The first time I noticed Baruchel was in
"Undeclared" (2001-2002), Judd Apatow's college-set quickly-canceled follow-up to the quickly-canceled high school-set
"Freaks & Geeks". It wasn't quite as rich and filled with potential as
"F&G", but it was a good show. Jay was the main character in that ensemble and carried it well, despite being only twenty. Not too long after
"Undeclared" was unrenewed, he showed up in that highlighted supporting role in Eastwood's Oscar-winner
Million Dollar Baby (2003) as the mentally-challenged but self-confident would-be boxer "Danger" Barch.
He got to star in the indie
I'm Reed Fish (2006) but had his most noticeable roles in support of Apatow's
Knocked Up (2007), the Michael Cera vehicle
Nick & Norah's Infinite Playlist (2008) and Ben Stiller's
Tropic Thunder (2008). Now he's starring in mainstream efforts like the desperately-wannabe-Apatow knock-off
She's Out of My League (2010) and the
dreadful-looking Disney project
Sorcerer's Apprentice (2010) alongside Nic Cage at his most embarrassing. Lending his voice to the main character in the surprise smash hit and critical darling
How to Train Your Dragon (2010) has probably done the most for his career this year, especially if DreamWorks decides to adapt more of the books into 3D animated extravaganzas.
He's a decent young everyman presence on screen for me. He hasn't exhibited much range, nor do I suspect he's capable of a whole lot at this point. I'm sure he only gets the scripts that Michael Cera, Jesse Eisenberg and Shia LaBeouf have already turned down (he may be still be half a thought ahead of Christopher "McLovin'"Mintz-Plasse for most casting directors), but he's got the potential to hang around for a while. Especially if he doesn't fall into making more movies with the likes of Jerry Bruckheimer and instead can find quirkier and smaller material. In that males under-30 pecking order, I like Baruchel less than both Eisenberg or Cera, but a good deal more than LaBeouf and eons ahead of Edward the vampire or Jacob the werewolf.