MoFo Battle Royale Sweet Sixteen: The Joker vs. The Crow

[Harry Lime]

http://i705.photobucket.com/albums/ww56/harrylime49/TheJoker.jpg
The Joker (Batman, The Dark Knight)

vs.

http://i705.photobucket.com/albums/ww56/harrylime49/TheCrow.jpg
Eric Draven (The Crow)

[Harry Lime]

http://i705.photobucket.com/albums/ww56/harrylime49/tourney3.jpg

Updated

[TheUsualSuspect]

I'm gonna hold off on this one....

[rice1245]

the crow, i have an undying love for him =\

[zedlen]

This is tough since its really 3 characters your choosing between, since Nicholson's Joker and Ledger's were so different.

[Harry Lime]

This is tough since its really 3 characters your choosing between, since Nicholson's Joker and Ledger's were so different.

Both, although different, were very good.

[zedlen]

Both, although different, were very good.

Definitely but shouldnt we decide which Joker we are comparing ?

I'd choose Ledger's Joker over The Crow but not Nicholsons.

[Iroquois]

http://www.geocities.com/magicvoice3000/images/croooow.gif

[MovieMan8877445]

Even though the Joker beat out Sundance, I'm still going to vote for him.

[Harry Lime]

I think we would have to consider both Jokers, it was to nominate a movie character, not an actor's portrayal of a character. Although I remember when this first started with the nominations I asked Lennon to specify which Punisher he was nominating. I suppose we would have to ask TheUsualSuspect to clarify this for us as he nominated The Joker. Suspect, it's up to you, all or one?

[MovieMan8877445]

Heath Ledger
Jack Nicholsen
Cesar Romero.

[Harry Lime]

True, there were more than two. Thank you MovieMan.

[TheUsualSuspect]

Well, I posted a picture of Ledger, so I'll go with him.

(the better performance too)

[Harry Lime]

So it's official, Ledger Joker it is.

[zedlen]

Good call Movie Man

[mack]

i really hope the crow takes this one home.

[n3wt]

The Joker as he is a bad ass :yup:

But I would love to see The Crow Vs The Joker movie, but it would have to have both Brandon and Heath as thier respectable charactors, its a dam shame that both these actors died so young :yup:

[Pedz]

Can we at least put The Crow down as Eric Draven, unless we are voting on the bird itself?

[Justin]

The Joker

[Iroquois]

Can we at least put The Crow down as Eric Draven, unless we are voting on the bird itself?

It's obviously meant to be Eric Draven (unless you want to count the various Crows from the sequels, but who would?)

[n3wt]

http://www.themechanism.com/images/crow_heads.jpg

[Powdered Water]

Bummer. I was hoping this would be a lot closer. The Crow (or Eric Draven for you pedantic types) is his own leading character, while The Joker who is an awesome supporting character, is still just that... a supporting character. Without Batman there would be no Joker. The Crow came back from the grave for cryin' out loud!

[TheUsualSuspect]

I voted Crow just because he's the underdog and I want this one to be close.

[n3wt]

I think both charactors are great but I choose The Joker to win this :yup: