirdManUSPoster.jpg/220px-ThirdManUSPoster.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
Saw someone mention it here a couple weeks ago, blanking on who.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
I am reluctant to answer honestly but Anna. Because she seems in a daze the whole film. Like everything going on around her is incomprehensible. I feel this is how I would probably react.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Most certainly. He is forward and capable but not as cock-sure as you normally find in Noir. I also love how he struggles with what is the right thing to do at times. I am becoming a Cotten fan.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
Hard not to love Harry Lime when he shows up. Even though he isn't in a lot of the film, he still hangs over everything that is transpiring. Really great character.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Yes. Very good acting throughout.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Ominous
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
Yes, but unlike a lot of classics for me in a good way. Really cool score.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
The dutch angles stand out. Not sure if I would love it showing up everywhere but it works wonderfully here.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
Really solid. Not a poor scene that I can think of.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
Nothing coming to mind unfortunately.
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
Martins and Lime on the ferris wheel. Lots of good stuff but this is the stand out.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Satisfied. There is nothing quite like a good classic.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
Not at all. There are certainly things that could have come off hokey but nothing ever does. The twists and turn and romance is handled deftly.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
Not a thing.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
Double Indemnity. I am getting to the point where I just want to consume as much Noir as possible. Why did I put off watching these movies for so long.
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you?
The cinematography, the score, Cotten, Welles. You choose, I don't want to.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be?
Did you have any alternate endings in mind or was this plan A, B, and C?
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
Not yet, Recommendations anyone?
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years?
See question 16.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
4.5
I'd recommend The Fallen Idol, Outcast of the Islands, Odd Man Out and Our Man in Havana first, but my fave would be The Fallen Idol about a love affair and an accidental death as seen through the eyes of a child who doesn't understand what he's seeing and how he can help the man he loves - I mean, does he lie or tell the truth, and do adults even pay attention to what children say most of the time? All these films have lots of cool Dutch angles to highlight the characters' (here the child's) disorientation.
Godoggo
12-13-14, 12:03 AM
So glad you liked The Third Man, Seanc. It's a fantastic movie.
I recently bought the script for that movie, Sean. It's been a long long time since I watched the movie so I figured I could read it with fairly fresh eyes.
I recently bought the script for that movie, Sean. It's been a long long time since I watched the movie so I figured I could read it with fairly fresh eyes.
Very cool. Do you have a lot of scripts?
rauldc14
12-13-14, 04:14 PM
There Will Be Blood
20 Questions
http://www.independent.co.uk/incoming/article9187551.ece/binary/original/there%20will%20be%20blood.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
A lot of recommendations, (namely SeanC and the whole PTA fanclub. It's a film I've been trying to get to for sometime and I was waiting for the right mood for it. It won the last MOFO movie tournament and placed very highly on the millennium countdown.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
Couldn't relate to any of the characters actually
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Well, no actually. There were times that I did though, but obviously not as a whole.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
The protagonist was my favorite, but Eli would probably come in second.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Absolutely. Simply a stunning performance by Daniel Day-Lewis and my favorite from him easily. He totally became his character Plainview
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word: Powerful
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
Yes, and I thought it was quite good.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
It was certainly stunning. Lots of great landscape shots.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
I thought the script was overall pretty well done. Not truly perfect but it was still good. The acting made up for some of the lulls in the script usually.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
I am a false prophet. God is a superstition.
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
This is a tough call. I'll go with the moment when Daniel and an older H.W. Meet to talk. I thought that scene was really well done.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Greed can get the worst out of people.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
No, not really.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
I'm on the fence with portions of the ending. It was an entertaining ending, but I wonder if it could have ended a little differently.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching? No, but that's a good thing. This certainly didn't remind me of any other PTA film, which I was worried about.
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you? Day Lewis' performance. I think it has a real chance to stick as a favorite of mine.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be? Why can't you make a film like this all of the time? :p
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
Yes. The Master and Punch Drunk Love, both of which I sincerely dislike. I've also seen Magnolia which was my favorite before this one, but I wouldn't call it a masterpiece.
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years? Again, Day-Lewis' phenomenal performance.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
4, with room to grow.
Very cool. Do you have a lot of scripts?
19 script books total, but some of them have more than one script in them. My Coen brothers book has four of their scripts, for example.
19 script books total, but some of them have more than one script in them. My Coen brothers book has four of their scripts, for example.
That might be a cool think to collect. You got me thinking.
So glad you had a positive experience with There Will Be Blood Rauldc. I was pretty worried you would hate it. I think all PTA stuff is pretty unique but if I had to pick one that it was like it would be The Master. That is due to it being performance driven, and the narrative arc being less than straight forward. Plus the score really drives the mood and tone, but that is what I would consider a hallmark of all PTA.
Surprised to hear how you feel about the ending. It is one of my favorites ever. So intense and engaging. In addition to the milkshake line, I just love the last line of the film. Great stuff. Glad you enjoyed it.
rauldc14
12-13-14, 08:32 PM
I also forgot to state how insanely cool it was in There Will Be Blood that my hometown was called out in the movie. Considering how small it is, that was ironically amazing.
I also forgot to state how insanely cool it was in There Will Be Blood that my hometown was called out in the movie. Considering how small it is, that was ironically amazing.
That's cool, whats the town? I remember either CSI or Criminal Minds had an episode in my hometown of Lockport, NY. Nothing in the rest of the episode reminded me of the town at all. It was still cool though, just because no one has ever heard of that place.
rauldc14
12-13-14, 08:38 PM
That's cool, whats the town? I remember either CSI or Criminal Minds had an episode in my hometown of Lockport, NY. Nothing in the rest of the episode reminded me of the town at all. It was still cool though, just because no one has ever heard of that place.
Fond du Lac, Wisconsin. It was cool because it wasn't mentioned just once, was mentioned at least 3 times.
The Sci-Fi Slob
12-19-14, 08:33 AM
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/b/b4/Snowpiercer_poster.jpg/220px-Snowpiercer_poster.jpg
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
rating_1
A typo surely..;)
A typo surely..;)
Agreed, I enjoyed Snowpiercer and thought it was a good film despite its flaws and the cockroach protein bars. But the movie is the ultimate hate-or-love film of the year, so I respect seanc's opinion even though I strongly disagree. :D
A typo surely..;)
In fairness, if I had known it was all action set pieces I would have stayed away. I like a little action with my characters not vice-versa. Just not my jam.
Citizen Rules
12-22-14, 05:42 PM
http://c3.cduniverse.ws/resized/250x500/movie/296/8995296.jpg
Alone for Christmas (2013)
1. What compelled you to watch this movie? My wife and Christmas time:)
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how? Nope, the characters were talking dogs and goofy burglars.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably? The dog was kinda of cute.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why? Kevin Sorbo...aka Hercules, he was the most fleshed out character in the film, funny too.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles? Kevin Sorbo did.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word: Silly
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie? No
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography? No
9. What would you tell people about the script? What script;)
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable? Yes 'Find your bite'
11. What was your favorite scene and why? Closing credits.;)
12. What emotion did the film make you feel? Bored
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted? A big yes!
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be? Rewrite the script.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
Home Alone.
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you? The goofy guy falling face first into a barbecue made me cringe.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be? Is that your real name on the credits.;)
18. Have you seen other films from this director? ???
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years? I won't remember 5 days from now.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale? rating_2 and that's generous.
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/a/ab/Ida_%282013_film%29.jpg/220px-Ida_%282013_film%29.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
Have heard it mentioned on a couple of podcasts lately.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
Didn't relate to anyone.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Yeah, her journey was very sympathetic.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
The aunt. She had the potential to be fun, but fell a bit flat.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
They were quite good and believable.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Somber
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
There was no score. Music was used in a few scenes and was pretty effective.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
The static B&W cinematography was absolutely gorgeous and the highlight of the movie for me.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
Minimalist to say the least.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
None
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
A scene where Ida removes her habit and works with her hair. May sound boring but pretty good and poignant within the context of the film.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
A little intrigued, a little bored.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
Not at all.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
I need more character in my characters. I am sure many will love the minimalist approach though.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
[i]White Ribbon[/b] because of the cinematography.
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you?
Ira's journey is intriguing, I just wish I shared her emotion.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be?
I don't have any. This movie is technically sound and exactly as it should be.
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
No
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years?
The cinematography.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
2.5
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/c/cb/A_Man_for_All_Seasons_%281966_movie_poster%29.gif/220px-A_Man_for_All_Seasons_%281966_movie_poster%29.gif
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
More 60's viewing
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
I would love to say I can relate to Thomas More, I will have to settle for I wish I related to Thomas More.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Most definitely. He is a picture of conscience that I think most anyone would hope to live up to.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
There are a lot of great ones but I think I like the Duke of Norfolk the best. He seems to be the character with the most conflict over what is transpiring.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
The acting is top notch across the board. I was left wondering why I have never heard of Scofield before.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Pious
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
Not at all. I can't remember if there was one.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
Very good at times. Many of the scenes are very contained though.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
Perfect. The words are everything, and they are wonderful.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
"This isn't Spain, it is England." Used twice, the second time to great effect.
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
Tons to choose from. I pick the first scene between More and King Henry. Sets the tone going forward and Shaw is doing great work. It was very hard to not choose the scene with Orson Welles.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Pity and bewilderment.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
No, I felt my intelligence being dwarfed in the best way possible. Like reading C.S. Lewis
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
I think I would make it longer. I would have liked to see a couple of the relationships fleshed out.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
A couple of other 60's period films I have watched fairly recently. Becket and A Lion In Winter.
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you?
Mores's scruples.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be?
Was anyone besides Scofield considered for the lead.
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
High Noon but I already see a couple more are in my Netflix que for 60's viewing.
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years?
The script. I was not surprised to see this was based off a play. I find that out about a lot of movies that I respond very positively to.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
5
This was an absolute pleasure to watch. Yet another 60's film that I wonder where it has been my whole life. I have discovered so many new favorites this year.
rauldc14
01-12-15, 08:52 PM
I'll do a 20 questions after my Guardians commentary
Godoggo
01-12-15, 10:21 PM
20 Questions
Dawn of the Planet of the Apes
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
I loved the first one so naturally I wanted to see the sequel.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
Hmm. I answer this question the same way almost every time, but it still fits here. I find the characters relatable, but not in a personal way.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably? Yes. Very much so.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why? Maurice. I would imagine that Maurice is a favorite of many people. He's thoughtful, curious, gentle and intelligent. Also his wonderful Orangutan face.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles? I'd say Andy Serkis did. Other than him the acting is what you expect in an action film.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word: Exciting
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie? Not enough to remember it
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography? Again pretty typical action movie cinematography
9. What would you tell people about the script? It's better than average for a standard action film.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable? Koba: Caesar weak!
Caesar: Koba weaker.
11. What was your favorite scene and why? When Maurice looks up at the humans and says, "Run!" It's a cool scene. Maurice doesn't normally speak so that makes it all the much more exciting and then his voice is like gravel. It's a good scene.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel? Excited, anxious
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted? No. It's not a super smart movie, but it's not dumb.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
I think I may have let Koba win so there could be a sequel where the two factions of Apes go to war. It seems like that would be a natural progression to the story.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching? The first one
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you? Koba's rage and anger and how destructive revenge in the name of justice is.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be? How much, if any, time did he spend studying ape behavior.
18. Have you seen other films from this director? Yes. Cloverfield & Let Me In
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years? That it was exciting and Maurice is an awesome character.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
4
Did you like it better than Rise Godog?
Godoggo
01-12-15, 10:33 PM
Did you like it better than Rise Godog?
No. I liked Rise better but not by leaps and bounds. I kept hearing people say that this was nowhere as good, but I disagree. I think it was a worthy sequel and I can't wait for the next one.
No. I liked Rise better but not by leaps and bounds. I kept hearing people say that this was nowhere as good, but I disagree. I think it was a worthy sequel and I can't wait for the next one.
I am one of those people you disagree with but it was in no way a deal breaker for me. I will check out the next one for sure. I have a tendency to love the origin stories anyway, so I wasn't really surprised I felt that way. BTW I completely concur on Maurice, I loved him in the first one as well.
Godoggo
01-12-15, 10:44 PM
I am one of those people you disagree with but it was in no way a deal breaker for me. I will check out the next one for sure. I have a tendency to love the origin stories anyway, so I wasn't really surprised I felt that way. BTW I completely concur on Maurice, I loved him in the first one as well.
Oh, I haven't found anyone that agrees with me yet. ;) I do think Rise was better in quite a few ways, but I don't think it completely eclipses the second one. Do you mind if I ask what you didn't like about it?
I think sometimes sequels suffer from expectation. It felt like Rise surprised some people (it did me) at how much I liked it which always gives credit to the movie that really has nothing to do with it's content. It's just impossible for a sequel to have that element. I felt that way about How To Train Your Dragon 2 as well.
Oh, I haven't found anyone that agrees with me yet. ;) I do think Rise was better in quite a few ways, but I don't think it completely eclipses the second one. Do you mind if I ask what you didn't like about it?
Expectations could have a lot to do with it. Mostly I felt it was much more action oriented. When you move from character beats to action beats you are probably going to start to lose me. I liked a lot of the stuff when it was just the apes but the human stuff didn't do anything for me at all, and I even found a couple of them rather annoying. Especially the guy who was sabotaging everything. Hope you know who I am talking about, I am a few months removed. That is just the total opposite of Rise for me, where I really liked the human characters as well as the apes.
Godoggo
01-12-15, 11:00 PM
Gotcha. I understand your feelings because normally I am not big on action films, which is probably why this one got four popcorns from me. It would be hard for me to list twenty action films that I really liked.
I also agree that the humans were either annoying or dull. It would have been nicer to have a stronger Malcom so that the friendship between him and Caesar had more impact.
One credit I have to give it as that many times in action films I completely lose the characters. By that I mean I can't tell who is doing what and I get confused as to who is who. It lessons the impact of someone in peril when you're not sure who they are. In Apes that didn't happen and I knew exactly what ape was what.
rauldc14
01-12-15, 11:24 PM
20 Questions
Birdman
1. What compelled you to watch this movie? Highly acclaimed, love 21 Grams and Watts, plus I need to see more 2014.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how? Not really.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably? I guess in a way. But I didn't have too much of an attachment to Keaton's character.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why? I enjoyed the role of Sam played by Emma Stone. I also liked Galifanakis' role.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles? I thought the acting was pretty solid all around, for what was given to work with.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word: different? I felt at times the performances were limited due to the story.
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie? Yes, that was fine for me.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography? Pretty average, but I may not have had the best video quality, either.
9. What would you tell people about the script? I thought it potentially limited the performances from being greater. I could be wrong, but that's how I feel.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable? No, actually.
11. What was your favorite scene and why? The ending scene. I thought it ended well.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel? That's the thing, it really didn't make me feel anything. I was a little underwhelmed, but I had huge expectations.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted? No
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be? A stronger story and maybe a tad more drama.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching? Not really
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you? Still, the performances. Although I don't think Keaton's was as astounding as it's made out to be.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be? Would he have changed anything?
18. Have you seen other films from this director? 21 Grams, which is absolutely astounding.
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years? I hope it grows on me, but time will tell.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale? 3.5-
Bummer you didn't like it more Raul. Solid rating though. I really loved the script. If I had to guess that is probably the reason our experiences were so different. You didn't enjoy the one take approach?
rauldc14
01-12-15, 11:38 PM
I cant exactly pinpoint what bothered me about the script and the story. It just......didn't thrill me in a way. I was expecting a hell of a movie, and instead I got something that was far less than what I expected. I shouldn't have had Gravity/American Hustle like expectations for this.
I think I feel with this film kind of how you felt about Gone Girl. I've been thinking a lot about Gone Girl lately and I think it will become stronger with time. With Birdman, I just don't see it.
Godoggo
01-15-15, 04:06 PM
20 Questions
How To Train Your Dragon 2
warning: My answers are usually very spoilery. Don't read if you haven't seen.
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
Loved the first one and it was supposed to be something cute and fun to cheer me up, but I ended up bawling my eyes out.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
Hiccup. He's an oddball that relates to dragons (dogs ;) a little better than he does people
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably? Yes, until I cussed him out for not caring enough for what happens to Stoic, but that was me projecting and had nothing to do with the film.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why? Toothless, of course. He's just so darned cute.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles? It's voice acted pretty well. That Game of Thrones guy did better than I thought he would in an animated feature.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word: fantastical
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie? No
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography? I really like that style of animation and it's filmed well
9. What would you tell people about the script? Not good as the first, but a worthy sequel. It obviously sets up a third film.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable? Stoick the Vast: A man who kills without reason cannot be reasoned with.
11. What was your favorite scene and why? Where Hiccup's mom (unbeknownst to him at the time) flys up next to him. She looked really cool and it was a kind of spooky scene.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel? Happy and having fun until the Stoic thing and then I had a meltdown.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted? No.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be? I'd take out the Ruffnut character. Normally I really like Kristen Wiig, but I can't stand that character.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching? The first one
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you? Stoic's death, but that has more to do with me right now.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be? What made him use dragons as his misunderstood creatures?
18. Have you seen other films from this director? All of them except Helma.
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years? The Hiccup/ Toothless friendship
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
3.5
Godog, remind me who Stoic is?
Daniel M
01-15-15, 05:41 PM
Strange to see how you felt that the Birdman script perhaps limited the performances. I thought it was the opposite, everyone's role seem perfectly written, and no star actors were overused for the sake of it, Naomi Watts and Zach Galifinakis were hardly in the film. I absolutely loved Edward Norton and Michael Keaton.
I am with you Daniel. One of the best scripts of the year. I liked the writing better than Inherent Vice, and that is saying something for me.
Godoggo
01-15-15, 06:14 PM
Godog, remind me who Stoic is?
Hiccup's dad. The one that died
Hiccup's dad. The one that died
Gotcha. I really liked the dragon movies. Surprisingly my kids don't seem to or I would have seen them 100 times by now. That is my gauge for them as they have never seen a movie and not loved it.:)
Miss Vicky
01-15-15, 06:26 PM
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be? What made him use dragons as his misunderstood creatures?
Not sure if you're aware, Amy, but the How to Train Your Dragon movies are based on a book series (http://www.amazon.com/How-Train-Your-Dragon-Paperback/dp/0316373680/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1421360722&sr=8-1&keywords=how+to+train+your+dragon+books).
Godoggo
01-15-15, 06:29 PM
I really like them too. I struggled between giving 2 a 4 or 3.5. The only reason I gave it a half star less is that I do think some of it was there to set up the next one. Which would be fine, but the events that occur to pave away for the next storyline need to exist for more than just that purpose. Even though I was too emotional when watching it and I really don't think Hiccup is an *******, I do feel the part about Stoic wasn't given nearly the attention it deserved. The relationship between he and Hiccup was an extremely important part of the first movie.
Godoggo
01-15-15, 06:30 PM
Not sure if you're aware, Amy, but the How to Train Your Dragon movies are based on a book series (http://www.amazon.com/How-Train-Your-Dragon-Paperback/dp/0316373680/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1421360722&sr=8-1&keywords=how+to+train+your+dragon+books).
No, I had no idea. I'll have to read those. Have you read them?
Miss Vicky
01-15-15, 06:33 PM
I haven't but I might give them a try. I don't usually do much reading.
Yeah I really like Stoic, now that I remember who he is.:D The movie looked great and I enjoyed but I did get a little sequelitis. Like you said everything sets up the next one, they gave away the mother story in the trailer. I have to remind myself its for kids and its a franchise. I responded much more to Lego movie this year.
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/a/ae/Foxcatcher_First_Teaser_Poster.jpg/220px-Foxcatcher_First_Teaser_Poster.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
One of my anticipated this year after all the Carell buzz.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
Not in particular. These guys are not in my social circle.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
At times. He is a broken man and prone to some uncomfortable character moments. He is sympathetic though.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
Dave Schultz (Ruffalo). He is a very engaging character and the bright spot in a bleak film.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Really great acting. Carell and Ruffalo are as good as advertised. Tatum doesn't have as much to do but is pretty good.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Bleak
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
Yes, it is used very sparingly which makes it even more effective when it shows up.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
There are some really effective shots. It is not amazing but very good.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
This film is certainly not about the talking but when characters do, you want to know what they are saying. The story is told more through body language than words.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
"My friends call me Eagle, or Golden Eagle."
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
There are quite a few really good scenes, so it is hard to choose. I think Tatum losing it in the hotel room gets my vote though.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Melancholy
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
No, it is intellectually stimulating.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
I really like the tone but a little less filling in the blanks would have worked for me. Whether that means making it longer or more talky.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
No, this movie put me in the zone, I wasn't thinking of anything else. Even now nothing comes to mind.
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you?
The brokenness of Mark Schultz and Dupont.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be?
When putting this story together did you feel Mark and John had similar insecurities?
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
I have seen Capote and Moneyball. I love the latter and respect the former. Foxcatcher is probably better than both.
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years?
The three central characters and the strained relationships. The ending will not be easily forgotten either.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
4
Daniel M
01-17-15, 08:13 PM
I thought it was great too. Question: Keaton or Carell?
I thought it was great too. Question: Keaton or Carell?
I think I am still team Keaton but I need to sit with it a day or two. I am partial to more dialogue driven movies so I am sure that plays a part with me.
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/0/01/Whiplash_poster.jpg/220px-Whiplash_poster.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
All the chatter. Wasn't on my radar till Swan's glowing recommendation.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
Probably the girlfriend with no drive or direction.:(
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Mostly. He had some moments of being an ass, but he was mostly someone who was striving to be the best.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
Fletcher (Simmons). He is just electric in every scene. A powder keg in every sense.
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Certainly, Simmons performance is rightly being called one of the best of the year. Teller is the best I have ever seen him. It was fun to see Reiser, even though he isn't given much to do, I have always liked him.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Intense
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
No, I am not sure there was one. The music was constant though, and it was fantastic.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
Tight. We are not given any wide shots I can think of. It matches the tone perfectly. It is a pressure cooker.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
Very good. Even though Simmon's actions may not always be believable, his character is, if that makes sense. Also, as intense as the movie is, the dialogue can also be quite humorous. Really a perfect blend and a big reason why this movie is so effective.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
There are no two words in the English language more harmful than good job.
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
The last scene of the film. It is as intense as the rest of the film. It is almost like the movie replayed again in a 10-15 minute scene. Phenomenal. My favorite scene of the year.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Excited
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
No. This is a hard question sometimes. I do think you have to suspend your disbelief at times in this film. I don't think this is the same thing as having your intelligence insulted though.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
I can't imagine changing a thing.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
No, I was engrossed form start to finish. I didn't think much, I love that.
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you?
Simmons performance and that ending tied. Sorry if that's a cheat, but I don't care.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be?
Is Simmons character patterned after a real life person?
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
This is his debut. Makes me kind of want to see Grand Piano because he wrote it though.
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years?
Simmons and the ending. Have I mentioned those? I think I will still be watching it. This will be an easy movie to pop in yearly.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
4
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/8/89/Force_Majeure_poster.jpg/220px-Force_Majeure_poster.jpg
1. What compelled you to watch this movie?
One of the better received movies of last year.
2. Was there a character in the movie you could relate to and how?
All were sympathetic but I didn't really relate.
3. Did you look upon the protagonist favorably?
Mostly, I felt pretty bad for the guy. I understand why what he did left such an impression on his wife but I still felt bad for him.
4. Besides the protagonist, who was your favorite character and why?
The main characters red headed, bearded friend that comes in about half way through. I had a lot of sympathy for that character
5. Did the actors get lost in their roles?
Pretty much. Well acted but nothing that will set cinema on fire either.
6. Describe the tone of the film in one word:
Realistic
7. Were you aware of the musical score during the movie?
Very, I didn't care for it. Maybe in a Wes Anderson film.
8. What, if anything, did you notice about the cinematography?
Excellent. The setting of the ski resort was beautiful inside and out.
9. What would you tell people about the script?
Good, very realistic.
10. Is there a line that stands out as quotable?
Nothing comes to mind.
11. What was your favorite scene and why?
The avalanche scene. Even knowing it was coming it was still intense.
12. What emotion did the film make you feel?
Some melancholy, some aggravated.
13. At any time did you feel your intelligence being insulted?
No, although I did feel like the ending betrayed the point of view set-up in the rest of the film.
14. If you could change one thing to make the movie better, what would that be?
I didn't like how the wife seemed most willing to communicate her feeling in front of others instead of her husband. The dialogue irritated me at times.
15. Did you think of other movies while watching?
Carnage a bit
16. What about the movie had the strongest impact on you?
The setting itself. Made me want to go to a ski resort.
17. If you could ask the director one question, what would it be?
How do you square your ending with the premise set-up during the rest of the film.
18. Have you seen other films from this director?
No, looked them up and have never even heard of any of them.
19. What if anything will you remember about the movie in five years?
I think the premise is interesting and will stick with me.
20. What is you rating on a five star scale?
2.5
vBulletin® v3.8.0, Copyright ©2000-2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.