Originally Posted by Sedai
I am a fan of Ultimate as well, but I feel that book is nowhere as deep (emotionally) as Morrison's stuff. Bendis is tremendous talent, but I get the feeling he likes to do more obscure stuff....I read New X-men to experience the wild creativity of Morrison, I like the character set better (HUGE white queen fan) and mind bending concepts....
....Re: Part 3 of Planet X. This has to be some of the best characterization I have ever read in a comic book, or any book for that matter. After initial fear that I would get another lame-ass Wolvie-Jean love triangle teen scene, I was treated to heartfelt, mature, respectable conversation between two adults. I am a 32 year-old man who was moved to misty eyes by an x-men comic book. Grant Morrison is so in touch with this material right now, and is taking it in such a fresh direction, that I am reading X-men stories that are totally original for the first time since I can remember (been reading x-men since the 70s). Basically I feel that issue is one of the best X-men comics ever.That said I was extremely disappointed when Morrison reneged on keeping Magneto dead...
I totally agree with your thoughts on Grant Morrison's fresh writing and characterization. I don't think anyone has been able to embrace Wolverine and write him so appropriately as Morrison has in New X-Men; and I especially love the strong separation he creates between character and character (ie: Emma Frost is written decidedly different than, say, Beast)
and between character classes (ie: the younger students are written decidedly different than the actual X-Men).
I also agree with your assessment of Bendis' work on Ultimate X-Men. Primarily, Bendis prefers crime stories (made evident with his
Powers story, and
aka Goldfish, and so it seemed like he was reaching a little with
New Mutants. He is still a fantastic writer, one of the best, and certainly a favorite of mine.
The Xorn/Magneto thing bugged me as well, particularly because I thought Xorn was a very compelling character. I never thought a "new" X-Man could be placed on the team with any level of security, but Morrison pulled it off with Xorn. The fact that Magneto was "dead" also proved quite interesting, since he was somewhat immortalized and regarded as a hero. That could have been taken down a very interesting road, and sometimes I wonder if Morrison was under some pressure to ressurrect Magneto and bring his name back out. If that was the case, then it could have been done much later (and not done through Xorn). Imagine what kind of character Morrison would have had if Magneto returned after all of this "immortalized" characterization, and what kind of amazing villain he would have been.