Live Action Musical Movie Hall of Fame

→ in
Tools    
Page 1 of 37
12Last »




Citizen Rules's Avatar
Profile
Posts
Message
Noir Time
02-24-17


Live Action Musical Movie Hof

Members Reviews:

 Swing Time
Citizen Rules
Gideon
Edarsenal
Nestorio_Miklos
Thursday Next
Gbgoodies
Clazor
SilentVamp

Mary Poppins
Nestorio_Miklos
Gideon
Gideon
Citizen Rules
Thursday Next
Clazor
SilentVamp
Gbgoodies
Pussy Galore
Edarsenal

 1776
Gideon
Citizen Rules
Nestorio_Miklos
Thursday Next
Clazor
Gbgoodies
SilentVamp
Edarsenal

The Pajama Game
Gideon
Citizen Rules
Nestorio_Miklos
Thursday Next
Edarsenal
SilentVamp
Pussy Galore
Clazor

West Side Story
Gideon
Pussy Galore
Nestorio_Miklos
Citizen Rules
Clazor
Gbgoodies
Edarsenal
Silent Vamp

 Godspell
Gideon
Nestorio_Miklos
Thursday Next
Citizen Rules
Edarsenal
SilentVamp
Clazor
Gbgoodies

Meet Me In St. Louis
Gideon
Camo (honorary member)
Nestorio_Miklos
Thursday Next
Gbgoodies
Citizen Rules
Pussy Galore
Silent Vamp
Edarsenal
Clazor

Chitty Chitty Bang Bang
Gideon
Edarsenal
Thursday Next
Nestorio_Miklos
SilentVamp
Gbgoodies
Clazor

Les Demoiselles de Rochefort
The Young Girls of Rochefort (English title)
Gideon
Thursday Next
Citizen Rules
Silent Vamp
Nestorio_Miklos
Edarsenal
Clazor
Gbgoodies




Members:

 Citizen Rules - List Received

SilentVamp - List Received
Gbgoodies List Received

Edarsenal- List Received

Nestorio_Miklos - List Received

Clazor- List Received

 Thursday Next - List Received

Pussy Galore - List Received

Gideon - List Received

Shopkeepertriuph - Dropped Out

Come on in and join the fun


Me and SilentVamp have come up with a Hall of Fame (Hof) idea for Twin Musical Hofs. You can join one or the other, or both of the Hofs.


Each has a different set of movie nomination guidelines which are designed to compliment each other and give members different choices. Link to SilentVamp's: Musical Artist Movie Hall of Fame




Eligibility: For my Hof, movies under 220 minutes, that are live action and are traditional musicals.



What's a Traditional Musical
Movies where the characters are actually singing several or more songs, (not just singing a song on stage like a band or music played in the background)....but actually breaking into song at a drop of a hat If you have questions PM me.



Procedure:
Everyone watches all the nominated movies and we discuss them in this thread. There might be 6 to 12 movies and the length of this Hof will be approximately 2 months which gives plenty of time to watch the movies. You need to write at least a short paragraph about your thoughts on each movie, after you watch it.



Please don't join if you don't intend to watch all the films and discuss them. Members who don't finish will have their movie nomination disqualified from the Hof.











Deadline is June 1st......................
















...
Attachments
Click image for larger version Name: Live Action Musical Hof.jpg Views: 450 Size: 155.0 KB ID: 40577  
Last edited by Citizen Rules; 01-20-18 at 02:06 PM.



Citizen Rules's Avatar
Profile
Posts
Message
Noir Time
02-24-17
The Movie Nominations for the Musical Live Action Hof


Meet Me in St Louis (Vincente Minnelli, 1944)
Nominated by Citizen Rules



1776 (Peter Hunt, 1972)
Nominated by SilentVamp



Godspell (David Greene, 1973)
Nominated by Edarsenal



Swing Time (George Stevens, 1936)
Nominated by Nestorio_Miklos



Chitty Chitty Bang Bang (Ken Hughes, 1968)
Nominated by Clazor



West Side Story (Robert Wise, 1961)
Nominated by Thursday Next



The Pajama Game (George Abbott, Stanley Donen, 1957)
Nominated by Gbgoodies



Les Demoiselles de Rochefort (Jacques Demy, 1967)
The Young Girls of Rochefort (English title)
Nominated by Pussy Galore



Mary Poppins (Robert Stevenson 1964)
Nominated be Gideon


Please check for the availability of these movies and let me know if you have difficulties finding any of them. I'm happy to help people find them online

Any questions, just ask, I love questions
Attachments
Click image for larger version Name: 1776.jpg Views: 467 Size: 227.8 KB ID: 30155   Click image for larger version Name: Chitty Chitty Bang Bang.jpg Views: 459 Size: 301.4 KB ID: 30156   Click image for larger version Name: Godspell.jpg Views: 462 Size: 233.8 KB ID: 30157   Click image for larger version Name: Mary Poppins.jpg Views: 474 Size: 202.1 KB ID: 30158   Click image for larger version Name: Meet Me In St Louis.jpg Views: 564 Size: 277.9 KB ID: 30159  

Click image for larger version Name: Swing Time.jpg Views: 539 Size: 256.6 KB ID: 30160   Click image for larger version Name: The Pajama Game.jpg Views: 486 Size: 212.0 KB ID: 30161   Click image for larger version Name: The Young Girls of Rocherfort.jpg Views: 540 Size: 141.2 KB ID: 30162   Click image for larger version Name: West Side Story.jpg Views: 471 Size: 164.0 KB ID: 30163  
Last edited by Citizen Rules; 07-11-20 at 10:27 PM.



edarsenal's Avatar
Profile
Posts
Message
Women will be your undoing, Pépé
02-24-17
as previously stated, I'm in and sending my nomination
__________________
What I actually said to win MovieGal's heart:
- I might not be a real King of Kinkiness, but I make good pancakes
~Mr Minio



Citizen Rules's Avatar
Profile
Posts
Message
Noir Time
02-25-17
Originally Posted by edarsenal
as previously stated, I'm in and sending my nomination
Originally Posted by gbgoodies
I'm in. I'll send my nomination tomorrow night.
Originally Posted by ShopkeeperTriumph
I'm in. I have a few musicals I love in mind, give me a bit to ponder which one I want to make you guys watch.
Thanks guys for joining! There's still plenty of room at the party! Do we have any more musical movie fans?



Citizen Rules's Avatar
Profile
Posts
Message
Noir Time
02-25-17
We have a new member Nestorio_Miklos joining us! Glad to have you aboard! and he's choose a very cool movie too.

All Mofos, new or old are welcomed, even if you just joined the site you are welcomed.
Questions? Post them or PM me, I'm happy to answer them...that's my job as a host



Clazor's Avatar
Profile
Posts
Message
Nothing good comes from staying with normal people
02-25-17
Join one, join all. Sign me up CR. Will send a nomination after checking up on a few different ones I'm considering.
__________________
Why not just kill them? I'll do it! I'll run up to Paris - bam, bam, bam, bam. I'm back before week's end. We spend the treasure. How is this a bad plan?



Clazor's Avatar
Profile
Posts
Message
Nothing good comes from staying with normal people
02-25-17
Originally Posted by edarsenal
welcome shop!

hey, clazor! Pretty curious to see what ya nominate!
Was jumping between a few different choices. Aside from the one I chose in the end, I considered Oliver!, Bedknobs and broomsticks and Repo! The genetic Opera. That last one I saw for the sci-fi countdown and was blown away by the set design as well as the totally over the top antagonists.



ShopkeeperTriumph's Avatar
Profile
Posts
Message
Really doe, like really doe
02-25-17
I remember loving Repo when it came out, it was really popular among my friend group. That being said, that was probably 7-8 years ago, so who knows if I'd still like it.



Clazor's Avatar
Profile
Posts
Message
Nothing good comes from staying with normal people
02-25-17
As far as the music went I wasn't blown away, but the climax at the theatre has the best performed number I think.



edarsenal's Avatar
Profile
Posts
Message
Women will be your undoing, Pépé
02-25-17
haven't seen the repo musical but heard a lot of good things about it
and I was seriously considering Oliver! as well lol. Also thought about Chitty Chitty Bang Bang too before going with my nom
Haven't seen Bedknobs since I was a kid - should rewatch that some time.

Page 1 of 37
12Last »