Rd 1 Eastwood, Coppola, Wells, and Fincher best film

[donniedarko]

Also vote in Rd.1 Stone, Spielberg, Arnofsky, and Nolan best film:
http://www.movieforums.com/community/showthread.php?t=28594

This will be up until June 22nd

Clint Eastwood
Play Misty For Me vs J. Edgar
Gran Torino vs Letter from Iwa Jima
Million Dollar baby vs Unforgiven
Mystic River vs The Rookie

Coppola
The Godfather vs The Rain maker
The Godfather Part II vs The Converstion
The Godfather Part III vs Appocalypse Now
The Outsiders vs Rumble Fish

Wells
Citizen Kane vs F for Fake
Touch of Evil vs The Stranger
The Trial vs the lady from shanghai
Chimes of Midnight vs Mr.Akradin

Fincher
Curious Case of Benjiman Button vs Girl With The Dragon Tattoo
Fight Club vs Panic Room
The Social Network vs Zodiac
Seven vs The Game

[gandalf26]

Clint Eastwood
Play Misty For Me vs J. Edgar
Gran Torino vs Letter from Iwa Jima
Million Dollar baby vs Unforgiven
Mystic River vs The Rookie

Coppola
The Godfather vs The Rain maker
The Godfather Part II vs The Converstion
The Godfather Part III vs Appocalypse Now
The Outsiders vs Rumble Fish

Wells
Citizen Kane vs F for Fake
Touch of Evil vs The Stranger ( Didnt see)
The Trial vs the lady from shanghai (Didnt see)
Chimes of Midnight vs Mr.Akradin (didnt see)

Fincher
Curious Case of Benjiman Button vs Girl With The Dragon Tattoo
Fight Club vs Panic Room
The Social Network vs Zodiac
Seven vs The Game

[wintertriangles]

Clint Eastwood
Play Misty For Me vs J. Edgar
Gran Torino vs Letter from Iwa Jima
Million Dollar baby vs Unforgiven
Mystic River vs The Rookie

Coppola
The Godfather vs The Rain maker
The Godfather Part II vs The Converstion
The Godfather Part III vs Appocalypse Now
The Outsiders vs Rumble Fish

Wells
Citizen Kane vs F for Fake
Touch of Evil vs The Stranger
The Trial vs the lady from shanghai
Chimes of Midnight vs Mr.Akradin

Fincher
Curious Case of Benjiman Button vs Girl With The Dragon Tattoo
Fight Club vs Panic Room
The Social Network vs Zodiac
Seven vs The Game

[The Rodent]

Clint Eastwood
Play Misty For Me vs J. Edgar
Gran Torino vs Letter from Iwa Jima
Million Dollar baby vs Unforgiven
Mystic River vs The Rookie

Coppola
The Godfather vs The Rain maker
The Godfather Part II vs The Converstion
The Godfather Part III vs Appocalypse Now
The Outsiders vs Rumble Fish

Wells
Citizen Kane vs F for Fake
Touch of Evil vs The Stranger
The Trial vs the lady from shanghai
Chimes of Midnight vs Mr.Akradin

Fincher
Curious Case of Benjiman Button vs Girl With The Dragon Tattoo
Fight Club vs Panic Room
The Social Network vs Zodiac
Seven vs The Game



Wow, tough choices with Se7en Vs The Game and Million Dollar Baby Vs Unforgiven.

[Gabrielle947]

Coppola
The Godfather vs The Rain maker
The Godfather Part III vs Apocalypse Now

Fincher
Fight Club vs Panic Room
The Social Network vs Zodiac
Seven vs The Game[/QUOTE]

[HitchFan97]

Play Misty For Me vs J. Edgar

Props to you for including Play Misty For Me. I absolutely love that film, such an underrated gem.

The Godfather Part II vs The Conversation

This isn't even close. The Godfather Part II is the best sequel ever made, and The Conversation is an overrated bore.

The Godfather Part III vs Apocalypse Now

I actually love both of these two, but Apocalypse Now wins.

The Social Network vs Zodiac

My two favorite Fincher films (though I haven't seen Se7en, so maybe I can't comment). Gotta go with Zodiac here though.

[Gabrielle947]

though I haven't seen Se7en, so maybe I can't comment)
Se7en is great,it's my favorite of Fincher,so yeah,you should watch it. :D

[honeykid]

Clint Eastwood
Million Dollar baby vs Unforgiven

Coppola
The Godfather vs The Rain maker
The Godfather Part II vs The Converstion
The Godfather Part III vs Appocalypse Now

Wells
Touch of Evil vs The Stranger (This is a shame, as The Stranger is a good film)

Fincher
Fight Club vs Panic Room

[Tyler1]

Clint Eastwood
A Perfect World

Coppola
Godfather Part II
Apocalypse Now

Wells
Citizen Kane vs F for Fake
Touch of Evil vs The Stranger
The Trial vs the lady from shanghai
Chimes of Midnight vs Mr.Akradin

Fincher
Curious Case of Benjiman Button vs Girl With The Dragon Tattoo
Fight Club vs Panic Room
The Social Network vs Zodiac
Seven vs The Game

[rauldc14]

Clint Eastwood
Play Misty For Me vs J. Edgar
Gran Torino vs Letter from Iwa Jima
Million Dollar baby vs Unforgiven
close for me, but everyone hates MDB
Mystic River vs The Rookie

Coppola
The Godfather vs The Rain maker
The Godfather Part II vs The Converstion
The Godfather Part III vs Appocalypse Now
The Outsiders vs Rumble Fish

Wells
Citizen Kane vs F for Fake
Touch of Evil vs The Stranger
The Trial vs the lady from shanghai
Chimes of Midnight vs Mr.Akradin

Fincher
Curious Case of Benjiman Button vs Girl With The Dragon Tattoo
Fight Club vs Panic Room
The Social Network vs Zodiac
Seven vs The Game

I've seen about 50% of these movies but I literally can only vote in 2 matchups

[honeykid]

I've seen about 50% of these movies but I literally can only vote in 2 matchups
And you voted incorrectly in at least 50% of those. :p:)

[donniedarko]

I've seen 1/3 of these but I can only vote in one…

[AKA23]

Play Misty For Me vs J. Edgar
Gran Torino vs Letter from Iwa Jima
Million Dollar baby vs Unforgiven
Mystic River vs The Rookie

The idea of this game is to choose which is the better film of these choices, right? I think I've done that. I do have a question about the last one, though. You've asked us to choose between "Mystic River," which is cited by many as one of the best films Eastwood has made, and "The Rookie," which is universally panned as one of his weakest efforts. The choice, to me, would seem to be obvious, and not one that many would disagree with, so I've got to wonder, why did you choose to match those two up? Do you happen to disagree with the viewpoint that "The Rookie" is a really weak film? Is it a favorite of yours, and you are wondering if other people may share that view? What is it that made you choose those two films? It was an interesting choice to me.

[honeykid]

Play Misty For Me vs J. Edgar
Gran Torino vs Letter from Iwa Jima
Million Dollar baby vs Unforgiven
Mystic River vs The Rookie

The idea of this game is to choose which is the better film of these choices, right?
Or your favourite. Personally, I always go with favourite. Picking the 'better' one is usually pretty obvious, as you pointed out with Mystic River and I would with Unforgiven... But you seem to've got that one wrong. ;)

[rauldc14]

And you voted incorrectly in at least 50% of those. :p:)


Yes, I know you have made hate on MDB. Don't be hatin'.

[genesis_pig]

Clint Eastwood
Play Misty For Me vs J. Edgar
Gran Torino vs Letter from Iwa Jima
Million Dollar baby vs Unforgiven
Mystic River vs The Rookie

Coppola
The Godfather vs The Rain maker
The Godfather Part II vs The Converstion
The Godfather Part III vs Appocalypse Now
The Outsiders vs Rumble Fish

Wells
Citizen Kane vs F for Fake
Touch of Evil vs The Stranger
The Trial vs The Lady from Shanghai
Chimes of Midnight vs Mr.Akradin

Fincher
Curious Case of Benjiman Button vs Girl With The Dragon Tattoo
Fight Club vs Panic Room
The Social Network vs Zodiac
Se7en vs The Game

[hoggy20]

Clint Eastwood
Play Misty For Me vs J. Edgar
Gran Torino vs Letter from Iwa Jima
Million Dollar baby vs Unforgiven
Mystic River vs The Rookie


Coppola
The Godfather vs The Rain maker
The Godfather Part II vs The Converstion
The Godfather Part III vs Appocalypse Now
The Outsiders vs Rumble Fish


Wells
Citizen Kane vs F for Fake
Touch of Evil vs The Stranger
The Trial vs the lady from shanghai
Chimes of Midnight vs Mr.Akradin

Fincher

Curious Case of Benjiman Button vs Girl With The Dragon Tattoo
Fight Club vs Panic Room
The Social Network vs Zodiac
Seven vs The Game

[Powderfinger]

Clint Eastwood
Play Misty For Me vs J. Edgar
Gran Torino vs Letter from Iwa Jima
Million Dollar baby vs Unforgiven
Mystic River vs The Rookie

Coppola
The Godfather vs The Rain maker
The Godfather Part II vs The Converstion
The Godfather Part III vs Appocalypse Now
The Outsiders vs Rumble Fish

Wells
Citizen Kane vs F for Fake
Touch of Evil vs The Stranger
The Trial vs the lady from shanghai
Chimes of Midnight vs Mr.Akradin

Fincher
Curious Case of Benjiman Button vs Girl With The Dragon Tattoo
Fight Club vs Panic Room
The Social Network vs Zodiac
Seven vs The Game

[donniedarko]

Eastwood
Play Misty for Me- 6 J. Edgar-0
Gran Torino-5. Letters from iwa Jima-2
Million Dollar Baby-3. Unforgiven- 6
Mystic River-6. The Rookie-1

Coppola
Godfather- 7. Rain maker-0
Godfather part II- 8. The Conversation-1
Godfather Part III- 0. Appocalypse Now-10
Outsiders-2 Rumble fish-2. (Rumble Fish takes it on RT scorecards)

Wells
Citizen Kane- 4. F for Fake- 2
Touch of Evil- 5 The Stranger-0
The Trial-2. Lady from Shanghai-2 (The Trial wins on RT)
Chimes of Midnight- 2. Mr.Akradin- 0

Fincher
Curious Case of Benjiman Button-2. Girl With the Dragon Tattoo- 6
Fight Club- 8. Panic Room-1
Social Network- 3. Zodiac-6
se7en- 8. The Game-0

Round 2 will be up shortly