The MoFo Top Comic Book & Graphic Novel Movies Countdown

Sexy has ruined what could have been a marginally passable list

Not to worry wint... we start the Top 40 on Wednesday... the next 8 are interesting though, will raise a few eyebrows.

__________________

I'm very proud of myself.

Acceptable. Who else voted for Wild Things?

The other 4 were sarah f, Godoggo, Holden, and lines

We're counting children's books as comics?

Linespalsy was the first to vote for Wild Things, and I said no to it initially... then he asked me to check on it.


After an hour of research, I found that Picture Books are part of the same media as Comics and Graphic Novels.
This was explained in the original thread after lines and I had a PM session between us.

SC is the Armond White of movie forums. Ha.

I don't read rules come on!!!

Nobody does.


I had most people not including dates on the films to decipher between originals and retakes (things like The Punisher and The Punisher) and had to keep asking people which one of the films they were voting for.


Meant overall, I had to research every film that was entered on its first time, to get the dates.

Yes! Hellboy II: The Golden Army was #10 on my list. The only reason it's so low is because I wanted to separate it and Hellboy, which I put much higher.

Love the Hellboy movies.

American Splendor is the 5th movie from my list to appear; I had it at #24.

I read the rules and went through the lists three times and still managed to miss some good stuff. I would have voted for Hugo. I did vote for American Splendor. The first movie I really noticed Giamatti in and he has become one of my faves. Love that movie.

__________________
Letterboxd

Hugo counted? DAMMIT! I should have voted for it!

I blame myself.

__________________
Fear and Loathing in MoFo... The Gunslinger 45's Top 50 Favorite Films

In the 10 Ring: Gunslinger45's reviews

Yet another one from my list! American Splendor. At #12.

ON MY LIST
Conan the Destroyer -- # 2
Batman & Robin -- # 4
Spider-Man 3 -- #7
Addams Family Values -- # 8
The Addams Family -- # 9
American Splendor -- # 12
Tank Girl -- # 17
X-Men: The Last Stand -- # 18
X-Men Origins: Wolverine -- # 19
The Mask -- # 20
Howard the Duck -- # 24

And I DESPISE Where The Wild Things Are.

One of the worst movie theater viewing experiences I have ever had.

A total annoying sap fest.

Sexy and his perception again.

__________________
It's what you learn after you know it all that counts. - John Wooden
My IMDb page

Well, Armond and I are possibly the only two people on Earth that liked Jack and Jill.

Armond White's review of Jack and Jill.

I voted for both Hugo and American Splendor. Great films.


MY LIST

#5 - Only Yesterday
#6 - Porco Rosso
#13 - The Addams Family
#17 - Hugo
#20 - Tekkonkinkreet
#21 - Dick Tracy
#22 - American Splendor
#23 - The Lone Wolf and Cub: Sword of Vengeance

I've hardly seen any of the films on this list, but Hugo Is Great

__________________